This was originally at dailyKos, and is a bit dated, but the theory is still sound, I think. I’ve noted places where filing is closed….there’s always 2010!
The other day, James Risser put up an excellent diary 86 the 86 in ’08. These are the 86 Dems. who voted with 194 Repubs to agree to keep funding the war.
I thought, though, that 1) We aren’t going to get 86 primaries going. It would be nice, but that’s a LOT of races! 2) We don’t want to replace moderate-conservative Democrats with right wing Repubs and therefore 3) The ones we really need to target are those in Democratic districts, where a more progressive Dem. would beat a Repub.
What I did was go through the list of 86, find out how long each had been in Congress, how liberal they were on other issues, and what the district was like. Then I rated each as ‘not a priority’, ‘moderate priority’, or ‘HIGH PRIORITY’; on a few, I added “GO GET HIM!”.
These ratings are about primarying, only! Clearly, we would be better off with 435 Democrats, all of whom vote like my guy (Jerrold Nadler, NY-8). Well, maybe someday. I have some ideas for what to do about that at the end. But for now, I think we need to concentrate on these people. Also, I did not take into account whether a primary challenge would WIN. The reason I didn’t is because even a challenge is valuable.
Jason Altmire (PA 4) is a first term congressperson from a Republican district (54-45 Bush over Kerry). He narrowly (52-48) beat Melissa Hart, who was bad news. On other issues, he seems pretty good. Leave him be.
Robert Andrews (NJ 1) was elected in 1990. The district is solidly Democratic (61-39 Kerry). His record is generally moderate. HIGH PRIORITY. Mahdi Ibn-Ziyad is running.
Joe Baca (CA 43) was first elected in 1999. This is a solidly Democratic district (58-41 Kerry). Baca is, in the Almanac of Am. Politics words “one of the most conservative CA Dems”. HIGH PRIORITY. Joanne Gilbert is running
Brian Baird (WA 03) was first elected in 1998. This is a tight district (50-48 Bush over Kerry) that Baird wins easily (62% an 63% in recent elections). Not a priority.
John Barrow (GA 12) was elected in 2004. This district is moderately Democratic (54-46 Kerry), and Barrow is, at best, a moderate. He could easily be replaced with a leftist, possibly an African American, as the district is 40% AA. The district is also getting more D over time. HIGH PRIORITY Update [2007-5-27 10:17:34 by plf515]: per the comments, apparently this district was just changed and is no longer so Democratic, so this is a moderate priority
Melissa Bean (IL 8) was first elected in 2004. This is Republican territory (56-44 Bush over Kerry) and, while Bean is no lefty, she’s probably as progressive as this district will go. Not a priority.
Shelley Berkley (NV 01) was elected in 1998. This is a solid Democratic district (57-41 Kerry). Berkley has faced primaries before, and won easily, nevertheless, her fairly moderate record makes her a HIGH PRIORITY. No opponents now, but filing deadline is May 16
Marion Berry (AR 01), first elected 1996. A tossup district (52-48 Bush over Kerry). Berry is a very conservative Dem. but in AR 01, I don’t know that we will do better. Not a priority.
Sanford Bishop (GA 02) was first elected in 1992. This is another case of a conservative Dem. winning in Republican territory (54-46 Bush over Kerry). Bishop is probably the most conservative guy in the Black caucus, and this district is 44% Black. So, could a more liberal Black get enough of the White vote to win? Maybe. Moderate priority
Dan Boren (OK 2) was elected in 2004. This district is highly Republican (Bush 59-41 over Kerry). Although Boren is a conservative Dem. he’s better than a Repub. Not a priority.
Leonard Boswell (IA 03) has been in since 1996. This is a swing district, Bush won by 300 votes. Boswell wins narrowly, and a more liberal Dem. might get crushed. Not a priority
Rick Boucher (VA 09) was first elected in 1982. VA 09 is overwhelminghly Repub. (Bush got 59% against Kerry) and Boucher is very popular (he wins 60% and more). He’s very active on internet issues, from what I gathered, he’s good on those. Not a priority – but see Va Dare’s comment.
Allen Boyd (FL 02) was first elected in 1996 in a district that is fairly Republican (Bush got 54 against Kerry). Boyd is a conservative Democrat. He ran unopposed in 06, it might be time to challenge. Moderate priority
Nancy Boyda (KS 01) was elected in 2006 in an overwhelmingly Repub. district (Bush 59-41 over Kerry), for this district, I think Boyda is as good as it gets. Not a priority.
GK Butterfield (NC 01) was elected in 2004. This is a strongly Democratic district (Kerry got 57%). Butterfield won in a special election to replace a criminal. He’s pretty good on most issues, but it’s time to hold his feet to the fire. He ran unopposed in 2006, let’s make that not happen in ’08. HIGH PRIORITY.
Dennis Cardoza (CA 18) was first elected in 2002 in a swing district (Bush won by a few hundred votes). He was co-chair of the Blue Dog Democrats. I dunno. Moderate priority
Chris Carney (PA 10) is a freshman from an overwhelmingly Repub district (Bush 60-40 over Kerry). Not a priority.
Ben Chandler (KY 06) was first elected in 2004. Not only is this Repub territory (Bush got 58%) but Chandler is popular. Not a priority.
Jim Clyburn (SC 6) was elected in 1992. This is overwhelmingly a Democratic CD (Kerry got 61%). Considering this, and considering Clyburn’s relatively moderate record on other issues, I’d say we could make this a HIGH PRIORITY. No primary opponents, deadline is March 31.
Jim Cooper (TN 5) was elected in 2002, but was in from 1983-1995, as well. This is a pretty Democratic CD (Kerry got 52%). Cooper might seek some higher office, in which case, we might try for something here, but otherwise, I’d say it’s a moderate priority, since I can’t see us touching Cooper
Jim Costa (CA 20) was first elected in 2004. This is a moderately Democratic district (Kerry got 51%, Gore got 55%). Costa is conservative, for a Dem, and may be vulnerable in this heavily Latino (63%) district. Moderate priority
Bud Cramer (AL 05) has been in Congress since 1990. He’s another conservative Dem in Republican country (Bush got 60%) and he wins by big margins. Not a priority.
Henry Cuellar (TX 28) was elected in 2004. This is a swing district, it went narrowly for Gore and narrowly against Kerry. Moderate priority
Susan Davis (CA 53) was elected in 2000. This is an overwhelmingly Democratic district (Kerry got 61%). She wins easily, but could be more liberal and still win easily. HIGH PRIORITY. No primary opponents yet, and deadline is March 7
Lincoln Davis (side note, did you know there are 8 people named Davis in Congress?) (TN 04) was elected in 2002. This is another Republican district, Bush got 58% against Kerry. Davis is conservative for a Democrat, but the choice is a Repub. Not a priority.
Norm Dicks (WA 6) has been in Congress since 1976. This district is moderately Democratic (Kerry got 53%, Gore 52%) and Dicks is in the middle of the party. I can’t see us getting anyone to challenge this guy – 30 years of serving is a lot – but if we COULD, it would be great. Moderate priority.
John Dingell (MI 15) has been in Congress longer than I’ve been alive, and I’m 47. He got in in 1955. This is a Democratic district (Kerry got 62%), and Dingell is getting old (he turns 81 this summer). A primary opponent might get him to retire. Lynn Rivers might be interested, she lost her seat due to redistricting (and lost the primary to Dingell). (Odd tidbit, Dingell’s father also served in Congress, starting in 1932 – that’s 75 years of a Dingell representing MI)
Joe Donnelly (IN 02) is a freshman rep. This is a Repub. district (Bush got 56% against Kerry) and Donnelly had lost to the previous rep (Chocala) in 2004. I’d say it’s not a priority.
Chet Edwards (TX 17), first elected in 1990, may be the Democrat in the most Republican district. TX 17 went 70% for Bush. Of course, part of that is Texas; still, this is TX, this seat was redistricted for the Repubs, and Edwards IS a Democrat (albeit a conservative one). Despite being in for all that time, his recent elections have not been cakewalks. Not a priority.
Brad Ellsworth (IN 08) is a freshman in an overwhelmingly Republican district (62% for Bush over Kerry). He replaced Hostetler, who was a real right-winger who won big in previous elections, even when he was outspent hugely. Ellsworth is no progressive, that’s for sure, but he’s way better than anyone else we could get here. Not a priority.
Rahm Emanuel (IL 05) was first elected in 2002 in a strongly Democratic district (67% for Kerry). Although he was head of the DCCC for 2006, it’s time he acted like a REAL Democrat, ALL the time. HIGH PRIORITY. Well, it would be nice, but not realistic, and the deadline is passed.
Bob Etheridge (NC 02) was first elected in 1996. This is a somewhat Republican district (54% Bush over Kerry) and yet Etheridge wins easily (over 60%). Etheridge is actually pretty good for this district, but he might run for Senate, maybe challenging Dole in 2008. Not a priority. Likely to go Repub if Etheridge gives up the seat.
Gabrielle Giffords (AZ 08) is a freshman in a moderately Repub district (Bush got 53%). She won pretty easily in an open seat (54-42) and is fairly progressive on other issues. Not a priority.
Kirsten Gillibrand (NY 20) is yet another freshman in a Republican leaning district (Bush got 54% over Kerry). So far, Gillibrand looks good on other issues, and so I don’t think this is a priority.
Charles Gonzalez (TX 20) was first elected in 1998. This is a Democratic district (Kerry got 55%) and Gonzalez is too moderate. HIGH PRIORITY. No opponent and the deadline has passed.
Bart Gordon (TN 6) was first elected in 1984 in this Republican district (Bush got 60% against Kerry, and tied with Gore despite this being Gore’s old seat). Gordon is a moderate, but I don’t see this district going more progressive. Not a priority.
Gene Green (TX 29) was first elected in 1992. This is a Democratic district (Kerry got 56%, Gore got 57% and this is Texas!). Green is a moderate….too moderate for this safe seat. The district is 66% Latino….any progressive Latinos want to make this a HIGH PRIORITY? No opponent, deadline has passed.
Herseth Sandlin (SD AL) was elected in 2004. She is certainly a conservative Dem. South Dakota is interesting – 60% for Bush, but Johnson won the Senate seat in a nail biter, and he’s far more liberal than Herseth. I’m going to claim ignorance and make it a moderate priority.
Baron Hill (IN 09) is a freshman in a Republican district (Bush got 59% against Kerry). He’s no progressive, but he and Mike Sodrel (R) have been trading this seat (Hill won in 2002, Sodrel in 2004, Hill in 2006) and I’m thinking that Hill is better than a Repub. Not a priority
Ruben Hinojosa (TX 15) got elected in 1996, in this swing district (Bush got 55% against Kerry, but beat Gore by only 109 votes). He’s a moderate Democrat, and this district was redistricted to favor the Repubs. I’d say it’s not a priority.
Tim Holden (PA 17) was first elected in 1992. This is a Republican district (Bush got 58%) and Holden has had serious challengers in 2004 and 2002, and might again in 2008. Holden is a conservative Democrat, but that’s the district. Not a priority.
Steny Hoyer (MD 05) was first elected in 1981. This is a solid Democratic district (Kerry got 57%) and Hoyer has a lot to answer for. GO GET HIM! HIGH PRIORITY. James Cusick is running, but might be worse than Hoyer, and his web page makes him look like a nut.
Steve Kagen (WI 8) is another freshman in a fairly Republican district (Bush got 55% against Kerry). He won a close race in an open seat in 2006, and he appears pretty solidly liberal. Write him letters and ask what he was doing, but this isn’t a priority.
Paul Kanjorski (PA 11) was first elected in 1984. This district is moderately Democratic (53% for Kerry, 54% for Gore), and Kanjorski is moderate. Kanjorski always wins easily, so let’s make this a HIGH PRIORITY. Maybe a primary challenge will induce retirement. No opponent, and the deadline has passed
Dale Kildee (MI 05) was first elected in 1976. This is a solidly Democratic district (59% Kerry) and Kildee isn’t bad, but he could be a lot better. He turns 78 this fall, and it’s time to ‘spend time with his family’. GO GET HIM! HIGH PRIORITY. No opponent, deadline past.
Ron Kind (WI 03) was first elected in 1996 in this swing district (Kerry got 51%). Kind is a moderate, and this is a moderate district – but he wins easily in general elections, so this is moderate priority
Nick Lampson (TX 22) took over from the Devil Incarnate aka Tom DeLay. He’s actually not too bad on some issues (Progressive Punch gives him a 76%) and this is a right wing district (Bush got 64%). I’d be surprised if Lampson holds on, and certainly this is not a priority.
Rick Larsen (WA 02) was first elected in 2000. This is a swing district (Kerry got 51%) and Larsen has been OK on other issues. He doesn’t usually win easily in the general, so I’d say this is not a priority.
Sander Levin (MI 12) was first elected in 1982 in this solidly Democratic district (Kerry got 61%). But Levin is a solidly liberal guy on most issues….still, this district is solidly Democratic, so if Levin can’t explain his vote (and I’d like to see him try!) this is a HIGH PRIORITY (also, Levin is 76, he may retire soon). No opponent but the filing deadline is in May.
Dan Lipinski (IL 03) was first elected in 2004 in this solidly Democratic district (Kerry got 59%). This guy inherited the seat from his father, and proudly (???) claims to be the most conservative Democrat in the Illinois delegation. GO GET HIM. HIGH PRIORITY! Well, we tried.
Tim Mahoney (FL 16) is the guy who took over from Mark Foley. This is a fairly Republican district, and Foley probably would have won if not for well….. you know. I don’t know what Mahoney was doing, but this is not a priority.
Jim Marshall (GA 08 aka 03) is a freshman Democrat in a Republican district (55% Bush over Kerry) (note, this used to be GA 03). Marshall faces tough general elections very often, and thus this race is not a priority.
Jim Matheson (UT 02) was first elected in 2000. Of all CDs that send Democrats to DC, this may be the most Republican (66% for Bush). Matheson is, to be sure, a conservative Democrat. But this is Utah. Not a priority.
Mike McIntyre (NC 07) was first elected in 1996. This is Republican territory (Bush got 56% against Kerry) and McIntyre is the right wing of the Democratic party. A primary challenge might even induce him to run as a Repub (and likely win). Not a priority.
Kendrick Meek (FL 17) was first elected in 2002. This is one of the most Democratic districts in the country (83% for Kerry!). Meek is wrong a LOT. This seat should be held by a flaming LIBERAL – and Meek was unopposed in 02, 04 and 06. Why??? GO GET HIM. HIGH PRIORITY. No opponent yet, but they have until May 2.
Charles Melancon (LA 03) was first elected in 2004 in this fairly Republican district (Bush got 58% against Kerry). Melancon is the right wing of the Democratic party, and I’m betting the people of LA are pretty pissed at Repubs about now. HIGH PRIORITY.
Update [2007-5-27 9:25:40 by plf515]: But see comments. I appear to be wrong about Louisiana
Harry Mitchell (AZ 05) is a freshman in a fairly Republican district (Bush got 54% against Kerry). He seems decent on other issues. Not a priority.
Alan Mollohan (WV 01) was first elected in 1982. He typically wins easily in this heavily Republican district. He’s not my favorite Democrat, but not as far right as some, and this is not a priority.
Dennis Moore (KS 03) was first elected in 1998. This is a Republican district (Bush got 55% against Kerry), and Moore isn’t a bad guy. Not a priority.
John Murtha (PA 12) has been in Congress since 1974. This is a Democratic district (Kerry only got 51%, but Gore got 55%) and Murtha is pretty conservative. He won’t be easy to beat, but let’s go for it. HIGH PRIORITY.
No opponent, deadline past.
Solomon Ortiz (TX 27) was first elected in 1982. Considering this is Texas, Bush didn’t do well here (55% against Kerry, but he lost to Gore by a few hundred votes) and Ortiz is the right wing of the party. HIGH PRIORITY. No opponent, deadline past.
Collin Peterson (MN 07) was first elected in 1990. This is a pretty Republican district (Bush got 55% against Kerry) but this guy is way to the right of the party. The Almanac of American Politics calls him a “different kind of Democrat” – yeah, the Republican kind! HIGH PRIORITY. Update [2007-5-27 20:19:31 by plf515]: But see comments below, this may not be as high priority as I think
Earl Pomeroy (ND AL) has been in Congress since 1992. I don’t get ND. It gave Bush 63%, but both senators, and lone representative are all Democrats! OTOH, its Republican governor won in a landslide. I’ll call it not a priority, but if someone knows something?
Nick Rahall (WV 03) was first elected in 1976. This is a swing district (it went for Bush over Kerry, but Gore over Bush). Rahall seems pretty decent on the issues, so I can’t say this is a priority
Ciro Rodriguez (TX 23) just beat Henry Bonilla in 2006. This is a solidly Repub district, and Rodriguez is not a bad guy (83 on Progressive Punch). Not a priority.
Mike Ross (AR 04) was first elected in 2000. This is a swing district (Bush over Kerry, Gore over Bush); Ross, though, seems to run unopposed. Should we change that? Moderate priority.
Dutch Ruppersberger (MD 02) was first elected in 2002. This district is moderately Democratic (54% for Kerry) and Ruppersberger is in the middle of the Democratic party. Still, a challenge could be good – this one isn’t going Repub. Moderate priority.
John Salazar (CO 03) was first elected in 2004. This is a moderately Republican district (Bush got 55% against Kerry), Salazar isn’t too bad (77 on Progressive Punch) and I say it’s not a priority.
Allyson Schwartz (PA 13) was first elected in 2004. This is a Democratic district (Kerry got 56%), and, in general, Schwartz is a liberal (88 on Progresive Punch), but still, what was she thinking? Moderate priority.
David Scott (GA 13) was first elected in 2002. This is a solidly Democratic district (Kerry got 64%) and Scott is a conservative Democrat. HIGH PRIORITY.
Joe Sestak (PA 07) is a freshman. This is a swing district (Kerry got 53%). Sestak has been good on other Iraq votes, so I’d say let’s try to figure out what he was thinking before deciding.
Heath Shuler (NC 11) is a freshman, and this is a solidly Repub district (Bush got 58% against Kerry). Not a priority.
Ike Skelton (MO 04) has been in Congress since 1976. He’s a blue dog, but this is a Republican district (Bush got 64% against Kerry) and this is not a priority.
Vic Snyder (AR 02) was first elected in 1996. This is a swing district (Bush got 51% against Kerry) and Snyder is pretty good on other issues. Not a priority.
Zack Space (OH 18) is a freshman. This is Bush territory (Bush got 57% against Kerry). Space won big in 2006, he seems to be right on most things, so this is not a priority.
John Spratt (SC 5) was first elected in 1982. This is a Republican district (Bush got 58% against Kerry) and, that considered, Spratt is not bad (76 on Progressive Punch). Not a priority
Bart Stupak (MI 01) was first elected in 1992. This is a swing district (Bush got 53% against Kerry), Stupak is scarcely a liberal, but not really a true blue dog. He often faces general election problems, so this is not a priority.
John Tanner (TN 08) was first elected in 1988. This is a swing district (Bush beat Kerry, Gore beat Bush). Tanner has won all the general elections easily, making this a moderate priority.
Gene Taylor (MS 4) was first elected in 1989 in this strongly Republican district (Bush got 68% against Kerry). Taylor is a conservative Democrat, but he is the best we are going to get here. If he retires or gets primaried, this would be Repub. Not a priority
Bennie Thompson (MS 02) was first elected in 1993. This is a solidly
Democratic district (Kerry got 59%) and it deserves a solidly Democratic rep. HIGH PRIORITY. Dorothy Benford is running
Peter Visclosky (IN 01) was first elected in 1984, and this is another moderately Democratic district (Kerry got 55%). Visclosky is pretty liberal, so I want to know what he’s thinking, or else, HIGH PRIORITY. No opponent, deadline next week
Tim Walz (MN 01) is a freshman in a swing district (Bush got 51% against Kerry). Walz seems good on most issues, and this is not a priority.
Debbie Wasserman Schultz (FL 20) was first elected in 2004. This is a solidly Democratic district (Kerry got 64%) and Schultz wins easily. She’s generally pretty liberal, but, I’d say, a moderate priority
Charles Wilson (OH 06) is a freshman in a swing district (Bush got 51% vs. Kerry). He has generally been pretty liberal, and is likely to be challenged by Republicans. Not a priority
Summary:
Of these 86 Democrats, 53 (if I’ve counted right) are in districts that went for Bush over Kerry. Most of these 53 are on the conservative side of the Democratic party, but that is hardly surprising. For those votes to change, the constituencies have to change. So, when I say “not a priority” I mean a PRIMARY is not a priority. But grass roots efforts ARE a priority…..make people see that Republicanism is stupid! This is especially true in the many swing districts.
Again, if I counted correctly, there are 25 high priority candidates on the list. That’s a LOT. We won’t win 25 primaries….but maybe we will move 25 representatives a bit to the left. And there are a few who might retire.
Next steps:
1. In the swing districts, let’s try to set up campaigns to influence the constituencies.
2. In the high priority districts, how can we find people to run?
3. Have we got a list of vulnerable Repubs? I can work on one, but I don’t want to duplicate effort.
4. Do something similar for the Senate – a list of Democrats is here
Update [2007-5-27 11:0:26 by plf515]:
5. Make a list of Democrats in vulnerable seats who did the right thing, and support them
sources:
Almanac of American Politics
Washington Post votes database
National Journal ratings
Progressive punch