What Will the Palin Effect Downballot Be?

Charlie Cook assesses dueling theories:

But what does that mean for races down the ballot? In part the answer depends on whether you believed that Republicans had a turnout problem before Palin was chosen. There are two schools of thought. The first is that although many Republicans were not excited about McCain, a longtime maverick and, yes, irritant to the GOP establishment, the party’s voters would have supported him anyway. They might not have run to the polls, but they would have voted. This theory posits that these voters simply feel better now about a vote they would have cast anyway.

The second theory is that if McCain had not added Palin or someone else capable of revving up the GOP base, quite a few Republicans wouldn’t have voted. A moderate case of sniffles, an unusually busy first-Tuesday-after-the-first-Monday-in-November, or any number of other excuses might well have been seized upon. And these Republicans would simply not have felt strongly enough about their support for McCain to persevere and vote. Under this theory, Palin really helps unless her standing is damaged.

Where Palin may not be able to help is among what some Bush campaign strategists in 2004 called “unreliable Republicans,” those who would vote Republican but have a history of not showing up on Election Day. These are people who have to be identified and hounded with phone calls and visits to their homes to remind them that, yes, this is Election Day and they are expected to vote. McCain has neither the money nor the organizational ability to match the get-out-the-vote efforts of President Bush’s 2004 campaign or Obama’s current effort.

So perhaps Palin is an asset but not quite a savior. For down-ballot GOP candidates who need all of the turnout assistance they can get, she will help some — but probably not enough unless they were already within shouting distance of victory. Republicans won’t have the masterful vote-generating machine they’ve grown accustomed to, but they are better off with Palin near the top of their ticket.

In other words, Cook says, to believe there will be a sizable Palin effect downballot, you’d have to think that at least some portion of the hardcore fundie base now going ga-ga over the GOP VP nominee would have otherwise stayed home had Palin not been named to the ticket. Otherwise, Palin is just revving up people who would have voted anyway, albeit unenthusiastically.

Personally, I think at least some Republicans who weren’t going to bother with this election are now going to show up, which is more or less what Cook concludes, since he thinks Palin “will help some.” But the reigning pessimist in me thinks the effect may be bigger than Cook imagines. What do you think?

10 thoughts on “What Will the Palin Effect Downballot Be?”

  1. We are already starting to see it take shape in the generic congressional ballot polls taken in the last few weeks.

    http://www.realclearpolitics.c

    I know that in the R2K/DKos trackers over the last four days, our lead has been 6,6,6, and 7 points.  

    Clearly, numbers have moved.  Now, maybe a huge portion of these voters are in the South, where McCain’s numbers have moved the most.  Hard to say.  Also, seven points is still a good place to be.  But I don’t think there is any question that races like AL-02, KY-02, LA-04/06, NV-02, WY-AL and other really Republican districts will see some sort of impact, and I can’t believe it will help our guys immensely.  

  2. but I think an important question is whether Palin has made some Republicans who were going to reluctantly vote for McCain so excited that they will now volunteer for his campaign.

    McCain doesn’t seem to have a lot of canvassing going, but maybe now he will get more boots on the ground.

    I tend to think Palin helped him most in the states he was going to win anyway.

  3. http://www.politico.com/blogs/

    To sum it up, Vito is trying to get on the ballot as an independant because there is essentially no hope for their golden Republican candidate.  So they are doing polling and looking into the laws or w/e as the usual steps go to do so.  

Comments are closed.