MI-Gov: Tight Race in Dem Primary, But Dems Lag in General

PPP (5/25-27, Michigan voters, likely voters in primary):

Virg Bernero (D): 26

Andy Dillon (D): 23

Undecided: 51

(MoE: ±5.5%)

Rick Snyder (R): 20

Peter Hoekstra (R): 19

Mike Cox(R): 17

Mike Bouchard (R): 15

Tom George (R): 9

Undecided: 20

(MoE: ±5.1%)

Virg Bernero (D): 28

Rick Snyder (R): 44

Undecided: 28

Virg Bernero (D): 34

Peter Hoekstra (R): 41

Undecided: 25

Virg Bernero (D): 36

Mike Cox (R): 38

Undecided: 27

Virg Bernero (D): 34

Mike Bouchard (R): 39

Undecided: 27

Virg Bernero (D): 31

Tom George (R): 30

Undecided: 39

Andy Dillon (D): 26

Rick Snyder (R): 46

Undecided: 28

Andy Dillon (D): 32

Peter Hoekstra (R): 41

Undecided: 27

Andy Dillon (D): 32

Mike Cox (R): 40

Undecided: 27

Andy Dillon (D): 29

Mike Bouchard (R): 38

Undecided: 33

Andy Dillon (D): 31

Tom George (R): 32

Undecided: 38

(MoE: ±3.3%)

PPP takes its first look at Michigan (whose primary isn’t until August 3); the general results don’t look that good for Democrats, but a lot of that problem is name-recognition-related. That can be seen in the high number of undecideds in the Dem primary, as well as low knowns for both state House speaker Andy Dillon (9/20) and Lansing mayor Virg Bernero (11/12). Of course, that can also be because Jennifer Granholm, at 29/61, is an anvil around any Dem’s neck. Note that Dillon’s worse favorables seem to have him polling a little worse than Bernero vis-a-vis the Republicans; they’re both in the thick of things with the lesser GOPers but in deep trouble if moderate Rick Synder survives the primary.

This is the first poll to give Bernero a lead in the Dem primary, although that’s largely because Alma Wheeler Smith’s recent dropout lets him consolidate the liberal vote. Bernero dominates among liberals, leading 38-15 there; the reason he isn’t up further is that Dillon, predictably, leads among moderates and conservatives. The GOP primary could be anyone’s game: while other pollsters have seen him surge, PPP is the first pollster to give Rick Snyder an outright lead, thanks to his dominance (relatively-speaking, given the crowd) among the state’s moderates.

EPIC-MRA for Detroit Free Press (5/22-26, likely voters, 3/28-31 in parentheses):

Andy Dillon (D): 29 (22)

Virg Bernero (D): 23 (15)

Alma Wheeler Smith (D): NA (11)

Undecided: 48 (42)

(MoE: ±>4%)

Peter Hoekstra (R): 30 (27)

Mike Cox(R): 18 (21)

Rick Snyder (R): 17 (15)

Mike Bouchard (R): 16 (13)

Tom George (R): 2 (3)

Undecided: 17 (18)

(MoE: ±>4%)

Virg Bernero (D): 28 (26)

Rick Snyder (R): 51 (42)

Undecided: 21 (32)

Virg Bernero (D): 24 (29)

Peter Hoekstra (R): 47 (42)

Undecided: 19 (29)

Virg Bernero (D): 36 (30)

Mike Cox (R): 46 (44)

Undecided: 18 (26)

Virg Bernero (D): 32 (NA)

Mike Bouchard (R): 48 (NA)

Undecided: 20 (NA)

Andy Dillon (D): 31 (30)

Rick Snyder (R): 50 (42)

Undecided: 19 (28)

Andy Dillon (D): 35 (33)

Peter Hoekstra (R): 47 (40)

Undecided: 18 (27)

Andy Dillon (D): 37 (34)

Mike Cox (R): 46 (43)

Undecided: 17 (23)

Andy Dillon (D): 33 (NA)

Mike Bouchard (R): 49 (NA)

Undecided: 18 (NA)

(MoE: ±4%)

EPIC-MRA, which polls this race most months, finds different outcomes, although with numbers in pretty much the same range as PPP: they have Dillon with a small lead in the Dem primary, and Hoekstra the top contender in the GOP primary. They also find bigger leads for the Republicans in the general; compared with two months ago, it looks a fair number of undecideds have moved in the Republican direction. One thing’s very consistent with PPP, though: they also find that Rick Snyder is not just one tough nerd, but also the toughest opponent for either Democrat come November.

46 thoughts on “MI-Gov: Tight Race in Dem Primary, But Dems Lag in General”

  1. Do you still see the MI-Gov race at this stage being in the “Tossup” category?  Based on this data, plus the fact that Granholm is unpopular, I’m not banking to much faith on the Dems retaining this seat.  I’m wondering if this race should be “Lean R” at this stage of the game.

  2. Is going to win the primaries.  Almost all the winning outcomes so far this primary season has been for the most liberal candidate.  The conservadems (most notably the anti-HCR crowd) have been getting pounded in election after election, state after state.  Bernero’s deficit in the general is mostly due to name recognition as well.  

    True, the republicans should be feeling pretty good about their chances because of Granholm’s suckiness, but Michigan is a blue state through and through.  Even in this environment, they are going to have to work hard to win.

  3. I don’t buy it. I mean, I’m sure the polls are accurate, and Rick Snyder is leading, but he’s also been running ads for a while now, and was the first one on the air. I really think it’s nothing but name recognition, and he’ll fade when the primaries and/or general heat up.

    (Full disclosure: I, too, self-identify as a nerd. Frankly, I think my nerd credentials beat his. And I don’t think “One tough nerd– I ran Gateway!” beats a populist message like the one Virg Bernero could put together.)

    The saddest part, though, is that no one except, well, the politics nerds recognize Dillon or Bernero. I think Bernero has a lot of potential, but I don’t think either of them are the leadership Michigan needs right now.

  4. I was impressed when I saw him interviewed on CNN (I believe it was). Have any of you seen how he performs in debates? I’m wondering if that could turn the election campaign.

Comments are closed.