MS-01: The Fingerpointing Begins

As David articulated last night, the “every man for himself” attitude that is crippling the House GOP conference will only grow stronger in the weeks and months ahead now that the NRCC is left with no excuses for losing a safe seat in Mississippi.

Already, they’re tripping over themselves to lay the blame at someone’s feet:

Texas Rep. Jeb Hensarling, who chairs the conservative Republican Study Committee, defended the campaign chairman during the closed-door session, saying “the problem was not Cole, but the Republican brand” and the lack of well-formulated policy planks articulated by the party.

But other members did point fingers; Tennessee Rep. Marsha Blackburn complained that newly-appointed GOP Sen. Roger Wicker did not do enough to help Republican Greg Davis retain his seat, members in attendance said afterward. Blackburn also explained that an ongoing feud between Republican Sen. Thad Cochran and the state’s recently retired GOP Sen. Trent Lott also played a part in the loss.

How bad is it?  Rumors are raging that Cole might be sacked in favor of retiring Rep. Tom Davis:

The finger-pointing wasn’t just limited to the conference room in the Capitol basement where members met; former NRCC Chairman Tom Davis, who has become a pointed critic of his party and President Bush since announcing his retirement earlier this year, gave members a 20-page memo he typed up over the weekend about what the party needs to do to improve its brand nationally, the Virginia Republican told reporters after the meeting.

“This is the floor,” Davis said, stopping his foot on the concrete. “We’re underneath it.”

Davis, however, dowmplayed a rumor that he would be elevated to replace Cole, and the current job holder said no major changes were in the works at the committee “yet.”

It’s no surprise that a lot of House GOPers would want to sack Cole’s sorry ass, but they may not have a chance with only six months to go until election day.

The Hill sums up the situation in the starkest of terms:

The sky is falling on House Republicans and there is no sign of it letting up.

The GOP loss in Mississippi’s special election Tuesday is the strongest sign yet that the Republican Party is in shambles. And while some Republicans see a light at the end of the tunnel, that light more likely represents the Democratic train that is primed to mow down more Republicans in November.

Get ready to rock this November.  Republicans can run, but they can’t hide.

Update: Blackburn has taken issue with the characterization of her remarks:

Blackburn referred to her former House colleague, but did not criticize him for a lack of effort. She was referring to a rift that emerged during the primary between rival regions in the district, a member present said.

MS-01: The Backbreaker

This is it, folks. The one. The final piece of straw set atop the shambling camel of the GOP, the one which clove its dessicated humps in two.

Only it’s more like a ton of bricks crushing the Republican roach.

Let’s take stock of this race to see what I mean:

  • This district has a PVI of R+10. It voted for Bush 62-37 in the last election. Only seven Democrats sit in comparably red seats – and not a single Republican sits in a seat as blue as this one is red. And almost every major prognosticator (at least at the start) treated this as a safe seat.
  • The GOP had a perfectly serviceable candidate in Greg Davis – a standard wingnut with none of the baggage of Woody Jenkins in LA-06 or Jim Oberweis in IL-14.
  • The NRCC spent $1.3 million on this race. Freedom’s Crotch spent at least $400K more – and used illegal tactics to boot. And of course Davis himself raised over a million.
  • They sent in Mike Huckabee, Thad Cochran, Trent Lott, Haley Barbour, and Roger Wicker.
  • And when that wasn’t enough, Darth Cheney came to town, to stump and raise money.
  • The GOP played up Obama/Pelosi/”librul” fear-mongering to the hilt. They were shameless in exploiting whatever racial angle they thought would work.

And yet what happened? Despite all this, Travis Childers just became the newest member of the Democratic Caucus with a resounding 54-46 win. It’s utterly unspinnable. Even Tom Cole knew not to try.

But a sober press release only sees him through until tomorrow morning. Then he has to face the same vast universe of problems he had before him today, except they will loom much larger and much more sharply. Almost every potentially contestable Republican seat is in play now. The “every man for himself” mentality that has taken hold amongst the GOP will become even more firmly entrenched, dooming already-weak NRCC fundraising. In Congress, discipline will likely suffer as vulnerable members (ie, much of the caucus) are tempted to side with the Dems. And we may even see some more retirements. Things are going to get much, much worse before they ever get better for the GOP – if they do at all.

For a lot of reasons, this to me is the sweetest of our three recent special election victories. But to the GOP, seldom has more bitter medicine passed their lips. Glib commentators will say that the Republican brand is tarnished. The fact is, it is the Republican Party which itself is broken.

And this election is what helped break it.

MS-01: Boehner Warns Republicans

For once, John Boehner is not spinning tonight’s result. As a matter of fact, he has issued a warning to fellow House Republcans.

House Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH) tonight responded to the MS-01 special election results with this cautionary statement:

“The results in MS-01 should serve as a wake-up call to Republican candidates nationwide. As I’ve said before, this is a change election, and if we want Americans to vote for us we have to convince them that we can fix Washington. Our presidential nominee, Senator McCain, is an agent of change; candidates who hope to succeed must show that they’re willing and able to join McCain in a leading movement for reform. We need to stop wasteful Washington spending, fight and win the war on terror, and stop the largest tax increase in history. That is truly the change the American people deserve — and that is a message on which we can succeed.”

My question of them is whether they are regretting that rally with George Bush.

MS-01: Draft the NRCC’s Press Release

I’d like you to imagine, for a moment, that you are the NRCC’s junior press secretary. You’ve just been tasked with the impossible: Spin tonight’s disastrous election loss in the deep red, R+10 first congressional district in Mississippi. Well, it would be impossible for normal people, but we’re talking about Republicans. No spin is too absurd! Anything will do! Those saps in the “emm-ess-emm” will dutifully transcribe whatever you write, anyhow. (Remember how they bought your line about how LA-06 was a bad portent for… Democrats? Delicious!) The key thing is, whatever explanation you decide on, it absolutely, positively, cannot be the fault of any Republican anywhere.

With that in mind, start writing!

UPDATE: The verdict is in: Tom Cole should have hired all the commenters on this thread! His staff has clearly forgotten how to write a Republican press release.

MS-01: Results Thread #2


462 of 462 Precincts Reporting
CandidatePartyVotesPercent
Travis Childers (D)57,27654%
Greg Davis(R)49,31446%

RESULTS: Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal | Columbus Dispatch | Clarion-Ledger

County-by-County Baselines (4/22 and 4/1 results)

10:34PM: A big thank you to everyone who commented, donated, made phone calls, volunteered or blogged about this race.  Travis Childers and the Mississippi Democrats just took what was supposed to be a GOP cakewalk and delivered a deathblow.  Savor this win — because it’s a huge one.

10:17PM: Trent just left for the TRAVIS CHILDERS VICTORY PARTY!!!

10:15PM: Folks, sorry for this site crashing tonight.  We’ve been utterly slammed with traffic at a level that we haven’t seen since election night ’06.

10:14PM: CHILDERS WINS!!!

10:13PM: Folks, I think we just won this race.

10:06PM: Time for a new thread.

MS-01: Results Thread #1


334 of 462 Precincts Reporting
CandidatePartyVotesPercent
Travis Childers(D)39,11650%
Greg Davis(R)38,41850%

RESULTS: Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal | Columbus Dispatch | Clarion-Ledger

County-by-County Baselines (4/22 and 4/1 results)

9:58PM: DeSoto is almost all in (36/38), narrowing the race.  We still have some very friendly precincts left (Clay, Prentiss) and some not-so-friendly ones (Tate).  Looking optimistic, though.

9:56PM: Grenada is all in, going 49-51 to Davis.  Last time, Davis won it 54-40.

9:49PM: Lee is all in, and Childers wins it 58-42.  It was 58-37 last time.

9:46PM: Now it’s a 2-point race.  A few more DeSoto precincts came in, closing the gap a bit.

9:42PM: Trent tells me that the mood is good at the Childers HQ.  Childers just flipped Lafayette County by 53-47.  It went for Davis by 44-51 last time.

9:35PM: Union came in, going from 39% on 4/22 to 44% tonight for Davis, but Childers stayed at 56%.

9:33PM: Big win in Panola for Cold Chillin’ Travis (57-43), which Davis won by 1 vote last time.

9:28PM: It’s not reflected above or on the AP’s tally, but Childers is at 72% in Clay County with 10 of 14 precincts in.  That would be an improvement over last time by 6 or 7 points.

9:20PM: Now they’re running even in Lowndes with 18 of 22 in.

9:17PM: Webster is all in, and Childers ran ahead by 6 points.  He’s also at 28% in DeSoto with 12 of 38 in.  With the Lowndes performance, this is good news.

9:15PM: New update — Lowndes is now reflected in the total above.

9:11PM: It’s not reflected in the above totals or in the AP’s results, but the Dispatch says that Childers is winning Lowndes by 59-41 with 2/3rds in.  Childers lost this county last time.

9:04PM: 7 of 38 precincts reporting in DeSoto.  Childers is at 26% there — a slight bump from the 17% he got there last time.

9:01PM: Folks, just a reminder — the Clarion-Ledger is your best bet for the fastest results by county.

8:56PM: Childers is up to 59% in Lee — much better.

8:46PM: More numbers in, from Lee and Chickasaw.  Childers is running slightly behind his 4/22 total, but it’s too early to tell just yet with only partial results from these counties.

8:41PM: Winston is in, breaking 6-4 for Childers.  Childers won 4-0 here on 4/22.

8:00PM Eastern: Polls are now closed.  It will probably take a few minutes before the first results trickle in, though, judging from past experience here.  Stay tuned.




Polls close here at 8pm Eastern, so we still have time for some pre-game chatter before we begin liveblogging the reults.

Will Bardwell has a few turnout updates here.  Our friends at Cotton Mouth and the Thorn Papers will be providing local color, as well.

It looks like turnout is up everywhere, but this could be an ominous sign for Childers: DeSoto county is printing extra ballots, which means that they’ll have more than 17,000 votes cast in this election.

MS-01: Predictions Open Thread

Polls close in Mississippi tonight at 8pm Eastern.  We’ll be liveblogging the returns as they come in, but until then, feel free to post your predictions in the comments.  You may find the county baselines that we posted earlier to be helpful.

There’s another election tonight, as well — the Democratic primary for the U.S. Senate nomination in Nebraska, where Scott Kleeb and Tony Raimondo will face off.  Polls close at 9pm Eastern in Nebraska.  Feel free to post your predictions for that race in the comments, too.

There’s still time to help GOTV for Childers with the DCCC’s virtual phonebanking center.

MS-01: County Baselines

Polls close in Mississippi at 8pm Eastern. We’ll be tracking and liveblogging the returns as they come in, but in order to really know what the numbers mean, we’ll have to pull up the county-by-county results of the April 22nd special primary, filtering out the also-rans so we get a pure Childers vs. Davis head-to-head:























































































































































































County Childers % Davis %
Alcorn 1808 63 1023 35
Benton 504 67 227 30
Calhoun 692 54 501 39
Chickasaw 1141 67 465 27
Choctaw 300 47 291 47
Clay 1609 65 722 29
DeSoto 2064 17 10148 81
Grenada 553 40 752 54
Itawamba 1155 59 701 36
Lafayette 1149 44 1342 51
Lee 4899 58 3143 37
Lowndes 1855 44 2252 53
Marshall 1633 62 950 36
Monroe 2374 62 1206 32
Panola 1057 43 1058 43
Pontotoc 1337 51 1117 43
Prentiss 4136 85 653 13
Tate 632 31 1313 65
Tippah 1131 60 704 37
Tishomingo 1135 61 663 35
Union 1191 56 846 39
Webster 286 35 475 58
Winston 4 100 0 0
Yalobusha 493 46 514 48
Total 33,138 49 31,066 46

Steve Holland (D) and Glenn McCullough (R), previously defeated in the April 1st primary runoff, won 1.17% and 1.44% of the vote, respectively.

Davis won 8 of the district’s 24 counties in the first round, but the biggest chunk of his votes came from the Memphis suburbs in DeSoto County, which contains his home base of South Memphis Southaven. Because of its sheer voting power, DeSoto has the potential of being a game-ender for Childers if Davis can keep the numbers close throughout the rest of the district.

Childers will need to do his best to run up the score in Prentiss (his home county), neighboring Alcorn, and key spots like Chickasaw (41% black), Clay (56% black), Marshall (50% black), and other friendly areas in Northeast Mississippi. We’ll also see if Childers and the DCCC have been able to turnout crucial votes in counties like that Davis won like Panola (48% black), Grenada (41% black), and Yalobusha (39% black). More ballots were cast for Democrats than for Republicans in these counties in the April 1st primary runoff, but some of those votes didn’t turn out for Childers in the first round of the special election.

A key bellwether here will be Lee County, where Tupelo is located. It’s a county that normally tilts Republican in statewide and federal races, but Davis’ savage attacks in the GOP primary against Tupelo’s former mayor, Glenn McCullough, didn’t do much to inspire enthusiasm for his bid here: Childers won the county by 58%-37% on April 22nd. But if Davis closes the gap here, Childers may have a hard time coming out on top.

For good measure, I’m adding the county-by-county numbers for the primary run-off below the fold.











































































































































































































































County Childers Holland Total Dem Davis McCullough Total GOP
Alcorn 1454 290 1744 349 554 903
Benton 384 95 479 82 42 124
Calhoun 500 471 971 201 305 506
Chickasaw 575 1066 1641 148 374 522
Choctaw 356 138 494 96 311 407
Clay 1012 599 1611 138 635 773
DeSoto 1056 388 1444 8281 1947 10228
Grenada 390 282 672 285 364 649
Itawamba 536 1123 1659 268 548 816
Lafayette 530 776 1306 454 695 1149
Lee 1266 4822 6088 1251 3566 4817
Lowndes 1056 468 1524 1022 1731 2753
Marshall 1118 348 1466 478 258 736
Monroe 1443 1644 3087 436 937 1373
Panola 1017 233 1250 548 227 775
Pontotoc 584 1028 1612 459 954 1413
Prentiss 3543 335 3878 198 377 575
Tate 646 100 746 812 242 1054
Tippah 889 245 1134 262 439 701
Tishomingo 926 392 1318 189 389 578
Union 796 637 1433 361 758 1119
Webster 274 174 448 219 321 540
Winston 3 1 4 2 1 3
Yalobusha 443 303 746 194 221 415
Total 20,797 15,958 36,755 16,733 16,196 32,929