One of the many interesting features at 538.com, and one that they’ve particularly drilled into the heads of the blogosphere, is the notion of the “tipping point” states. In other words, which states are in the middle of the left-to-right spectrum and the likeliest to be the ones that put a presidential candidate over the required 270 electoral votes to win (and thus get the most emphasis)?
This left me wondering: is this something that can be applied at the state level to identify which counties are the likeliest to be the decisive ones in terms of which way the state falls? Of course, the method is a little different, because a state is won simply by reaching a plurality of votes, rather than through the complicated machinery of the Electoral College. So while a Democratic campaign might particularly emphasize the swing voters clustered in a state’s median counties, it would also certainly want to push turnout in strongly-Democratic urban areas and still try to mine as many votes dispersed around conservative rural areas. But in an era of micro-targeting (via cable, internet ads, direct mail, etc.), knowing where the decisive voters are located, and how an entire state pivots around them, seems critical.
Naturally, I don’t have access to up-to-the-minute county-by-county polling data, so what I tried is arranging every county in each state from highest Democratic percentage to lowest Democratic percentage, for both the presidential races in 2004 and 2000, and then finding in which county the 50% mark fell, in terms of total number of votes. As you’ll note, the usual location tends to be an affluent suburban county, home to the stereotypical moderate swing voter. The tipping point tends to be in a slightly Republican-leaning county (even in some bluish states like Minnesota), which reflects, well, that the Republicans won the last two presidential elections, as well as the heavy concentration of Democratic votes in a few urban counties in many states.
I’m restricting my list to the states where there are prominent statewide races this year, as well as a few states where there isn’t a prominent statewide race but that are key to the presidential race (yes, I know this is Swing State Project, but I also know what everyone is fixated on right now, with the realization that the presidential race is going to turn into yet another house-by-house battle in a few key swing states… so if nothing else, this can be a handy scorecard for watching election returns in November). Rather than list every single freakin’ county in each state, I’m listing only counties with more than 100,000 residents (c. 2000). I’m also listing the D and R percentages for each county for each year. The !!! indicates the county where the tipping point falls. (In a few cases, it fell in a small rural county instead, which I’ll mention in the footnotes.)
Let’s start with Colorado, which is on a lot of people’s minds right now. Other states are over the flip…
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Denver |
70/29 |
Denver |
62/31 |
Boulder |
66/32 |
Pueblo |
54/42 |
Pueblo |
53/46 |
Adams |
50/44 |
Adams |
51/48 |
Boulder |
50/36 |
Arapahoe |
47/51 |
Arapahoe |
43/51 |
Larimer !!! |
47/52 |
Jefferson !!! |
43/51 |
Jefferson |
47/52 |
Larimer |
39/53 |
Weld |
36/63 |
Weld |
36/58 |
Douglas |
33/67 |
Douglas |
31/65 |
El Paso |
32/67 |
El Paso |
31/64 |
Mesa |
32/67 |
Mesa |
30/63 |
Florida
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Broward |
64/35 |
Broward |
67/31 |
Leon |
61/38 |
Palm Beach |
62/35 |
Palm Beach |
60/39 |
Leon |
60/38 |
Alachua |
56/43 |
Alachua |
55/40 |
Miami-Dade |
53/47 |
St. Lucie |
53/44 |
St. Lucie |
52/48 |
Volusia |
53/45 |
Volusia |
50/49 |
Miami-Dade |
53/46 |
Orange |
50/50 |
Osceola |
51/47 |
Pinellas |
50/50 |
Pinellas |
50/46 |
Osceola |
47/52 |
Orange |
50/48 |
Hillsborough !!! |
46/53 |
Hernando |
50/47 |
Hernando |
46/53 |
Pasco !!! |
49/48 |
Sarasota |
45/54 |
Hillsborough |
47/50 |
Pasco |
44/54 |
Sarasota |
45/52 |
Charlotte |
43/56 |
Manatee |
45/53 |
Manatee |
43/57 |
Polk |
45/53 |
Citrus |
42/57 |
Citrus |
45/52 |
Martin |
42/57 |
Brevard |
45/53 |
Duval |
42/58 |
Charlotte |
44/53 |
Brevard |
42/58 |
Marion |
43/54 |
Seminole |
41/58 |
Seminole |
43/55 |
Marion |
41/58 |
Martin |
43/55 |
Polk |
41/59 |
Lake |
41/56 |
Indian River |
39/60 |
Duval |
41/57 |
Lee |
39/60 |
Lee |
40/58 |
Lake |
39/61 |
Indian River |
40/58 |
Collier |
34/65 |
Escambia |
35/63 |
Escambia |
34/65 |
Collier |
32/66 |
St. John’s |
31/69 |
St. John’s |
32/65 |
Bay |
28/71 |
Bay |
32/66 |
Clay |
23/76 |
Clay |
25/73 |
Santa Rosa |
22/77 |
Santa Rosa |
25/72 |
Okaloosa |
22/78 |
Okaloosa |
24/74 |
Georgia
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
DeKalb |
73/27 |
DeKalb |
70/27 |
Clayton |
70/29 |
Clayton |
65/33 |
Fulton |
59/40 |
Fulton |
58/40 |
Clarke |
58/40 |
Richmond |
55/44 |
Richmond |
57/43 |
Muscogee |
54/45 |
Muscogee |
51/48 |
Clarke |
52/41 |
Bibb |
51/49 |
Bibb |
50/48 |
Chatham |
50/50 |
Chatham |
49/49 |
Cobb !!! |
37/62 |
Cobb !!! |
37/60 |
Gwinnett |
33/66 |
Houston |
36/63 |
Houston |
33/66 |
Gwinnett |
32/64 |
Henry |
33/67 |
Henry |
31/66 |
Hall |
21/78 |
Hall |
27/70 |
Cherokee |
20/79 |
Cherokee |
23/73 |
Indiana
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Lake |
61/38 |
Lake |
62/36 |
Monroe |
53/45 |
La Porte |
50/48 |
Marion |
51/49 |
St. Joseph |
49/49 |
La Porte |
50/49 |
Vigo |
48/50 |
St. Joseph |
48/51 |
Marion |
48/49 |
Vigo |
46/53 |
Delaware |
47/50 |
Porter |
45/54 |
Porter |
45/52 |
Delaware |
43/56 |
Madison |
45/54 |
Vanderburgh |
41/59 |
Vanderburgh |
44/54 |
Madison |
40/59 |
Monroe |
44/48 |
Tippecanoe |
40/59 |
Tippecanoe * |
39/56 |
Allen * |
36/63 |
Allen |
36/62 |
Elkhart |
29/70 |
Elkhart |
30/67 |
Hendricks |
26/73 |
Johnson |
28/70 |
Johnson |
26/74 |
Hendricks |
27/71 |
Hamilton |
25/74 |
Hamilton |
24/74 |
Maine
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Cumberland |
58/40 |
Androscoggin |
53/41 |
Androscoggin |
54/44 |
Kennebec |
53/41 |
York !!! |
53/45 |
Cumberland |
52/41 |
Kennebec |
53/45 |
York !!! |
49/45 |
Penobscot |
49/49 |
Penobscot |
45/49 |
Michigan
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Wayne |
69/30 |
Wayne |
69/29 |
Washtenaw |
63/35 |
Genesee |
63/35 |
Genesee |
60/39 |
Washtenaw |
60/36 |
Ingham |
58/41 |
Ingham |
57/39 |
Muskegon |
55/44 |
Bay |
55/43 |
Bay |
54/45 |
Muskegon |
55/43 |
Saginaw |
53/46 |
Saginaw |
54/44 |
Kalamazoo |
51/48 |
Monroe |
51/47 |
Oakland !!! |
50/49 |
Macomb |
50/48 |
Macomb |
49/50 |
Calhoun |
50/48 |
Monroe |
49/51 |
Oakland !!! |
49/48 |
Calhoun |
48/51 |
Kalamazoo |
48/48 |
Eaton |
46/53 |
St. Clair |
48/49 |
St. Clair |
45/54 |
Eaton |
47/50 |
Berrien |
44/55 |
Jackson |
45/52 |
Jackson |
43/56 |
Berrien |
43/55 |
Kent |
40/59 |
Livingston |
38/59 |
Livingston |
36/63 |
Kent |
38/59 |
Allegan |
36/63 |
Allegan |
35/63 |
Ottawa |
28/72 |
Ottawa |
27/71 |
Minnesota
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
St. Louis |
65/34 |
St. Louis |
60/33 |
Ramsey |
63/36 |
Ramsey |
57/36 |
Hennepin |
59/39 |
Hennepin |
54/39 |
Dakota !!! |
48/50 |
Dakota !!! |
47/48 |
Washington |
48/51 |
Anoka |
47/48 |
Olmsted |
47/52 |
Washington |
46/48 |
Anoka |
46/53 |
Olmsted |
43/52 |
Stearns |
43/55 |
Stearns |
40/52 |
Mississippi
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Hinds |
59/40 |
Hinds |
53/43 |
Harrison !!! |
36/63 |
Harrison * |
36/61 |
Jackson |
30/69 |
Jackson |
31/67 |
De Soto |
27/72 |
De Soto |
27/71 |
Rankin |
20/79 |
Rankin |
19/80 |
Missouri
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
St. Louis city |
80/19 |
St. Louis city |
77/20 |
Jackson |
58/41 |
Jackson |
59/38 |
St. Louis |
54/45 |
St. Louis |
51/46 |
Boone |
50/50 |
Jefferson |
50/48 |
Jefferson |
49/50 |
Clay |
49/49 |
Clay !!! |
46/53 |
Boone !!! |
48/48 |
St. Charles |
41/59 |
St. Charles |
42/56 |
Greene |
37/62 |
Greene |
40/57 |
Jasper |
29/71 |
Jasper |
31/66 |
New Hampshire
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Strafford |
56/44 |
Strafford |
51/43 |
Merrimack |
52/47 |
Merrimack |
48/47 |
Hillsborough !!! |
48/51 |
Hillsborough !!! |
47/49 |
Rockingham |
47/52 |
Rockingham |
46/49 |
New Mexico
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Santa Fe |
71/28 |
Santa Fe |
65/28 |
Bernalillo !!! |
51/47 |
Dona Ana |
51/46 |
Dona Ana |
51/48 |
Bernalillo !!! |
49/47 |
San Juan |
33/66 |
San Juan |
35/62 |
North Carolina
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Durham |
68/32 |
Durham |
64/36 |
Orange |
67/32 |
Orange |
63/36 |
Robeson |
53/47 |
Robeson |
60/39 |
Mecklenburg |
52/48 |
Cumberland |
50/49 |
Guilford |
50/49 |
Guilford |
49/51 |
Buncombe |
49/50 |
Mecklenburg |
48/51 |
Wake |
49/51 |
Wake |
46/53 |
Cumberland |
48/52 |
Pitt |
46/54 |
Pitt |
46/53 |
Buncombe * |
45/54 |
Forsyth !!! |
46/54 |
New Hanover |
44/55 |
New Hanover |
44/56 |
Forsyth |
43/56 |
Alamance |
38/61 |
Wayne |
38/61 |
Wayne |
38/62 |
Alamance |
37/62 |
Cabarrus |
33/67 |
Onslow |
34/65 |
Rowan |
32/67 |
Iredell |
34/65 |
Catawba |
32/67 |
Rowan |
34/66 |
Gaston |
32/68 |
Johnston |
33/66 |
Johnston |
32/68 |
Cabarrus |
33/66 |
Iredell |
32/68 |
Gaston |
33/67 |
Onslow |
30/69 |
Catawba |
32/67 |
Union |
29/70 |
Union |
32/68 |
Davidson |
29/71 |
Davidson |
31/68 |
Randolph |
25/74 |
Randolph |
27/73 |
Ohio
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Cuyahoga |
67/33 |
Cuyahoga |
63/33 |
Mahoning |
63/37 |
Mahoning |
61/35 |
Trumbull |
62/38 |
Trumbull |
60/36 |
Lucas |
60/40 |
Lucas |
58/39 |
Summit |
57/43 |
Lorain |
53/43 |
Lorain |
56/43 |
Summit |
53/43 |
Franklin |
54/45 |
Ashtabula |
50/45 |
Portage |
53/46 |
Portage |
50/45 |
Ashtabula |
53/46 |
Montgomery |
50/48 |
Montgomery |
51/49 |
Franklin |
49/48 |
Stark !!! |
51/49 |
Clark |
49/48 |
Clark |
49/51 |
Stark !!! |
47/49 |
Lake |
48/51 |
Columbiana |
46/49 |
Columbiana |
47/52 |
Lake |
45/50 |
Hamilton |
47/53 |
Wood |
43/53 |
Wood |
46/53 |
Hamilton |
43/54 |
Medina |
43/57 |
Medina |
40/56 |
Richland |
40/60 |
Richland |
39/57 |
Greene |
39/61 |
Greene |
38/58 |
Wayne |
38/61 |
Licking |
37/60 |
Licking |
38/62 |
Fairfield |
35/62 |
Fairfield |
37/63 |
Wayne |
35/61 |
Butler |
34/66 |
Butler |
34/63 |
Delaware |
34/66 |
Allen |
32/65 |
Allen |
33/66 |
Delaware |
31/66 |
Clermont |
29/71 |
Clermont |
30/67 |
Warren |
28/72 |
Warren |
28/70 |
Oregon
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Multnomah |
72/27 |
Multnomah |
64/28 |
Lane |
58/40 |
Lane |
52/40 |
Washington |
52/46 |
Washington |
49/46 |
Clackamas !!! |
49/50 |
Clackamas !!! |
47/48 |
Marion |
44/54 |
Marion |
44/51 |
Jackson |
43/55 |
Jackson |
39/54 |
Deschutes |
42/56 |
Deschutes |
38/56 |
Linn |
38/60 |
Linn |
38/57 |
Douglas |
33/66 |
Douglas |
30/64 |
Pennsylvania
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Philadelphia |
80/19 |
Philadelphia |
80/18 |
Allegheny |
57/42 |
Lackawanna |
60/36 |
Delaware |
57/42 |
Fayette |
57/40 |
Lackawanna |
56/42 |
Allegheny |
57/40 |
Montgomery |
56/44 |
Delaware |
54/43 |
Erie |
54/46 |
Montgomery |
54/44 |
Fayette |
53/46 |
Washington |
53/44 |
Luzerne |
51/48 |
Erie |
53/44 |
Bucks |
51/48 |
Beaver |
53/44 |
Beaver |
51/48 |
Luzerne |
52/44 |
Lehigh !!! |
51/48 |
Northampton |
51/45 |
Washington |
50/50 |
Bucks !!! |
50/46 |
Northampton |
50/49 |
Cambria |
50/46 |
Monroe |
50/50 |
Mercer |
49/47 |
Cambria |
49/51 |
Lehigh |
49/48 |
Mercer |
48/51 |
Monroe |
47/50 |
Centre |
48/52 |
Westmoreland |
46/52 |
Chester |
48/52 |
Schuylkill |
45/51 |
Berks |
46/53 |
Dauphin |
44/53 |
Dauphin |
46/54 |
Berks |
44/53 |
Schuylkill |
45/55 |
Chester |
44/53 |
Westmoreland |
44/56 |
Centre |
43/53 |
Cumberland |
36/64 |
York |
36/61 |
York |
36/64 |
Butler |
35/62 |
Butler |
35/64 |
Cumberland |
35/62 |
Lancaster |
34/66 |
Lebanon |
35/62 |
Blair |
33/66 |
Blair |
35/63 |
Lebanon |
33/67 |
Lycoming |
34/63 |
Lycoming |
31/68 |
Lancaster |
31/66 |
Franklin |
28/71 |
Franklin |
30/67 |
Virginia
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
Richmond city |
70/29 |
Richmond city |
65/31 |
Arlington |
68/31 |
Portsmouth city |
63/36 |
Alexandria city |
67/32 |
Norfolk city |
62/35 |
Norfolk cit |
62/37 |
Alexandria city |
61/34 |
Portsmouth city |
61/38 |
Arlington |
60/34 |
Hampton city |
57/42 |
Hampton city |
57/41 |
Fairfax |
53/46 |
Newport News city |
51/47 |
Newport News city |
52/47 |
Fairfax |
47/49 |
Prince William |
46/53 |
Chesapeake city |
45/53 |
Henrico |
46/54 |
Prince William |
45/53 |
Loudoun * |
44/56 |
Henrico * |
43/55 |
Chesapeake city |
42/57 |
Virginia Beach city |
42/56 |
Virginia Beach city |
40/59 |
Loudoun |
41/56 |
Chesterfield |
37/63 |
Chesterfield |
35/63 |
Washington
County |
2004 |
County |
2000 |
King |
65/34 |
King |
60/34 |
Thurston |
56/43 |
Thurston |
52/41 |
Whatcom |
53/45 |
Snohomish |
52/44 |
Snohomish !!! |
53/46 |
Pierce !!! |
51/44 |
Kitsap |
51/47 |
Kitsap |
49/45 |
Pierce |
50/48 |
Whatcom |
46/46 |
Skagit |
48/50 |
Clark |
46/50 |
Clark |
47/52 |
Skagit |
45/49 |
Spokane |
43/55 |
Spokane |
43/52 |
Yakima |
39/60 |
Yakima |
38/59 |
Benton |
32/66 |
Benton |
33/64 |
The 2004 tipping point in Indiana is Fayette County; Allen is the closest large county.
The 2000 tipping point in Indiana is Wayne County; Tippecanoe is the closest large county.
The 2000 tipping point in Mississippi is Scott County; Harrison is the closest large county.
The 2000 tipping point in North Carolina is Duplin County; Buncombe is the closest large county.
The 2004 tipping point in Virginia is Nottoway County; Loudoun is the closest large county.
The 2000 tipping point in Virginia is Dinwiddie County; Henrico is the closest large county.
(I know that, short of looking at a map, it’s not always readily apparent what cities are in a county or where the county is, so if you have any geographic questions, feel free to ask in the comments.)