Election Night Results Wrapup

The main event last night was Rep. Alan Mollohan‘s slightly surprising loss in the Dem primary in WV-01 to state Sen. Mike Oliverio. Maybe not that surprising, given Mollohan’s seeming lack of preparation (the guy hasn’t had a competitive primary in literally two decades) and weak fundraising and GOTV organizing. Compounding that: increased attention on Mollohan’s ethics woes (although Mollohan had formally been cleared, that didn’t keep the cloud from going away, or Oliverio from exploiting that), as well as, of course, the generalized anti-incumbent anti-Washington sentiment in both parties, a residual of voter anger over the crappy economy.

The DCCC was notably cool to Oliverio in their post-election statement, as there seems to some wait-and-see regarding how Oliverio clarifies his anti-Nancy Pelosi comments as they size him up. Still, even with their apparent distate for Oliverio, that’s probably part of a bigger ambivalence on their part (paralleled by some NRCC disappointment), as it’s quite possible that Oliverio may perform better in November than Mollohan would have, being a “fresh face” free of the taint of incumbency, and free of Mollohan’s ethical baggage and his tough pro-HCR vote (I don’t think HCR in itself is as much of anchor in this district as the Beltway media might have you believe, but the abortion angle on HCR seemed to be a liability, compounded by the Susan B. Anthony List’s involvement in the race).

And while conservative Dem Mollohan was no prize overall, it’s worth noting that he was about as liberal a guy as we were going to get in this R+9 district; the PVI/Vote Index has him as 2008’s 11th most overperforming Democrat according to National Journal scores (consistent with Nate Silver‘s math, who finds him 8th most valuable Democrat). Of course, if Oliverio goes on to win in November and moves the ball a few paces to the right, even he’ll probably still be overperforming the district’s lean; while most of what came out of Oliverio’s mouth during the campaign was pretty alarming, he at least has a solid pro-labor record, in the form of strong AFL-CIO ratings.

In the GOP primary, ex-state Rep. and former state GOP chair David McKinley pulled out a decent victory, with 35% of the vote (to 27% for Mac Warner and 21% for Sarah Minear); he’ll face Oliverio. Anti-incumbent sentiments were on display in the WV-03 and NE-02 primaries, where Dem Nick Rahall and GOPer Lee Terry pulled in only 67% and 63% respectively against small-time opponents. Rahall will face off in November against ex-Dem ex-state Supreme Court Justice (and BFF of Massey Energy head Don Blankenship) Spike Maynard, who prevailed over a fractured GOP field with only 30%. Finally a couple state legislative results: the GOP held Scott Brown’s former Massachusetts state Senate seat in the outer reaches of Boston’s suburbs, with state Rep. Dennis Richard Ross winning, while in Georgia, Jason Carter, the grandson of Jimmy Carter, is the newest member of the state Senate after holding a safely-Dem district in DeKalb County.