Premium Sponsor


Featured Sponsor


Our Sponsors


Ad Networks

Advertise Liberally

Buy an ad on all of the top liberal blogs with just one click.

Site Stats

IL-SEN 2010: Who will replace Obama?

by: safi

Sun Oct 26, 2008 at 3:15 PM EDT


There doing this same thread at Daily Kos and I disagree with some of brownsox'a analysis but its a good start.

One of the things you have to keep in mind, is that unless he appoints himself he's probably facing a stiff primary opponent. I know a little bit about Illinois politics, so here's some of the names who will be tossed around:

safi :: IL-SEN 2010: Who will replace Obama?
1. Blagojevich: I don't think its out of the realm of possibility that Blago appoints himself. Having said that, it would be incredibly stupid on his part to do so. He's not particularly popular in Illinois and this move would make him look pretty bad.
Odds: 50-1

2. Lisa Madigan: This is almost as bad as him appointing himself. This would look like a purely political move, a complete quid pro quo. The worst part is that while Madigan would be his toughest primary opponent both Dan Hymes and Alexi Giannoulas could still knock him off. (This same logic applies to choosing Himes and Giannoulas as well)
Odds: 35-1

3. Jan Schakowsky: This move would please a lot of prgoressives and be heralded around these parts. But, she's got some baggage due to her husband and there's another factor that I'll lay out later as to why I don't think she'll be the choice.
Odds: 20-1

4. Jesse White: This is the move that on paper looks perfect. Historic African-American leader who is universally respected by Republicans and Democrats in Illinois, alike. The problem with this pick is that White is 74 years old and would be 76 on election day 2010. Meaning, he probably doesn't run for re-election and an open Senate seat in Illinois could get very crowded and very ugly.
Odds: 15-1

5. Jesse Jackson Jr.-This is who I think it will be. My main disagreement with brownsox's analysis is that he didn't include the role race will play in this decision. Their is only 1 African-American senator right now and if he wins the presidency and is replaced by a white person, Blago could alienate a large slice of the Democratic electorate. This issue would be compounded by the fact that, other than Erik Fleming against Thad Cochoran, there are no African-Americans running for US Senate this cycle. That means the 09-10 Congress will ahve no African-American represenation. If you don't think Blago's primary opponent will use that to his advantage, your out of your mind. The one concern about Jesse Jackson Jr. is his dad and the view that this could make him unelectable statewide, but he's not his dad.

Poll
Who will Obama's replacement
Rod Blagojevich
Lisa Madigan
Jan Schakowsky
Jesse White
Jesse Jackson Jr.
Other

Results

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Jackson Jr.
I really don't know much about the guy.  He sounds like a solid progressive.  Please tell me he's not the race-baiter his dad is.  Otherwise he'll have a very tough re-election race to the Senate.

I despise Jessie Jackson Jr.
Why? This


That was disgusting
But there were a lot of unfortunate and very unfair things said by both Obama and Clinton people during the primaries in the heat of the moment.  It seems like everyone has made amends since those primaries.  If tht's the worst thing Jackson Jr. has said I'm not going to hold it against him TOO much.

[ Parent ]
If given the choice between him and a Republican
I would most likely vote for him. But he sure wouldn't get a primary vote from me, and I would never give him a nickel.

It's a good thing I don't live in Illinois.

Of this things said during the primary, that's in the top five worst IMO.  


[ Parent ]
I definitely disagree
With that. I don't think that was one of the top 20 worst things said during the primary.

[ Parent ]
it won't be Schakowsky
she's too liberal, got too much baggage, and too old to really get in there for 3 or 4 terms and build seniority for the state.

my money is on Madigan -- it gets rid of his most threatening primary challenger, adds a woman to the Senate (which will help with female voters), and perhaps gets him the support of Lisa's father for the primary.


I've seen Duckworth's name batted around
That would be an interesting choice.

we should be able to do better
Illinois should elect just about any democrat.  

[ Parent ]
duckworth or someone out of the box
i prefer none of those names mention.

no chance in heck that blago names madigan to the seat. although there is an excellent chance she is the next U.S. Attorney.

I would think it could be White just so that he could step down in two years and we would have a completely open primary.


None of the Above....
Go with Tammy Duckworth.  She has a great personal story, a history of competitiveness in unfriendly partisan turf, and is thus far unstained by Illinois politics.

She sounds moderate
She would have been good for the 6th district, but probably not statewide in IL.  We should accept nothing less than a rock solid progressive in IL.

[ Parent ]
Duckworth
Could Duckworth possibly be on the shortlist as Obama's Secretary of Vet. Affairs?  I know her name is making the rounds as his possible replacement, but I was curious if she had a shot at the Cabinet.

[ Parent ]
She's tailor-made for that job
She definately should be on the short-list.  

[ Parent ]
Duckworth would be an ace choice for VA Sec.
Senate? Not so much.

[ Parent ]
that's the prediction
of Bleeding Heartland diarist American007:

http://www.bleedingheartland.c...


[ Parent ]
In addition to
The comments made by others, she's got virtually no electoral experience. A failed congressional run and less than 2 years in a state cabinet post. Put her in a race against someone like Mark Kirk, and I'm just not sure.

[ Parent ]
Gag.
Anyone with the name Jesse Jackson is toxic, even in the liberal state of IL.

I doubt the seat, even in Jackson's hands, would switch to Republican but just the fact that he would be in the caucus is not helpful to us. Imagine Jeb Bush being elected as the Junior Senator from Florida. It just invites the spectre of Bush back into the national scene -- the last thing the R's would ever want to do.


[ Parent ]
Jeb is a little different story
For the most part he has avoided the negative effects of the Bush name here in FL.  I never quite understood his popularity here, but he always remained in the high 50's to 60's in job approval.  He would have given Bill Nelson a real challenge had he run for Senate in 2006.  


[ Parent ]
His Comments in His 2003 Inaugural....
....about "his dream of emptying all the state buildings surrounding him of workers" was among the scariest words I've ever heard uttered by a politician.

[ Parent ]
Exactly
The guy is just as nutty as his brother, and governed as a far-right conservative.  Jeb was so far-right he makes Governor Crist look like a liberal.  I have no idea how he maintained approvals so high his entire reign as Governor.

[ Parent ]
Simply
Not true. Those who are familiar with Illinois politics know that Jackson has carved his own legacy and while it is a very progressive legacy, its also one that has gotten him nothing but praise from those on all sides of the political aisle.

[ Parent ]
good diary on this at Bleeding Heartland
I say Jackson
Remember the pressure that's going to be on Blagojevich to appoint an African-American, considering that, should Obama resign to take the Presidency, there would be no blacks in the Senate.

I'm assuming Madigan isn't black, so I'm guessing Jackson.

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.


Jackson Jr.
Am I the only one here a little worried at the thought of Jesse Jackson's son running for re-election after being appointed to the Senate?  I'm as liberal as it gets and I cannot stand Jackson Sr.  Granted, I'm sure his son is a decent guy and sounds like a solid progressive, but I fear in a neutral or unfavorable democratic year Jackson Jr. would lose to a moderate republican just on the basis of his last name.

He's carved out
A legacy in Illinois very seperate from his father. Like I said, no one in the political world regardless of their political affiliation has a bad thing to say about the guy.

To ease some of your fears think about this, Obama made him one of his national co-chairs and one of his most high profile surrogates. Granted this is a largely ceremonial job, but if Obama were concerned that Jackson Jr. and his name would be a detriment to him, do you really think he would place him in such a high profile position?


[ Parent ]
Thanks for the info
I had a feeling that was the case if he he is being seriously considering for a Senate appointment.

[ Parent ]
Jr. has a somewhat frosty relationship
with Sr. (remember JJ Sr.'s remarks on Fox? He completely repudiated him on that.)

[ Parent ]
You're Wrong on Jesse White's Age
Your facts are wrong.  You incorrectly added 10 years to Jesse White's age; however, according to published reports, he is not interested in this appointment.

Thanks for
Catching that. Corrected and done.

[ Parent ]

Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Follow Us

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

SSP Race Ratings

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox