(Note: These ratings are independent and are not the same ratings drafted by SSP).
Republican Favored
Open Seat (ID-R)
Open Seat (NE-R)
Republican Favored/Likely Republican
Inhofe (OK-R)
Alexander (TN-R)
Likely Republican
Roberts (KS-R)
Graham (SC-R)
Likely/Leans Republican
Cornyn (TX-R)
Leans Republican
McConnell (KY-R)
Collins (ME-R)
Toss-Up
Stevens (AK-R)
Chambliss (GA-R)
Coleman (MN-R)
Wicker (MS-R)
Leans Democrat
Open Seat (CO-R) **
Sununu (NH-R) **
Dole (NC-R) **
Smith (OR-R) **
Likely Democrat
Landrieu (LA-D)
Likely Democrat/Democrat Favored
Lautenberg (NJ-D)
Democrat Favored
Open Seat (NM-R) **
Johnson (SD-D)
Open Seat (VA-R) **
Democrats are expected to pick up at least six seats. While possible, it is quite a stretch to expect Democrats to pick up more than eight seats.
Of the Toss Up seats, Stevens is most likely the safest, since it is more likely that his trial will end in acquittal. The Coleman and Chambliss races have shown the most momentum in the past month, while Wicker’s race has remained relatively flat. No Democrat is expected to lose at this point.
Oh and as for Joe, expect him to go over to that other side. Democrats will no longer need him and his chairmanship of the Homeland Security Committee will be revoked post-election. Should Joe resign outright, which is highly unlikely, then Governor Rell, a Republican, appoints his successor. Top prospect is Chris Shays, who if appointed, would clearly have a voting record similar to Joe, yet also one far more liberal than Joe as it relates to Iraq. If Joe stays, then Democrats still win. And if Joe goes, Democrats still win. A win-win either way.
Recent Changes:
Chambliss (GA) – This race was previously considered Likely Republican, in a large part to the likelihood of a large African-American electorate showing up on Election Day. The race has since changed dramatically. A Libertarian candidate has been taking voters from Chambliss in some of the stronger Republican areas, such as Warner Robins. The gas shortages in Georgia, the bailout vote, and Chambliss’s perceived softening on illegal immigration, have also cost him some of the radical Republican voters. With 30% of the electorate classified as African-American, Chambliss could ill afford to lose his base. Independents may also desert Chambliss in large part to the anti-incumbent mood inflicting the Republican Party. Expect this race to move closer to the Democrats in the final week.
Landrieu (LA) – Like Georgia 30% of the electorate is African-American. Landrieu has also managed to win over a large bloc of Republicans in the past. Many were ready to concede defeat here following Hurricane Katrina and the mass exodus of African-Americans. However, most of those African-Americans appear to have returned home or resettled elsewhere in the state (Baton Rouge or Alexandria). Kennedy, a former Democrat, has failed to catch traction. In a desperate attempt, the NRSC has sought to label Landrieu as corrupt, tying her into Bill Jefferson and former Governor Edwin Edwards. The last minute desperate attempt appears to be failing. Once vulnerable, a little more safe is the end result.
Collins (ME) – Former Sen. George Mitchell appears in a recent ad endorsing Tom Allen. The endorsement could definately make the race even more competitive since Mitchell is largely popular throughout Maine. The anti-incumbent mood doesn’t apply here since both are virtually incumbents. However, Maine is a Democratic state and Collins can not be guaranteed victory here. An obvious liability for Collins may be the war in Iraq, which is largely unpopular here. This race should definately tighten during the final week.
Coleman (MN) – The strangest race of the Senate cycle has avoided the issues for the most part. Questions of Franken’s character came first, followed by questions of Coleman’s character. Coleman clearly had the advantage until questions of his character were revealed. The beneficiary of Coleman’s loss is surely Independent Barkley. A strong Democratic turnout is surely expected, yet this will be an interesting race to watch on election night. Which candidate will fall prey to Barkley’s gains?
Wicker (MS) – After years of working against the middle class, Wicker has transformed. He suddenly appears concerned about the middle class strife. Musgrove came out with a very effective ad and it surely should translate into votes. A large African-American turnout, anti-incumbent mood, and Wicker’s short tenure and low name recognition outside Northern Mississippi, should give Musgrove a narrow advantage. Another race that should develop, in the favor of Musgrove.
Lautenberg (NJ) – Not only is George Bush unpopular in the Garden State, so is Governor Corzine. Republicans in the state are seeking to link Democrats, including Lautenberg, with Corzine at every turn. This also explains why the two open Republicans seats have not moved into the Safe Democratic column. Lautenberg’s age and lack of support in Southern New Jersey are two concerns. Lautenberg’s base is Northern New Jersey and Central New Jersey is the balance between the North and South. However, Zimmer has not been running a strong campaign. He is clearly two conservative for the state and is instead attacking Lautenberg on earmarks. For his part, Lautenberg is avoiding debates with Zimmer, clearly a strong strategy. The last thing that Democrats need is for Lautenberg to mess up and create a unexpected race at the end. Clearly a Lautenberg retirement would have been the best outcome for Democrats.
Dole (NC) – Lizzy clearly was not wanting to run on the economy. In fact, her first ad was about illegal immigration. The social issue revolution does not exist and Lizzy has been placed on the defensive. Unlike her first ad, Lizzy comes off as warm and compassionate. There’s even a home in the background, ironic since many have questioned whether Lizzy even lives in the state. Research done by a local newspaper indicated that she spent less than two months in an entire year residing in the state. Several factors, other than Bush, are working against Lizzy. The collapse of Wachovia, based in Charlotte, will surely translate into pink slips for many. Lizzy did not vote for the bailout bill, one of the only bills, other than illegal immigration, which Bush presented which she refused to vote for. The downward turn in the economy, Obama’s competiveness in the state, and her incumbency have all but guaranteed that Lizzy Dole is doomed. Viagra Dole has come in to campaign for his wife, yet like Dorothy, both should be back in Kansas sometime soon.
Smith (OR) – Unlike previous years, Oregon has not been competive on the presidential level. Merkley is an outsider in a state which clearly favors Democrats. Recent attacks have been leveled against Smith regarding his employing of illegal immigrants. The strategy is designed to alienate Smith from the conservative base which he can not afford to lose. Unlike other Republicans, Smith has sought to move himself closer to Obama and even his fellow colleague, Senator Wyden. Reaching out to his own base, while also Democratic leaning independents, is the strategy, yet it appears to be failing.
Graham (SC) – Normally a Democrat would have an uphill battle against Graham, yet Conley is running more to the right than Graham. This is the same conservative Graham who moderated many of his positions when he reached the Senate. Graham’s softening on illegal immigration was the main issue during the primary. Conley’s far right stances has not won him praise from statewide or national Democrats, both are actually hoping he loses. Ironic that Democrats are actually cheering for a Republican over a Democrat. Once again, 30% of the electorate is African-American. Conley is hoping that an awkward combination of straight party voting African-Americans and radical right Republicans in Greenville will help him win. Graham continues to run as a conservative, hoping to keep the rate of desertion fairly low. Graham needs to keep the upstate counties in his column, while also reaching out to African-Americans, a hard process in a state like this. If Graham wins in Greenville, then Conley’s strategy would have been considered failed.
Alexander (TN) – One third of new registrations in June 2008 came from the nine counties Obama carried in the primary. Only two, Shelby and Davidson, were major urban centers. Democrats could have recruited a better candidate, yet Tuke is already starting to hit Alexander hard. Not only does African-American turnout in Nashville and Memphis worry Alexander, so do several other factors: downward economy, his vote on the bailout, and gas shortages this past month in parts of the state. Alexander clearly has the advantage, yet it is already weakening.
Cornyn (TX) – The economy goes bust and Big Oil’s fighter clearly goes boom. Democratic nominee Noriega has military credentials, yet Cornyn should carry the Fort Hood vote in Waco. Noriega should perform well in the Rio Grande Valley and El Paso due to the large Hispanic population. He should also carry Austin and perform ahead of or even with Cornyn in San Antonio, Cornyn’s own hometown. Noriega is hoping that a large Hispanic and African-American turnout in Dallas, Houston, and Beaumont will help him keep the race competitive until the end. The panhandle and Eastern Texas are clearly strongholds for Cornyn. However, Obama and Noriega should do fairly well in the Eastern Texas cities of Longview and Tyler. Corpus Christi may also be close between both Cornyn and Noriega. If Cornyn is not taking more than 60% of the vote in the panhandle and Eastern Texas, usually the first two areas to report returns on election night, then this could be a close race in the end. Turnout from Hispanics and African-Americans will be key in determing whether Cornyn survives. Clearly former congressman Jim Turner, a conservative Democrat from Eastern Texas, who also would have started out with $3 million remaining in the bank, would have been the stronger challenger. Stopping the spicket on Exxon John would clearly be hailed as unprecedented.