The Senate – a worst case scenario

One of the major developments this cycle thus far has been Republican recruiting successes for the Senate.  At the beginning of the 2010 cycle, it appeared that the Democrats had a good chance of picking up seats for the third consecutive cycle.  But due to a multitude of happenings, the situation has turned on it’s head.  A lot of that has to do with the change in the national environment, but a lot of it is due to individual events independent from the environment.  Let’s run down the laundry list. (Note that I don’t think all these moves weren’t necessarily the right moves, I’m just sticking with the electoral ramifications)

Phase I – The governor appointments to the White House

A.Arizona – Janet Napolitano is appointed by Obama to be secretary of homeland security.  This takes off the board what could have been a blockbuster race in AZ between McCain and Napolitano.

B.Kansas – Kathleen Sebelius is picked by Obama to be secretary of health and human services.  This takes off the board a potential pickup in Kansas, where Sam Brownback is leaving to run for governor.

Phase II – Republican recruiting success

1.Delaware – Perhaps the most glaring of all examples this cycle, Mike Castle, DE’s lone house rep, unexpectedly launches a bid for Senate at the age of 70.  Beau Biden, Delaware’s attorney general and presumed Senate secessor to his father, vice president Joe Biden, declines to run.  This flips the seat from Safe D to Likely R.  

2.Illinois – wildly popular attorney general Lisa Madigan, the Democrats’ top prospect to replace president Barack Obama, declines to run for the Senate (and the governorship).  Perhaps the only person that could win the seat for the Republicans, representative Mark Kirk, does.  This puts what should be a safe seat into tossup status against treasurer Alexi Giannoulias.

3.North Dakota – Byron Dorgan looked like a shoo-in for re-election, just so long as that one shoe by the name of governor John Hoeven didn’t drop.  Well the shoe dropped, and Dorgan dived out of the way to avoid a sure loss.

Phase III – Unpopular incumbents

4.Colorado – Ken Salazar’s appointment as Interior Secretary was followed by what some call a lackluster appointment of Michael Bennet.  I think the GOP was going to strongly contest this seat regardless however.

5.Nevada – majority leader Harry Reid is incredibly unpopular in Nevada, and despite the Republicans’ recruiting woes here, he is no better than even money (and perhaps worse) of beating the republican nominee.

6.Arkansas – Blanche Lincoln’s constant waffling and selling out of democratic principles has killed her standing with the base in AR, and prompted Lt governor Bill Halter to primary her.  Her standing with independents is also in the crapper, making it hard to imagine her winning.  Halter’s liberal politics would seem to make it a tough race for him as well if he wins the primary.

7.California – Barbara Boxer appears now to be in hotter water than any of us anticipated, barely ahead of opponents Tom Campbell and Carly Fiorina, with the consensus being that Campbell is the most electable of the republican challengers.  I’m not sure we can really group Boxer in with Reid and Lincoln as her situation isn’t nearly as dire, but a lot of the same dynamics are at play here.  

Phase IV – The Flip-Flopper

8.Pennsylvania – Arlen Specter decided that the GOP’s run to crazy had driven him out of the party, and he flipped to the Dems, presumably to avoid losing the primary to Pat Toomey.  Now those two will face off in the general election.

Phase V – Evan Bayh

9.Indiana – This seat was also looking to be an easy democratic retention until Bayh bolted just days before the filing deadline.  It now appears that the democrats aren’t as bad off as feared, as Brad Ellsworth will take on either Coats or Hostettler for the GOP.

Now, I’ve mentioned 9 vulnerable democratic seats.  In rough order of flipping likelihood, they are ND, DE, AR, NV, CO, IN, IL, PA, and CA.  If the Republicans were to run the table, without losing any of their own seats, then control of the chamber would be split 50/50, with the vice president breaking ties.  But let’s say that the Republicans want to take control of the chamber.  There are many ways in which they could conceivably do it, and in a “sky is falling” type situation, could actually win firm control of the chamber.  If you don’t like horror stories, I suggest you stop reading now.

If you’re still on board, here we go.

10.New York – It’s been claimed as unlikely that George Pataki will challenge Kirsten Gillibrand.  But that’s what they said about John Hoeven and Mike Castle.  If Pataki jumps in this race turns into a toss-up.  

11.Wisconsin – Another situation similar to Delaware and New York, where everybody is waiting to see what Tommy Thompson does.  If he gets in, the polls show that his race against Russ Feingold turns into a toss-up as well.  The fact that the polls show Feingold in such bad shape shocks me, but it is what it is, I guess.

12.Washington – The Republicans have several options here that could be competitive and possibly beat Patty Murray.  Dino Rossi I know has been mentioned a lot, but another strong contender is Dave Reichert.  If he were to get in, this race would become very similar to Illinois, in which the one guy that could probably win the race does get in.

13.Hawaii – Now I know you’re thinking this is ridiculous throwing Hawaii up there, but what if somehow, Daniel Inouye suddenly retires and governor Linda Lingle runs for the open seat.  That would open up another very blue seat for a potential Team Red takeover.  

14.Maryland – Now admittedly, this isn’t likely, but what if that report from last week that Bob Ehrlich was serious about challenging Barbara Mikulski was true?  What if fearing a competitive race, Mikulski retired, turning a safe D seat into a Lean/Likely R one in a hugely blue seat.  It’s already happened in nearby Delaware.

Now, if this nightmare scenario were to play out in total, the Democrats would retain just 3 seats in the 2010 cycle, New York (Schumer), Oregon (Wyden), and Vermont (Leahy), who are unassailable.  The Republicans would hold a 54-46 advantage in the chamber just 2 years after facing a democratic filibuster-proof majority.

On the other hand, the Democrats gaining seats is probably more likely than this pie in the sky GOP outlook on things.  

Next time, I’ll have the opposite viewpoint, one in which the Democrats could actually pull off gaining more than a few seats this cycle.

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 11/March Ratings Update

So, after 50 states and 435 districts, we have reached the end of our first journey through the House of Representatives.  In this part, I will provide a summary of everything we’ve seen, and the total big board for 2010 will be unearthed.  But as we all know, things can change rather quickly in politics and virtually everything is fluid.  Indeed, it’s been almost a month and a half since I completed the first section of this series, and many of my ratings are no longer where I put them back then.  So in addition to providing the big board, I’ll have my first update of race ratings changes.  So this will essentially serve as a double post.

Here are the total # of seats I have in each rating category through part 10.  Note that all categories except for “Safe R” and “Safe D” are what I consider to be “On the board”.  Districts in italic text represent pickups.  At present, the national score is Republicans +20 seats.  The Democrats are forecast to pick up 5 seats (PA-6, MD-1, LA-2, IL-10, and CA-3).  The Republicans are forecast to pick up 25 seats (NH-1, NY-24, NY-29, MD-1, PA-11, VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8, MI-7, IN-8, OH-1, AL-2, MS-1, LA-3, TX-17, AR-1, AR-2, IA-3, KS-3, CO-4, NV-3, ID-1, and WA-3).

2010 Big Board:

Safe Dem – 161 seats

Likely Dem – 41 seats

CA-36 (Harman)

CA-47 (Sanchez)

HI-1 (Open)

CO-3 (Salazar)

CO-7 (Perlmutter)

NM-1 (Heinrich)

AZ-1 (Kirkpatrick)

AZ-8 (Giffords)

NV-1 (Berkley)

OR-5 (Schrader)

SD-1 (Herseth-Sandlin)

IL-8 (Bean)

IL-11 (Halvorson)

WI-7 (Obey)

MN-1 (Walz)

MS-4 (Taylor)

LA-2 (Cao)

TX-23 (Rodriguez)

TX-27 (Ortiz)

IN-2 (Donnelly)

OH-6 (Wilson)

OH-10 (Kucinich)

SC-5 (Spratt)

GA-2 (Bishop)

FL-2 (Boyd)

VA-11 (Connolly)

KY-3 (Yarmuth)

NC-11 (Shuler)

NJ-12 (Holt)

DE-1 (Open)

PA-3 (Dahlkemper)

PA-4 (Altmire)

PA-17 (Holden)

MA-4 (Frank)

MA-10 (Open)

RI-1 (Open)

CT-4 (Himes)

NY-4 (McCarthy)

NY-13 (McMahon)

NY-20 (Murphy)

NY-25 (Maffei)

Lean Dem – 24 seats

CA-11 (McNerney)

AZ-5 (Mitchell)

MO-4 (Skelton)

ND-1 (Pomeroy)

IL-14 (Foster)

WI-8 (Kagen)

MI-9 (Peters)

OH-13 (Sutton)

OH-16 (Boccieri)

OH-18 (Space)

GA-8 (Marshall)

FL-8 (Grayson)

FL-24 (Kosmas)

VA-9 (Boucher)

WV-1 (Mollohan)

KY-6 (Chandler)

NC-8 (Kissell)

NJ-3 (Adler)

PA-8 (Murphy)

PA-10 (Carney)

ME-1 (Pingree)

NH-2 (Open)

CT-5 (Murphy)

NY-1 (Bishop)

Toss Up – 31 seats

CA-3 (Lungren)

CO-4 (Markey)

NM-2 (Teague)

NV-3 (Titus)

ID-1 (Minnick)

WA-3 (Open)

WA-8 (Reichert)

IA-3 (Boswell)

AR-1 (Open)

IL-10 (Open)

MS-1 (Childers)

TX-17 (Edwards)

IN-9 (Hill)

MI-7 (Schauer)

OH-1 (Driehaus)

OH-15 (Kilroy)

FL-22 (Klein)

VA-2 (Nye)

VA-5 (Perriello)

TN-4 (Davis)

TN-8 (Open)

MD-1 (Kratovil)

PA-6 (Gerlach)

PA-7 (Open)

PA-11 (Kanjorski)

PA-12 (Open)

NH-1 (Shea-Porter)

NY-19 (Hall)

NY-23 (Owens)

NY-24 (Arcuri)

NY-29 (Open)

Lean Rep – 14 seats

AZ-3 (Open)

KS-3 (Open)

NE-2 (Terry)

MN-6 (Bachmann)

AL-2 (Bright)

LA-3 (Open)

IN-8 (Open)

OH-2 (Schmidt)

OH-12 (Tiberi)

SC-2 (Wilson)

FL-10 (Young)

FL-12 (Open)

FL-25 (Open)

PA-15 (Dent)

Likely Rep – 24 seats

CA-19 (Open)

CA-25 (McKeon)

CA-44 (Calvert)

CA-45 (Bono Mack)

CA-48 (Campbell)

CA-50 (Bilbray)

AK-1 (Young)

MO-8 (Emerson)

AR-2 (Open)

KS-2 (Jenkins)

KS-4 (Open)

IL-13 (Biggert)

MN-3 (Paulsen)

AL-3 (Rogers)

AL-5 (Griffith)

TX-32 (Sessions)

MI-3 (Open)

MI-11 (McCotter)

SC-1 (Open)

VA-1 (Wittman)

KY-2 (Guthrie)

TN-6 (Open)

NJ-7 (Lance)

NY-26 (Lee)

Solid Rep – 140 seats

If you do the math, the Republicans currently have 178 seats on their side of the ledger, meaning that the Democrats would need to sweep all the toss ups to retain their current amount of 257 seats.  Either that, or they would have to pick up some seats from the Republican side of the ledger in exchange for losing some toss ups.  Obviously, the chances of Democrats retaining a 257 seat majority is very minute.   On the flip side, if the Democrats were to lose all 31 toss up seats, they would be dropped to 226 seats to the Republicans’ 209, meaning that they Republicans would still need to pick off 9 seats on the Democratic side of the ledger while losing none of their own in order to regain the House majority.  My gut instinct tells me that this outcome isn’t very likely either.

The point is that even in a situation where a vast majority of the toss ups break one way or the other, the balance of power in the House is not likely to change all that much except perhaps on major/controversial legislation such as health care reform.

Changing gears now, here is the list of ratings changes that I’m making for the second half of February/first half of March:

New York-29 – from Toss Up to Lean Republican

Utah-2 – from Safe Democrat to Likely Democrat

Ohio-13 – from Lean Democrat to Likely Democrat

Kansas-3 – from Lean Republican to Likely Republican

Florida-10 – from Lean Republican to Likely Republican

Alabama-2 – from Lean Republican to Toss Up

North Carolina-8 – from Lean Democrat to Likely Democrat

New Hampshire-2 – from Lean Democrat to Toss Up

Massachusetts-10 – from Likely Democrat to Lean Democrat

New York-13 – from Likely Democrat to Lean Democrat

Florida-8 – from Lean Democrat to Toss Up

Explanations – NY-29 & MA-10 have opened up since the time we last ran through those districts, as Eric Massa and William Delahunt have moved on.  NY-29 now looks like a good pickup opportunity for Team Red, and though they are also optimistic about MA-10, I give pause there because of how dominant the democrats have been in congressional elections there outside of Scott Brown’s shocking upset win for Senate two months ago.  AL-2 produced a shockingly good poll result for Bobby Bright a few weeks ago, so that rating changes in the democratic direction.  However, I’m not willing to pull the seat back into democratic control without some corroborating evidence.  North Carolina-8 also produced some strong polling for Larry Kissell, changing its rating.  

With it looking more likely that Charlie Justice just doesn’t have it, and that Bill Young is sticking around, FL-10 moves in the republican direction.  The democrats still don’t have a qualified challenger in KS-3, so that one moves right.  I think I overreacted somewhat upon hearing about Tom Ganley’s entry into the OH-13 race, really I don’t think an incumbent as popular as Betty Sutton , in a district this democratic has much to worry about.  With the virtual certainty that Mike McMahon will lose the WFP ballot line in his November race, the chance of a republican pickup there increases marginally.  In NH-2, the odds are growing that Charlie Bass will win the republican primary, increasing the chances of a pickup there, though I’m not moving the seat yet.  It’s becoming increasingly obvious that Alan Grayson won’t be able to stay out of the news, or stop saying controversial things before November.  I’m starting to fear that independents could turn against him en masse, and a right-wing Some Dude could pull off an upset, so his race is now a Toss Up.  

And lastly, a procedural move in UT-2.  As a rule, I always keep on the board races in which the incumbent is in a district that (according to the PVI) favors the opposing party by +10 points or more.  According to that standard, Jim Matheson’s race is now Likely D.  If you were wondering why I have Gene Taylor’s MS-4 on the Big Board, that’s the reason.  

For now, I’m not going to flip any seats from one party to another, so the score remains Republicans +20.  There were some seats I considered changing, but I’ll leave them be for now, especially with health care reform on the precipice of passing, which could change the dynamics of a LOT of races.  Beginning in April I will be updating the national score twice a month, and then I’ll probably do it once a week in the final 4-5 weeks before the election.

And so, the journey begins…  

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 10

Hello, and welcome to the 10th and final installment of my 2010 baseline predictions for the House of Representatives.  In this section I will cover the Pacific Coast.  This region officially contains Washington, Oregon, California, and Hawaii, but for division purposes I slid Washington and Oregon over to the Rocky Mountain region, leaving only Hawaii and California.  This is arguably the most liberal region of the United States, outside of maybe the Northeast region.  At present, Democrats hold 36 of 55 seats in the region, the Republicans have 19.  Because of high Obama approval ratings and a leftward shift in general, this might be an area where the Dems could hold even in 2010 and maybe even gain seats.

First off, a recap of where we’ve been, and where we still have to go*:

Northeast – Rep +3 – (Rep pickups of NH-1, NY-24, NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even – (Rep pickups of PA-11, MD-1, Dem pickups of PA-6, DE-1)

Upper South – Rep +5 (Rep pickups of VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8)

South Atlantic – Even – (no pickups on either side)

Eastern Great Lakes – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of OH-1, MI-7, IN-8)

South Gulf – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of AL-2, MS-1, LA-3, TX-17, Dem pickup of LA-2)

Western Great Lakes – Dem +1 (Dem pickup of IL-10)

Central Plains – Rep +4 (Rep pickups of IA-3, AR-1, AR-2, KS-3)

Rocky Mountains – Rep +4 (Rep pickups of CO-4, NV-3, ID-1, WA-3)

Pacific Coast –

Total National Score – Rep +21

* – Please note that in most cases these ratings were done prior to any polling becoming known.  

Do note that, despite what said in the beginning, this actually will not be the last diary in the series.  Following this diary, I’ll be going back over the whole list and seeing if, in lue of polls and other data from the last month, if I want to change any of my picks.  At that point I’ll post Part 11, in which I lock in my selections and I’ll show the entire list of races “on the board”, ie: those races between Likely D and Likely R.  All races will be re-visited as we head toward November.

California-1 – Mike Thompson/Democrat – Here’s a district that covers most of the northern California coastline north of the Bay Area.  It’s an easy winner for Thompson, who is entrenched.

District PVI – D+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-2 – Wally Herger/Republican – Herger actually got a moderately tough re-election in 2008, winning by a margin mirroring the presidential vote in this northern CA district.  That being said, this year’s race isn’t expected to be close at all.  

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-3 – Dan Lungren/Republican – Enjoy this one, folks, because this is bound to be a tough fight.  Lungren entered office in 2004 when this suburban Sacramento district was arguably much more conservative.  It’s taken a shift to the left, as evidenced by Barack Obama’s 49-48 plurality win over John McCain, and Lungren only survived against an underfunded Dem challenger 49-44.  This time he’s up against much tougher opposition.  Physician Ami Bera has launched a challenge and has cleared the democratic primary field.  And so far, Bera is leading Lungren in the fundraising race, 871k to 732k, and also leads in cash on hand by a slightly larger margin.  It’s uncertain just how good a campaigner Bera is, but if he is, Lungren will have to face that and an environment in California that has arguably bucked the national trend and stayed blue.  I haven’t done this much in this series, but I’m picking a minor upset here, Bera defeats Lungren, making him only the 3rd Rep incumbent to go down this cycle (Jim Gerlach in PA-6 and Anh Cao in LA-2 were the others)

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Dem Pickup (5th overall)

National Score – Rep +20

California-4 – Tom McClintock/Republican – Surprisingly, this northeast California district was the site of one of the closest House races in the nation in 2008, as Air Force pilot Charlie Brown came within several hundred votes of beating McClintock.  It appears the democrats have pretty much ceded this race in 2010, the only confirmed candidate is Clint Curtis, who formerly lived in FL-24 and ran in the 06 primary there.  It is worth noting that McClintock is facing a primary challenge from medical firm executive Michael Babich.  If somehow Babich pulls that out the race could still get interesting, but I doubt that happens.  

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-5 – Doris Matsui/Democrat – The Sacramento-based 5th is a liberal bastion, as is much of northern California.  Matsui is safe.  (Hint hint, lots of one sentence reviews ahead)

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-6 – Lynn Woolsey/Democrat – This coastal district lies to the north of the bay, and is extremely democratic.  Safe.

District PVI – D+23

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-7 – George Miller/Democrat – The 7th consists of much of the northeastern Bay Area.  It’s more democratic territory, and safe for Miller.

District PVI – D+19

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-8 – Nancy Pelosi/Democrat – Central San Francisco is home to Pelosi, the Speaker of the House.  It’s funny reading on certain blogs, the people that say random stuff like “Pelosi needs to start worrying about HER re-election.”  If they were talking about a  primary challenge then maybe, but the idea of this seat ever going republican is just pure idiocy.

District PVI – D+35

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold  

California-9 – Barbara Lee/Democrat – This district consists mostly of Central Oakland, and is the most democratic district in California, and the 6th most democratic in the nation.  Safe.

District PVI – D+37

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-10 – John Garamendi/Democrat – Garamendi actually had a crappy election in the 2009 special election here, winning by an underwhelming 55-43 against David Harmer.  I don’t imagine it’s because of weakness on Garamendi’s part, as it could be the fault of the democratic electorate instead.  Luckily, the republicans don’t have a confirmed candidate for November yet.

District PVI – D+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-11 – Jerry McNerney/Democrat – The 11th used to be a republican district, but times are a changing here.  McNerney won this seat in 2006 over disgraced ex-Rep Richard Pombo, and held it by 10 points in 2008, mirroring Obama’s 9-point win.  McNerney has fundraised fairly well this cycle, pulling in 1.05 million to this point.  More good news for McNerney is that the republican primary looks crowded and tough.  U.S Marshal Tony Amador, vineyard owner Brad Goehring, non-profit org vice president Elizabeth Emken, and former 10th district nominee David Harmer are all alive in the race for the nomination.  Goehring has the fundraising lead, Harmer has the lead in name ID.  It’s hard to say what’s going to transpire here, but McNerney has set himself up fairly well I think.  

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

California-12 – Jacqueline Speier/Democrat – The 12th stretches from south San Francisco to San Jose, and like much of the region, is very democratic.  Safe.

District PVI – D+23

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-13 – Pete Stark/Democrat – This district on the east said of the bay is again, very liberal and very democratic.  Stark is safe.

District PVI – D+22

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-14 – Anna Eshoo/Democrat – Moving to the south of the Bay Area proper now, but nothing’s changed yet, still very democratic territory and safe.

District PVI – D+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-15 – Mike Honda/Democrat – This somewhat gerrymandered district runs from San Jose down through Santa Clara.  It’s less democratic than the central Bay Area districts are, but we’re still a ways away from republicans competing still.  

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-16 – Zoey Lofgren/Democrat – This district lies to the east of CA-15, and is the last Bay Area district, lying mostly in Santa Clara county.  It’s another easy win for the democrats and for Lofgren.

District PVI – D+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-17 – Sam Farr/Democrat – This district takes in much of the central California coast, stretching from Monterey Bay southward.  It, like most coastal California districts, is solidly democratic.

District PVI – D+19

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-18 – Dennis Cardoza/Democrat – We now move toward the Central Valley, which is largely split apart between the democratic west and republican east.  This district, which lies on the east side of the imaginary line and contains Stockton and parts of Modesto, leans democratic but not overly.  Cardoza went unopposed in 2008, and so far only one republican, Mike Berryhill, has stepped up to challenge him.  Berryhill is well behind in the fundraising chase, and I don’t have much data on him.  Cook has this race at likely, but I don’t buy it.  

District PVI – D+4

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-19 – Open/Republican – On the other side of the barrier lies the 19th, which takes in parts of Modesto and Fresno as well as rural areas.  As with most open seats, the primary field on both sides is cloudy.  State senator Jeff Denham is Radanovich’s preferred choice, but ex-Rep Richard Pombo is also in the race, along with former Fresno mayor Jim Patterson, who has the backing of SSP favorite, the Club for Growth.  On the democratic side, Mariposa County planning commission member Les Marsden is running, as is state representative Lorraine Goodwin.  I don’t have any fundraising data thus far, but the republicans clearly have a deeper bench here.  The wild card is Pombo.  If he wins the primary I think the Dems have a shot at a pickup because of his ethical problems.  Any other permutation and Team Red probably wins easily, so my rating will reflect these possibilities.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

California-20 – Jim Costa/Democrat – This district is back on the west side of the Central Valley boundary, taking in the west part of Fresno county and the most democratic parts of Kern county, including most of Bakersfield.  Costa is very popular here and won re-election by nearly 50 points in 2008.  Only one challenger, Andy Vidak, is going at this race for Team Red, he’s raised less than 60k thus far.  And yet, Cook again has this one at likely instead of solid.  I don’t know what he’s looking at.  CQ and the others all have it solid as far as I know.

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-21 – Devin Nunes/Republican – On the east side of the boundary again, the 21st is heavily republican, and should be no problem for Nunes to hold onto.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-22 – Kevin McCarthy/Republican – This mostly rural district is the most republican in California, an easy hold for McCarthy.  

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-23 – Lois Capps/Democrat – The ridiculously shaped 23rd, which is almost literally the grains of sand running along the coast of south central California, is I guess democratic.  (Can fish vote?)

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-24 – Elton Gallegly/Republican – This district essentially takes in the same generally area as the 23rd except it starts on the hills overlooking the beach and moves inland.  It’s a marginally republican district that was carried by Obama in 2008 50-47.  That being said, a strong democratic challenge to Gallegly isn’t very likely.  

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-25 – Buck McKeon/Republican – In the 2008 presidential race, this district was one of the biggest shockers in the nation, as Obama won a 49-48 plurality over McCain in this republican stronghold.  McKeon held on to beat Jackie Conaway by a 57-42 mark despite the top ballot surge, but it was his lowest re-election total since his initial election in 1992.  I think this district bears some watching because Conaway is running again, and McKeon hasn’t declared for re-election yet and doesn’t have much cash on hand either, so it’s possible that he might have retirement on the brain.  If that happens, this could turn into a pickup opportunity, so I’ll keep it on the board just in case.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-26 – David Dreier/Republican – Starting to move toward the LA area now, the 26th contains affluent suburbs like Arcadia and Rancho Cucamonga.  Obama won this usually republican district by a 51-47 count, but like many republican incumbents, Dreier still managed a 12% win over Russ Warner.  Still, like McKeon in CA-25, that was a very low total compared to normal.  Warner is back for another run, but he’s facing a tough, entrenched incumbent who is the ranking Republican on the powerful House Rules Committee.  I don’t like his odds of success.

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-27 – Brad Sherman/Democrat – The Burbank-based 27th is fairly democratic, so I don’t think Sherman has too much to worry about.  

District PVI – D+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-28 – Howard Berman/Democrat – We’re moving closer to central LA now, hitting it’s northwestern suburbs like San Fernando.  Berman is safe.

District PVI – D+23

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-29 – Adam Schiff/Democrat – The Pasadena-based 29th isn’t quite as democratic as the 28th, but it’s still on the fringes of what the republicans could pick up even if the sky was falling for Team Blue.  Schiff is safe.

District PVI – D+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-30 – Henry Waxman/Democrat – One of the most powerful Dems in the House, Waxman’s district takes in Santa Monica and parts of west LA county.  It’s safe territory.

District PVI – D+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-31 – Xavier Becerra/Democrat – We’re now in the metropolitan core of Los Angeles, this district stretching from downtown to the north side.  Safe.

District PVI – D+29

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-32 – Judy Chu/Democrat – This district covers LA’s eastern inner suburbs mostly, and Chu won a 2009 special election for this seat by a wide margin.  She’s safe.

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-33 – Open/Democrat – This western LA seat, which houses Culver City and most of Hollywood’s famous studios and stuff, is open as Diane Watson is retiring.  Doesn’t really matter though, as this is the 11th most democratic district in the US.  

District PVI – D+35

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-34 – Lucille Royal-Allard/Democrat – This district comprises most of East LA, and is very heavily democratic not unlike the rest of the region.  Safe.

District PVI – D+22

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-35 – Maxine Waters/Democrat – South-central LA is where we find ourselves now, and like so many other LA districts, this one’s a cinch for Team Blue

District PVI – D+31

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-36 – Jane Harman/Democrat – Down into the shores south of LA, Redondo Beach-ish area, is where we find the seat of disgraced Rep Jane Harman.  In the wake of her flap with the FBI over trying to secure a chairmanship through very unethical means, teacher Marcy Winograd is attempting to primary Harman, and it’s looking like it could be an interesting race.  The republicans have two candidates here, financial advisor Peter Kesterson and Mattie Fien, founder of the Institute for Persian Studies.  My guess is if Harman survives the primary there’s a chance that Team Red could score an upset here.

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-37 – Laura Richardson/Democrat – This district runs the whole economic continuum, stretching from the depths of Compton to more affluent suburbs.  It’s also safe democratic territory for Richardson and Team Blue.  

District PVI – D+26

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-38 – Grace Napolitano/Democrat – Two more districts to go in the eastern LA suburbs for Team Blue, this one the first.  Safe.

District PVI – D+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-39 – Linda Sanchez/Democrat – Another safe democratic district on the east and southeast side of LA.

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-40 – Ed Royce/Republican – Moving into Orange County now, Royce’s district is usually very republican but Obama put up a strong showing, only falling by 4% to McCain.  But the well entrenched Royce won re-election easily by 25% over Christine Avalos.  I don’t really see this one becoming competitive.  

District PVI – R+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-41 – Jerry Lewis/Republican – This district contains most of San Bernardino County outside of the metroplex, and should be an easy hold for Lewis.  

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-42 – Gary Miller/Republican – This district is a suburban/exurban mix and contains some of the most conservative parts of the LA metro area.  Safe.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-43 – Joe Baca/Democrat –  The San-Bernardino-based 43rd is a strong democratic bastion, much stronger than many realize.  Baca’s sitting pretty.  

District PVI – D+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-44 – Ken Calvert/Republican – Well, here’s what, on paper, could probably have been the democrats’ best shot at a pickup in California this cycle.  Ken Calvert, an embattled incumbent who has struggled with ethical problems, barely survived 51-49 against democrat Bill Hedrick in 2008, while Obama won 50-49 in a close vote against McCain.  Calvert is facing a primary challenge from commercial real estate broker Chris Riggs, which doesn’t look overly problematic but it’s possible the district’s GOP voters might want an untainted candidate.  Hedrick, whose race wasn’t on the radar last cycle, certainly is now, but something isn’t right.  His fundraising has been downright horrible thus far at 179k, compared to 869k for Calvert.  That’s a huge advantage, and that combined with incumbency is going to make things very difficult on Hedrick assuming the GOP primary doesn’t get ugly.  

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

California-45 – Mary Bono Mack/Republican – Bono Mack has taken a lot of hits from within her own party because of her voting record, most notably on her vote for cap-n-trade.  However, after several lawmakers threatened to primary her, Bono Mack is good to go for the general.  Despite Obama’s 52-47 win here last cycle, she still cruised to re-election by 17% against state representative Julie Bornstein.  The democrats have a very strong recruit in this district, Palm Springs mayor Stephen Pougnet, which could make this district interesting.  Bono Mack is currently leading the fundraising chase 992k to 553k, though the cash on hand race is closer.  All in all, Pougnet’s total is still pretty good.  I could see this race flipping if enough Republicans refuse to vote on this race because of Bono Mack’s lack of conservatism, but ultimately I think she’s going to win.  

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

California-46 – Dana Rohrabacher/Republican – Rohrabacher had a more difficult re-election than usual in 2008, winning by only 9% over democrat Debbie Cook.  His re-election looks like it will be much easier this time as Team Blue isn’t putting up much of a fight here.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-47 – Loretta Sanchez/Democrat – Sanchez is a fairly well entrenched incumbent, and while this district isn’t incredibly democratic, it did go for Barack Obama by 23% in 2008, and she cruised to re-election by over 40 points.  Given that, you wouldn’t expect a strong republican challenger to emerge, much less two, but that’s what we had as Van Tran and Quag Pham were headed for a primary battle until Pham bolted last week.  Tran is fundraising fairly well, but trails in the money race 719k to 448k.  Honestly, even if the red wave is big, it would be very hard to see Sanchez, who’s mostly beloved in her district, go down.

District PVI – D+4

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-48 – John Campbell/Republican – This district was another shocker in the presidential race of 08, as Obama fought to a 49-48 plurality win over McCain after Bush walloped Kerry by 20 four years earlier.  Campbell beat back his democratic challenger by 15% that same year, but this year the democrats found a strong challenger in Irvine city councilwoman Beth Krom.  Krom has been heralded as a solid campaigner, and she’ll need to be since the district at best leans republican and she’s losing to Campbell 949k to 299k in the money race, putting her in a similar position to Bill Hedrick in neighboring CA-44.  Thus, I give this race a similar rating.  

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

California-49 – Darrell Issa/Republican – We’re getting close folks, into the northern San Diego exurbs now.  Issa is safe here.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-50 – Brian Bilbray/Republican – Bilbray has had a rough go of it in recent elections since his 05 special election win, he hasn’t been elected with a double digit vote total yet, winning the special by 5, his 06 re-election by 9, and his 08 re-election by 5.  The good news for Bilbray is that Team Blue’s top candidate, Dave Roberts, dropped out late last year.  Francine Busby, who nearly won the seat back in 2005 but later struggled in 2006, is back for another run at the seat, though she’ll have to go up against attorney Tracy Emblem in the democratic primary.  Either way, Bilbray is looking pretty good, especially since he’s got a nice lead, 606k to 288k, over Busby in the money race.  Bilbray, much like republicans like Leonard Lance, Jerry Moran, and Dave Reichert, has gone out of their way to stress their moderate nature, so that may help him.

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

California-51 – Bob Filner/Democrat – This district, which consists of San Diego’s south and east suburbs as well as Imperial county, is fairly democratic.  I don’t see the entrenched Filner having much of a problem here.

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

California-52 – Duncan Hunter/Republican – This district is comprised of the most republican parts of San Diego County, mostly rich suburbs.  This should be a cinch for Hunter.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

California-53 – Susan Davis/Democrat – This final district is comprised of downtown San Diego.  It’s a liberal bastion and an easy win for Davis and Team Blue.  

District PVI – D+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Hawaii-1 – Open/Democrat – We started this journey way up in the far northeast of Maine, and we finish it in the tropical Pacific islands of Hawaii.  Interestingly enough, we have an open seat race that because of the format of the race, could turn out to be crazy.  My projections are for November, but next month, a special election to replace Neil Abercrombie will take place.  It essentially amounts to a three-way R/D/I race between Honolulu city councilman Charles Djou, state senate majority leader Colleen Hanabusa, and former US Rep Ed Case.  The polls have shown this contest to be a close contest on all sides, and it’s a tough call.  But since this is a November prediction, I have to look ahead, and based on their political positions, you’d have to believe that, unless Case wins the special election, Hanabusa would destroy him in the democratic primary, resulting in a Hanabusa v Djou rematch in November.  If Case wins next month he might survive to face Djou instead, although it would probably be tight.  If that matchup comes to pass, I could see enough disenchanted democrats voting for Djou just because of how much Case is hated among the base, but if Hanabusa gets through either the special or the September primary, she’s going to win in November.  The only question is how to rate this race.  

District PVI – D+11

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Hawaii-2 – Mazie Hirono/Democrat – The final district in the US, and it’s a snoozer, as Hirono will have no trouble retaining.

District PVI – D+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Region recap:  Well, after all that, I have only one seat changing hands, a democratic pickup in CA-3, giving the Democrats a +1 in the Pacific Coast, and their 2nd region of positive gain along with the Western Great Lakes.  The final score thus comes out unofficially at Republican +20.  In my final post, I will make the total official and if any changes in the total score occur I will highlight them.  You’ll also see my full national board, with all races that are likely, lean, and toss up paired alongside one another.    

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 9

Hello, and welcome to part 9 of my 2010 baseline predictions for the House of Representatives.  In this section I will cover the Rocky Mountains.  This region contains the states of Montana, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, Arizona, Utah, Nevada, Idaho, Oregon, Washington, and Alaska.  (I threw in the Pacific Northwest because keeping those in the Pacific region would’ve made that zone far too large, thanks California).  This region is kind of strange.  Some states are heavily republican while others are democratic, and some are swingish.  The problem for the democrats is that they are almost maxed out in the region, as they have 27 of the region’s 43 seats, compared with only 16 for the republicans.  Of those 27 seats, 8 of them are R+4 or worse in PVI, including 2 seats of R+15 or worse. Because of that and the fact that many states here have an independent-natured electorate, along with the Upper South and the Central Plains, the Rocky Mountains could be the site of major Dem losses.

First off, a recap of where we’ve been, and where we still have to go*:

Northeast – Rep +3 – (Rep pickups of NH-1, NY-24, NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even – (Rep pickups of PA-11, MD-1, Dem pickups of PA-6, DE-1)

Upper South – Rep +5 (Rep pickups of VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8)

South Atlantic – Even – (no pickups on either side)

Eastern Great Lakes – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of OH-1, MI-7, IN-8)

South Gulf – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of AL-2, MS-1, LA-3, TX-17, Dem pickup of LA-2)

Western Great Lakes – Dem +1 (Dem pickup of IL-10)

Central Plains – Rep +4 (Rep pickups of IA-3, AR-1, AR-2, KS-3)

Rocky Mountains –

Pacific Coast –

Total National Score – Rep +17

* – Please note that in most cases these ratings were done prior to any polling becoming known.  

Montana-1 – Denny Rehberg/Republican – Montana was the site of a big democratic swing in 2008 as Obama nearly won against McCain four years after Kerry got demolished by Bush.  Maybe that trend will continue, maybe it won’t, but what won’t change is Rehberg’s hold on this district.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Wyoming-1 – Cynthia Lummis/Republican – Lummis had a surprisingly difficult time winning this open seat, as democrat Gary Trauner kept it close most of the way before ultimately falling by 10%.  Seeing as this is Wyoming, it’s likely that Lummis will have this seat for as long as she wants, barring a scandal.  

District PVI – R+20

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Colorado-1 – Diana DeGette/Democrat – From the vast emptiness of Wyoming to the bustle of downtown Denver we move, and boy does the political landscape change.  DeGette probably would have more to sweat in a primary than in a general vs a republican.

District PVI – D+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Colorado-2 – Jared Polis/Democrat – The Boulder-based 2nd, along with many college based districts not in the plains or south, is solidly democratic.  It’s on the fringes of what the repubs could conceivably challenge for in the best of red years, but Polis hasn’t drawn any credible opposition.

District PVI – D+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Colorado-3 – John Salazar/Democrat – The 3rd stretches over a wide, mountainous area in the western half of Colorado.  Salazar, who is one of the more conservative democrats in the House, has had a very strong grip on this conservative leaning district, winning with 62% of the vote in both 2006 and 2008 despite McCain beating Obama 50-47.  State representative Scott Tipton, Salazar’s 2006 opponent is back for another run, and he’s barely ahead of a bunch of nobodies looking for the republican nomination.  Given Salazar’s popularity I don’t see a pickup as very likely here.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Colorado-4 – Betsy Markey/Democrat – The rural eastern part of Colorado is generally very conservative, but a major shift occurred in 2008, as Barack Obama came within 1% of winning the presidential vote here, and Betsy Markey defeated conservative firebrand Marilyn Musgrave by a 56-44 margin.  I tend to think that was more a result of incumbent weakness than anything else.  Regardless, this is going to be a huge battleground in 2008, as the republicans got a very strong candidate in Colorado house minority whip Cory Gardner.  Other candidates in the race include Colorado regent Tom Lucero and Colorado Springs city councilman Diggs Brown.  Markey has been an absolute stalwart in fundraising, having raised 1.17 million, with only Gardner being in the same stratosphere at 596k.  Markey’s voting record has been somewhat pragmatic, and I think she’s positioning herself well, so I want to pick her for a retention.  But seeing just how conservative this district was not long ago, and assuming Gardner makes it out of the primary, I have some serious doubts.  Hickenlooper might be able to provide some coattails at the top of the ticket, but that could be canceled out if Jane Norton is headed for a Senate victory.  Ah, such a tough one to call, kinda like OH-15.  This time though, I go red.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (22nd overall)

National Score – Rep +18

Colorado-5 – Doug Lamborn/Republican – The Colorado Springs-based 5th is the most republican district in Colorado, and should be an easy retention for Lamborn.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Colorado-6 – Mike Coffman/Republican – This is a seat based mostly in the Denver suburbs that is starting to turn more democratic, but at present, it’s still fairly red.  Looking back on it, with Obama only falling by 6%, the Democrats should have done more to contest this open seat last cycle, which Coffman won with a 60% share.  It’s unlikely to be competitive this cycle, but watch for redistricting in case democrats are holding the hammer.  How they redraw the lines might be dependent on whether Markey survives too.

District PVI – R+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Colorado-7 – Ed Perlmutter/Democrat – The suburban Denver 7th was initially drawn to be a partisan battleground, but it too has trended blue, and is now a D-leaning seat.  Perlmutter won by a huge margin in 2008 but the republicans have a strong challenger for 2010, Aurora city councilman Ryan Frazier.  At present, Perlmutter is leading the fundraising chase 882k to 434k, that combined with the partisan lean of the district lead me to believe that a pickup isn’t likely here.

District PVI – D+4

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

New Mexico-1 – Martin Heinrich/Democrat – The Albuquerque-based 1st was a longtime land of enchanted frustration for the democrats as despite a democratic lean, the district was dominated by republicans for many years.  But opportunity came as incumbent Heather Wilson ran for the open Senate seat, and Martin Heinrich defeated his republican challenger by 12%.  Obama won here by 20% though, so he actually underperformed the top of the ticket, always a bad sign.  Luckily, the republican opposition doesn’t look so tough, former new mexico GOP vice chair Jon Barela is the likely republican nominee.  Heinrich is killing it in fundraising, having raised 1.13 million to Barela’s 293k.  This race is on the board officially, but I’d be stunned if Heinrich were to lose in November.

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

New Mexico-2 – Harry Teague/Democrat – Here’s another big battleground for 2010.  The 2nd, which encompasses much of New Mexico’s southern desert landscape, usually leans republican, but Teague was able to pick up the seat when longtime incumbent Steve Pearce ran for the Senate and got crushed by Tom Udall.  Teague’s victory of 56-44 was strong considering Obama lost to McCain by 50-49.  Pearce is back for a run to reclaim his old seat, and he has railed against Teague’s “liberal” voting record, which has in fact been one of the more conservative in the democratic caucus.  The money race is fairly close at 1.07 million for Teague and 821k for Pearce.  This is another tough call to make, but at the end of the day I think Pearce is a really crappy campaigner, as evidenced by his horrific Senate run in 2008.  Therefore, Teague will win a close one.  Diane Denish leading the top of the ticket will help too.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Dem Hold

New Mexico-3 – Ben Lujan/Democrat – The mountainous northern part of the state, Lujan won big in an open seat race here in 2008, and the opposition doesn’t look all that strong for 2010.  Plus, the democratic lean of the district makes this one safe.

District PVI – D+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Utah-1 – Bob Bishop/Republican – Heading into Mormon country, Utah is one of the nation’s most conservative states, and this northern Utah district is the 13th most conservative in the country.  No problem for Bishop.  

District PVI – R+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Utah-2 – Jim Matheson/Democrat – Utah’s answer to Texas’s Chet Edwards and Mississippi’s Gene Taylor, Jim Matheson has weathered several republican attempts to dislodge him, most notably the 2002 re-districting that was done solely to get rid of him by cutting out Salt Lake City’s west side and replacing it with eastern and southern Utah.  But Matheson remains, and he won by a huge 29% margin in 2008 while his district was a surprisingly close 58-40 spread for John McCain.  Still, you’d expect the republicans to put up a strong challenge in 2010.  Only token opposition is up there right now.  I’m nervous taking a district this conservative off the board entirely, but it’s hard to imagine any scenario in which Matheson loses this cycle.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Utah-3 – Jason Chaffetz/Republican – This is the 7th most republican district in the country, and Chaffetz is a weapons-grade wingnut.  Pretty much a perfect match.

District PVI – R+26

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Arizona-1 – Ann Kirkpatrick/Democrat – Kirkpatrick benefitted from a scandal-tainted incumbent retiring in 2008, but had to fight a bit of a home state vote for John McCain as she won this open seat by a 55-39 count.  Republicans claim her victory was scandal-induced, but the field is a bit unsettled in 2010.  The fundraising lead is held by dentist Paul Gosar, but former state senator Rusty Bowers could be a stronger name.  Kirkpatrick has banked 875k so far this cycle, so all things considered her standing looks pretty good.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Arizona-2 – Trent Franks/Republican – Franks presides over largely republican territory in the state’s northwest and west central.  I think he’s safe.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Arizona-3 – Open/Republican – This R-leaning seat in north Phoenix and it’s northern suburbs is open thanks to John Shadegg calling it quits.  The republican primary field is a free-for-all, including state representative Sam Crump, state senators Jim Waring and Pamela Gorman, Paradise Valley mayor Vernon Parker, and attorney Ben Quayle.  The democrats got a bit of bad news when their #1 choice, Phoenix mayor Phil Gordon decided not to run, but they got a very solid #2 in businessman John Hulburd, who already has a sizeable lead in the fundraising race.  That lead could become larger as the republican primary candidates beat each other up.  McCain won this district by a 56-42 count in 2008, so it’s a tough one for the democrats but not impossible.  If the GOP primary gets ugly then Hulburd might have a shot at pulling an upset.  

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Arizona-4 – Ed Pastor/Democrat – This area consisting of downtown Phoenix, is the most liberal part of the state.  Easy hold for Pastor.

District PVI – D+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Arizona-5 – Harry Mitchell/Democrat – This northeastern Maricopa county district is going to be the site of some serious fireworks in 2010, the question is who will be setting them off?  Mitchell won this seat by defeating uber-wingnut J.D. Hayworth in 2006, then held it against Maricopa County Treasurer David Schweikert last cycle.  Schweikert is running again, and he is fundraising fairly well at 405k so far, but the republican primary looks to be hotly contested.  Businessman Jim Ward and physician David Salvino are in, but of greater interest is the candidacy of former state representative Susan Bitter Smith, who was somewhat responsible for de-railing Schweikert’s 2008 run thanks to a brutally nasty primary.  This race is going to be a close one, but I have a feeling the environment won’t be a strong argument in Arizona, where McCain provided a good topline for the GOP in 2008.  

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Arizona-6 – Jeff Flake/Republican – This is the most Republican district in Arizona, and Flake’s conservatism fits well here.  

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Arizona-7 – Raul Grijalva/Democrat – One of only two democratic PVI districts in Arizona, Grijalva is pretty much safe.

District PVI – D+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Arizona-8 – Gabrielle Giffords/Democrat – Giffords won this seat in 2006 and defended it against a strong republican challenger in 2008, winning by 12%.  Her name was floated in both the Senate and gubernatorial races this year but she’s hanging in for re-election.  Giffords has fundraised with the best of them, banking 1.19 million this cycle.  The republican field is splintered and not all that impressive, as the top possible GOP candidates all passed on the race. For what its worth, Iraq war veteran Jesse Kelly holds the fundraising lead, but is behind the incumbent by about 1-5. To be honest, I think Giffords is a rising star in the democratic caucus, and I really don’t understand why so many pundits have this race as a big pickup opportunity for Team Red.  

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Nevada-1 – Shelley Berkley/Democrat – This seat, lying right in the heart of Las Vegas, is very democratic.  Berkley has never really had to fight much for her seat but this year looks to be very ugly for Democrats in Nevada.  Obama cleaned up here 64-34 and Berkley won by almost 40% that year, but 2008 might as well be 1908 when you consider how much the landscape has changed here.  Craig Lake Jr is the likely republican nominee and he is off to a decent fundraising start in the 250k range.  If you haven’t guessed by now, the only reason I even have this race in play is because of the double albatross at the top of the ticket, Harry Reid for Senate and Rory Reid for governor.  I still think Berkley’s going to win, but she’d better be willing to work because otherwise I could see this one becoming somewhat Coakley-esque.

District PVI – D+10

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Nevada-2 – Dean Heller/Republican – This district consists of pretty much the whole state minus Las Vegas.  Heller won this seat in an open seat race in 2006 and held it by 10% in 2008.  The democratic opposition doesn’t look very strong this cycle which is a shame since Obama and McCain finished tied at 49% in 2008 and this district isn’t the republican stronghold it once was.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Nevada-3 – Dina Titus/Democratic – The 3rd district, which consists mostly of the Vegas suburbs, has been a partisan battleground for many years.  Titus knocked off 3-term incumbent Jon Porter by a 47-42-11 plurality to win the seat, a bit of an underperformance against Obama’s 55-43 win over McCain.  Titus has fundraised very well at 993k so far this cycle, and the republican opposition is headed for a tough primary.  The leading candidates are former state senator Joe Heck and real estate investor Robert Lauer, neither of whom is over 200k raised.  However, this is a race where I don’t think fundraising is going to matter very much.  Las Vegas has gotten pounded, and I mean pounded by the recession, way more than your typical American city, which is also going to be an albatross for Berkley in NV-1.  Secondly, the Reid father-son pairing at the top of the ticket is going to really be a drag.  I like Titus, but sadly due to factors outside of her control, she’s fighting a battle she can’t win.  

District PVI – D+2

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Moderate Rep Pickup (23rd overall)

National Score – Rep +19

Idaho-1 – Walt Minnick/Democrat – I have a feeling that due to his conservative voting record and apparent popularity in the district, that Walt Minnick could be in better shape than some would suspect. (maybe similar to Bobby Bright in AL-2, which we found out about last week after I had already made my preliminary call there)  That being said, this is an extremely republican district, the 27th most conservative in the nation in fact, and Minnick only won here because former incumbent Bill Sali was a lunatic.  Former marine corps major Vaughn Ward is the leading candidate for the GOP, having been promoted by the NRCC’s “young guns” program.  Minnick is way ahead in fundraising with 1.16 million, a huge total, with Ward at 341k.  Maybe if the environment wasn’t as bad as it is, I’d stick to my suspicions and stick with Minnick to retain, but in the absence of any polling to corroborate my thoughts, I will defer to the PVI and give Team Red a pickup here.

District PVI – R+18

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (24th overall)

National Score – Rep +20

Idaho-2 – Mike Simpson/Republican – This is going to be an easy win for Simpson, as this part of Idaho is just as conservative as it’s counterpart.

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Oregon-1 – David Wu/Democrat – Wu went through the 2008 election without a republican challenger, and he romped while Obama fought to a 61-38 win over John McCain here.  Sports management consultant Robert Cornilles is in the race against Wu, but aside from being a self-funder, I don’t see much appeal around him.  

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Oregon-2 – Greg Walden/Republican – The lone republican in Oregon’s house delegation, Walden represents the eastern 2/3 of the state, which is rural and mostly conservative.  He’s safe.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Oregon-3 – Earl Blumenauer/Democrat – This district, based in Portland, is a rather blue liberal bastion.  No republican is going to be winning here for quite some time.  

District PVI – D+19

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Oregon-4 – Peter Defazio/Democrat – Republican hopes in the Eugene/Springfield-based 4th were pretty much dependent on Defazio running for the open gubernatorial seat.  But he declined that, and the republicans top candidate, Springfield mayor Sid Leiken, just hit the eject button on his candidacy.  

District PVI – D+2

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Oregon-5 – Kurt Schrader/Democrat – If there’s going to be any activity in the Beaver/Duck State in 2010, it’ll probably be here.  Schrader won this district in a 2008 open seat race by 16% while Obama won the district by 11%, a remarkable turnaround considering that Bush carried this district twice.  State representative Scott Brunn is the likely republican nominee, but he’s got an uphill climb in both the money race and against an electorate that is moving pretty quickly to the left.  

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Washington-1 – Jay Inslee/Democrat – We turn our attention now to Washington state, where Inslee sits in a district of mostly Seattle’s northern suburbs.  A fairly democratic district, it shouldn’t be all that competitive in 2010.

District PVI – D+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Washington-2 – Rick Larsen/Democrat – This district is less democratic than WA-1, but it doesn’t look as though Larsen has much to worry about.  There’s only one republican running against him and it’s somebody in the “some dude” category.  

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Washington-3 – Open/Democrat – The 3rd, which covers most of southwestern Washington, is going to be the site of some strong political fighting this fall as incumbent Brian Baird is retiring.  The primary fields look to be crowded.  The democratic primary will be contested by state representative Denny Heck, state senator Craig Pridemore, and Hispanic activist Maria Rodriguez-Salazar.  Heck is seen as the slight favorite at this point but it’s anyone’s game really.  On the republican side, retired marine David Hedrick, financial advisor David Castillo, and Washougal city councilman Jon Russell are in, but the prospective favorite is youthful state representative Jaime Herrera.  My feeling is, if Herrera does win the nomination, the repubs will probably score a pickup here, but if she loses the primary then the dems will probably hold the seat.  For now, I’m going with Team Red, but stay tuned on this one.

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (25th overall)

National Score – Rep +21  

Washington-4 – Doc Hastings/Republican – One of only two safe R seats in Washington and the most conservative seat in the state, Hastings is safe here.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Washington-5 – Cathy McMorris-Rodgers/Republican – This western Washington district was actually pretty close in 2008 as McCain beat Obama 52-46, but Rodgers steamrolled to a big win.  She’s safe.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Washington-6 – Norm Dicks/Democrat – The long serving Dicks, representing this district on the Olympia peninsula, is very solidly entrenched and shouldn’t have anything to worry about here.

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Washington-7 – Jim McDermott/Democrat – This district is centered around Seattle and is one of the country’s most democratic.  Safe.

District PVI – D+31

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Washington-8 – Dave Reichert/Republican – One of the few incumbents that have survived the democratic onslaught in recent years within a democratic district, Reichert is used to having to fight for re-election, and this year looks no different.  The expected democratic candidate, Suzan Delbene, has actually outraised Reichert 1.04 million to 985k and leads him by an even wider margin in cash on hand.  It’s uncertain how well of a campaigner Delbene is, and if she’ll be able to blunt Reichert’s obvious popularity in the district, but with a democratic leaning electorate and a cash advantage, she’s got the tools necessary to pull off an upset.  This one is going to be one to watch for sure.  Sidebar: in the event that Reichert pulls off another win in 2010, redistricting is going to be a major problem for him as the democrats hold the hammer (unless WA does independent redistricting, I’m not sure).

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Hold

Washington-9 – Adam Smith/Democrat – Smith’s southern Puget Sound based district is fairly democratic for the most part, and he’s very well entrenched.  Methinks he’s safe.

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Alaska-1 – Don Young/Republican – Young shocked many when he got past Ethan Berkowitz despite the ethical clouds hanging over his head, perhaps the result of Sarah Palin’s coattails at the top of the ticket.  (Which consequently nearly saved Ted Stevens against Mark Begich in the Senate race)  For what it’s worth, he’s facing a primary challenge from Andrew Halcro.  The only democrat in the race is state representative Harry Crawford, who I admittedly don’t know much about.  There’s always the chance that Young could get swept down by corruption ahead of the election, but otherwise I think this seat stays red.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Region Recap – There’s a lot of competitiveness in the mountain states this year, and ultimately I see a lot of the toss up races not going our way, at least not at the moment.  I have the republicans picking up 4 seats, CO-4, NV-3, ID-1, and WA-3, bringing them to 25 total pickups and a national score of Rep +21 with only one region to go.  The Democrats really don’t have many good opportunities at pickups, with AZ-3 and WA-8 being the best opportunities.  

Final stop…The Pacific Coast…next time

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 8

Hello, and welcome to part 8 of my 2010 baseline predictions for the House of Representatives.  In this section we will cover the Central Plains region.  This region covers the states of Iowa, Missouri, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, South Dakota, and North Dakota.  This is, along with the South Gulf, one of the two most conservative regions of the United States, as the western and southern portions are extremely conservative, with only Iowa and Missouri really in play at the presidential level.  However, the democrats have done a pretty good job at the congressional level here, as the republicans only lead 18 seats to 14.  The bad part about that is that there are only 6 D+ PVI seats in the whole region, all held by democrats, meaning that the potential for big losses in 2010 is there.

First off, a recap of where we’ve been, and where we still have to go*:

Northeast – Rep +3 – (Rep pickups of NH-1, NY-24, NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even – (Rep pickups of PA-11, MD-1, Dem pickups of PA-6, DE-1)

Upper South – Rep +5 (Rep pickups of VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8)

South Atlantic – Even – (no pickups on either side)

Eastern Great Lakes – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of OH-1, MI-7, IN-8)

South Gulf – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of AL-2, MS-1, LA-3, TX-17, Dem pickup of LA-2)

Western Great Lakes – Dem +1 (Dem pickup of IL-10)

Central Plains –

Rocky Mountains –

Pacific Coast –

Total National Score – Rep +13

* – Please note that in most cases these ratings were done prior to any polling becoming known.  

Iowa-1 – Bruce Braley/Democrat – Braley won this eastern Iowa seat in 2006 and retained it by 29% in 2008.  He seems like a popular guy too within the district.  There’s really not much of any republican opposition forming this cycle either, so I think he’s safe.

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Iowa-2 – Dave Loebsack/Democrat – Loebsack isn’t quite as entrenched into his district yet as Braley is, but again, the opposition for Team Red doesn’t look all that promising, and IA-2 is a bit more democratic than IA-1.  Gotta like Loebsack for a retention here.

District PVI – D+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Iowa-3 – Leonard Boswell/Democrat – It looks like all the action in Iowa is going to be taking place here.  This district, which is centered on Des Moines in central Iowa, is a nearly even district politically speaking.  Boswell isn’t the strongest of incumbents, but it should be noted that his 14% win in 2008 was actually a 5% overperformance over Obama’s 54-45 win over John McCain that same year.  Boswell hasn’t been the strongest fundraiser, sitting at 583k this cycle, but it still puts him ahead of the nearest republican challenger by almost 3-1.  Speaking of the opposition, the republican primary is very congested, lead by state senator Brad Zaun and financial analyst/former wrestling coach Jim Gibbons.  Either of these candidates would be a strong challenge to Boswell, and I have deep concerns about coattails in Iowa because of Chuck Grassley running for Senate and the hugely unpopular Chet Culver running for governor.  I may be pessimistic about this one, but I think inability to get entrenched plus a strong republican pull at the top of the ticket will doom Boswell in November.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (18th overall)

National Score – Rep +14

Iowa-4 – Tom Latham/Republican – Latham beat back a challenge from farmer and party activist Becky Greenwald by a surprisingly large margin, as the race was assumed to be a tough one.  That performance leads me to believe that Latham is safe this cycle.  

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Iowa-5 – Steve King/Republican – The one republican-leaning district in the state, King is on easy territory looking toward his 2010 race.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Missouri-1 – William Clay/Democrat – We head into Missouri now, and into the democratic bastion of the state in St Louis.   Clay is very safe in this extremely liberal area.  

District PVI – D+27

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Missouri-2 – Todd Akin/Republican – The 2nd, which consists mostly of St. Louis’s affluent western and northwestern suburbs, is a very republican zone.  Akin won his 2008 re-election by over 25%, so he’s got nothing to be worried about.  

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Missouri-3 – Russ Carnahan/Democrat – The 3rd is a district consisting of St. Louis’s southern suburbs and some union-friendly towns along the Mississippi.  It’s a democratic district, but not so much that a republican could never win.  Carnahan is very popular, having won his race by 39% in 2008.  Which is why I’m a bit puzzled as to how his republican challenger, Ed Martin, is leading him in cash on hand this cycle 335k to 217k.  Normally I’d be more concerned about that, but I don’t think Carnahan is in any real danger.

District PVI – D+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Missouri-4 – Ike Skelton/Democrat – Skelton has been a long serving representative, one of the longest in the democratic caucus, and when he won this district it was much more competitive and swingish than it is now.  MO-4 is trending hard to the right, and John McCain won here by a 61-38 count while Skelton cruised with a 31% win.  With the environment going their way, the republicans figure they have a good chance to win here, and they’ve got two strong candidates competing for the republican nomination, state senator Bill Stouffer and state representative Vicky Hartzler.  Both are fundraising well so far at 347k and 302k respectively, but that trails Skelton by a wide margin as he’s raised 1.1 million this cycle, an impressive count for an incumbent that hasn’t had to do much campaigning in recent years.  Despite the tough opposition, there’s a chance that Stouffer and Hartzler could beat each other up, plus I think that Skelton has a bit of that Gene Taylor/Chet Edwards “untouchable incumbent” quality to him.  I say he wins by a fair margin.  

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Missouri-5 – Emanuel Cleaver/Democrat – The Kansas City-based 5th is another democratic bastion, and Cleaver shouldn’t have any trouble holding it in 2010.

District PVI – D+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Missouri-6 – Sam Graves/Republican – Out of all the rural districts in Missouri, this one in the northwest part of the state is the least conservative.  However, the democrats haven’t even found a challenger to Graves, who won re-election in 2008 by roughly 20%.  

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Missouri-7 – Open/Republican – Roy Blunt is abdicating this seat to run for the Senate, but as with most republican open seats this cycle, it is very solidly red turf.  The republican primary is very jammed with candidates, but it’s pretty much a certainty that whoever wins that wins the seat.  

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Missouri-8 – Joann Emerson/Republican – Emerson’s district in southeastern Missouri is really trending republican at the moment, and it is the 2nd most republican in the state.  That being said, surprisingly, she has drawn a strong challenger in democrat Tommy Sowers, who has raised 383k so far this cycle.  That still trails Emerson’s 687k though, although the cash on hand disparity is much less, about 340k to 260k.  If Sowers campaigns well, you never know, this could turn into a bit of a sleeper.  However, in this environment, in a cherry-red district like this, against a wildly popular incumbent, Sowers would need a minor miracle to pull this one off.  

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Missouri-9 – Blaine Luetkemeyer – This district represents a major recruiting epic fail for the democrats, as they nearly picked off this district in a 2008 open seat race between Luetkemeyer and democrat Judy Baker, which Luetkemeyer won 49-47.  No democratic challenger has emerged thus far for 2010.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Arkansas-1 – Open/Democrat – We now head to Arkansas, which aside from Tennessee is probably the single worst state for House Dems heading into 2010.  Marion Berry is retiring, which makes this seat a very tough hold.  What’s weird about this race is that so far there’s only one confirmed candidate on each side, and virtually no money has been raised yet.  It’s a late developer, as both sides are waiting on their preferred candidates.  Team Blue has lots of choices, from state senator Steve Bryles to former Arkansas Dem party chairman Jason Willett, to Berry’s own chief of staff Chad Causey.  On the other side, farmer and army veteran Rick Crawford, congressional aide Princella Smith, and state senator Johnny Key are all in the hunt among others.  This district is a tough one to call, as it’s mostly democratic at the state level but has been rapidly trending republican at the national level.  They say politics is local, but in a cycle like this, I’m inclined to believe that adage won’t have as many legs as it usually does.

District PVI – R+8

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (19th overall)

National Score – Rep +15

Arkansas-2 – Open/Democrat – Like his 1st district counterpart, Vic Snyder has called it quits.  This district is going to be a real headache for the democrats as the Republicans have already coalesced around their candidate, former US attorney Tim Griffin.  Griffin brings money and name recognition, though he could be vulnerable because of his work in the Bush Administration.  The Democratic primary is a very jumbled affair now that their #1 guy, Lt Gov Bill Halter, has decided to run against Blanche Lincoln in the democratic Senate primary.  Given all this, and considering that Arkansas is moving way right, way fast, this looks like a republican pickup.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Pickup (20th overall)

National Score – R+16

Arkansas-3 – Open/Republican – Another republican open seat thanks to John Boozman running for the Senate, but yet again, it’s in a crazily republican district.  Whoever comes out of the republican primary will cruise into this seat.

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Arkansas-4 – Mike Ross/Democrat – Ross is the only member of the Arkansas delegation standing in for re-election, and he looks like a sure bet even though his district is turning red.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Oklahoma-1 – John Sullivan/Republican – Now we hit the single most conservative state in the union in 2008, Oklahoma.  The 1st district is based around Tulsa, and is hugely republican.  Sullivan is safe.

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Oklahoma-2 – Dan Boren/Democrat – Boren is a very conservative democrat, almost to the point where he’s just as conservative as the most liberal republicans in the house.  He’s very popular in this eastern Oklahoma district and isn’t in much danger despite the district’s rapid turn to the right, which means we’ll still be hearing his occasional diatribes against the House dem leadership after 2010.  The republicans are sure to go after him but so far only token opposition has made the plunge.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Oklahoma-3 – Frank Lucas/Republican – This western Oklahoma district is the 11th most republican in the nation.  No big deal for Lucas.

District PVI – R+24

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Oklahoma-4 – Tom Cole/Republican – The Norman-based 4th is also extremely republican, just like the rest of the state.  Cole is safe.  Seriously, without Boren, the Dems would be dead meat in this state.  Kinda like Jim Matheson in Utah, whom we’ll get to in the next section.

District PVI – R+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Oklahoma-5 – Open/Republican – Well gee, another hugely republican-leaning open seat, this one courtesy of Mary Fallin bailing for a run at the governorship.  The Oklahoma City-based 5th is the most democratic district in the state, which is like saying that RI-1 is the most republican district in Rhode Island.  There are a huge amount of republicans running in their primary, but no confirmed democratic candidates yet.  The only way in which this race becomes competitive is if Oklahoma first lady Kim Henry decides to jump in, but the odds of that are slim.  

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Kansas-1 – Open/Republican – Another republican open seat in solidly republican territory (like seriously did they plan all this out beforehand?  And why can’t democrats only open up their safe seats?)  Anyway, rep Jerry Moran is running for the Senate, and whoever wins the republican primary will win the seat, which consists of Kansas’s rural west and is the 12th most republican in the nation.

District PVI – R+23

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Kansas-2 – Lynn Jenkins/Republican – This district was the site of one of the few republican pickups in 2008, as Jenkins knocked off Nancy Boyda 50-46 to claim the seat.  With Boyda not running again, the democrats had a very strong candidate in state senator Laura Kelly to run against Jenkins but she dropped out a few months ago.  Without Kelly, the democrats will look to retired banker Cheryl Hudspeth and health care company president Kyle Kessler.  Interestingly, Jenkins is facing a primary challenge from teabagger Dennis Pyle.  It’s unlikely she’ll lose but if she does, the dems will really be kicking themselves over losing Kelly.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Kansas-3 – Open/Democrat – This is the theme in the Plains Region, lots of open seats, republican ones in safe R zones, democratic ones in swing or dangerous zones.  This seat is no different, as Dennis Moore is retiring perhaps in front of a groundswell of protest over his voting record this cycle.  Barack Obama did squeeze out a 51-48 win here though, so it’s not impossible for a liberal to win here.  However, the democrats must find a candidate first, as they currently have none, which is pathetic considering that they currently hold the seat.  It’s rumored that Moore’s wife might run for the seat, which might be the Dems only shot at retention.  The republican primary is scrambled, with lots of candidates and no clear favorite, but at least they have live bodies.

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Pickup (21st overall)

National Score – Rep +17

Kansas-4 – Open/Republican – If it sounds like I’m beating a dead horse by now, it’s because I am.  Another open seat in solidly red territory, caused by Todd Tiahrt’s run for Senate.  But my oh my, there’s a twist in the usual script in the Wichita-based 4th.  The democrats have an unusually strong candidate here in state representative Raj Goyle, who is leading the fundraising race having pulled in a strong 656k.  The republican field though, is deep and fairly strong, paced by state senator Dick Kelsey, RNC committeeman Mike Pompeo, and businessmen Willis Hartman and Jim Anderson.  This has the potential to be a race if Goyle proves himself on the campaign trail, but he’s got a very difficult road ahead.  

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Nebraska-1 – Jeff Fortenberry/Republican – Nebraska is one of only four states in the union with a democratic house member, and the only state with multiple districts (Wyoming, Montana, and Alaska are the others).  Fortenberry is well entrenched and has nothing to worry about here.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Nebraska-2 – Lee Terry/Republican – This former Republican stronghold took a very hard swing to the left in 2008 and garnered national attention when Barack Obama beat John McCain 50-49 to earn an electoral vote.  Republican Lee Terry struggled too, nearly losing to democrat Jim Esch.  It looks like another tough race is on the horizon here as state senator-representative Tom White is in the race, probably the best candidate Team Blue had in the district.  He’s fundraising well too, only trailing 485k to 340k in cash on hand so far this cycle.  Complicating things for Terry is that he is facing a primary challenge from businessman Matthew Sakalowsky.  The big question in this Omaha-based district is whether or not the democratic surge in 2008 was a one time deal or a portrait of things to come.  I’m not sure what the answer is.  If it’s the latter, then Terry is in huge trouble.  The environment should help the incumbent a bit though.  Quick sidebar, unless Nebraska has independent redistricting, it’s likely that this district is going to get split apart after 2010 as state republicans fumed over Obama’s win there.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Nebraska-3 – Adrian Smith/Republican – Here’s another cinch district for the Republicans, as it’s the 9th most conservative in the nation.  

District PVI – R+24

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

South Dakota-1 – Stephanie Herseth-Sandlin/Democrat – South Dakota is a fairly republican state, though it did move quite a bit left in 2008, resulting in only a single digit win for John McCain over Barack Obama.  Herseth-Sandlin has always been a popular figure in the state, and republicans were hoping she would bail to run either for the open governorship or challenge John Thune for the senate.  The republicans still think in the current environment that this race is winnable, and they do have some strong candidates in secretary of state Chris Nelson and state representative Blake Curd.  If things get really, really bad for the dems I could see them dropping this race, but it would have to be a Lincoln Chafee-esque situation where House control came down to the last few days for Herseth-Sandlin to lose.  The odds are in her favor.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Dakota-1 – Earl Pomeroy/Democrat – Another long entrenched incumbent here in Pomeroy, and one that usually doesn’t have to sweat much through re-election.  However, this year will be different, as the republicans are throwing at him two strong candidates, former state house majority leader Rick Berg and state public service commission chairman Kevin Cramer.  Pomeroy, like counterpart Herseth-Sandlin, is a great fundraiser and is generally quite popular, but this race is more serious because of one extra variable, popular republican governor John Hoeven is running for the Senate, which might bring lots of coattails.  Still, I think Pomeroy is too strong.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Region Recap – Because of the large distribution of open seats and the national environment, the Central Plains look to be a very hostile region for the Democrats in 2010.  I see the Republicans picking up 4 seats in this region, IA-3, AR-1, AR-2, and KS-3, bringing them to 21 total pickups compared to the Democrats’ 4, for a total national score of Republicans +17.  Iowa-3 was an extremely tough call, one that I made more on the strength of coattails from Chuck Grassley and Chet Culver, negative coattails in the latter situation, then on Boswell himself.  I feel much more confident in the other calls.

Only two regions left!  Next stop…The Rocky Mountains

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 7

Hello, and welcome to part 7 of my 2010 baseline predictions for the House of Representatives.  In this section I will cover the Western Great Lakes.  This region encompasses the states of Illinois, Wisconsin, and Minnesota.  There are 35 total seats in this region, the smallest region we’ve covered so far.  Of those 35 seats, 22 are currently held by the democrats, and 13 are held by the republicans.  The region is one of the most liberal in the United States, although the more northerly states can occasionally be swingish.  I think this will be one of the democrats’ best regions in the 2010 elections, where they probably won’t lose many seats, and might actually gain.  The reason for that is that the democrats have a lot of entrenched incumbents in the swing districts here (kinda like how the republicans did in the Eastern Great Lakes), and the national mood will have to be really strong to touch them.

First off, a recap of where we’ve been, and where we still have to go*:

Northeast – Rep +3 – (Rep pickups of NH-1, NY-24, NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even – (Rep pickups of PA-11, MD-1, Dem pickups of PA-6, DE-1)

Upper South – Rep +5 (Rep pickups of VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8)

South Atlantic – Even – (no pickups on either side)

Eastern Great Lakes – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of OH-1, MI-7, IN-8)

South Gulf – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of AL-2, MS-1, LA-3, TX-17, Dem pickup of LA-2)

Western Great Lakes –

Central Plains –

Rocky Mountains –

Pacific Coast –

Total National Score – Rep +14

* – Please note that in most cases these ratings were done prior to any polling becoming known.  

Illinois-1 – Bobby Rush/Democrat – We begin the region in the Chicago area, which is the democratic center of the Midwest.  This particular district is the 14th most democratic in the nation, so Rush is safe.

District PVI – D+34

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-2 – Jessie Jackson Jr/Democrat – Another very liberal district here, this one the 8th most democratic in the country.  No problem for Jackson.

District PVI – D+36

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-3 – Dan Lipinski/Democrat – This part of the Chicago metroplex, mostly its southwestern suburbs, isn’t quite as liberal as the rest of the urban core, but it’s still not anything to worry about.  

District PVI – D+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-4 – Luis Gutierrez/Democrat – One of the most hideous gerrymanders in the country, IL-4 is very democratic and an easy win for Gutierrez.  I don’t know why the district is drawn like this, it must be a racial gerrymander or something like that.

District PVI – D+32

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-5 – Mike Quigley/Democrat – Rahm Emanuel’s old district on the north side, like most parts of Chicago, is a democratic bastion.  Quigley, who won a 2009 special election for the seat, has nothing to worry about.  

District PVI – D+19

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-6 – Peter Roskam/Republican – This once conservative district in Chicago’s western suburbs has really moved to the left recently, part of which may have been an Obama-related anomaly.  Roskam though, is fairly well entrenched, and the democrats have had a bit of a recruiting shortfall, as Ben Lowe is the only Dem candidate in the race.  Roskam’s 1.05 million in funds raised this cycle would make this a tough one anyway.

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Illinois-7 –  Danny Davis/Democrat – There was talk earlier in the cycle that Davis was running for a Cook County office, but even if he had done so, an open seat here would’ve been no sweat.  This is the 12th most democratic district in the nation.

District PVI – D+35

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-8 – Melissa Bean/Democrat – The 8th consists of Chicago’s northwest suburbs and exurbs, and once was a republican stronghold.  In fact, Bush won here by 12% in 2004, but Obama crushed McCain by 15% four years later, one of the biggest turnarounds in the whole country.  The Republicans appeared to have strong challengers lined up here in Long Grove mayor Maria Rodriguez, and businessman Dirk Beveridge and Chris Giessler, but Bean caught a break when the republicans instead nominated uber-conservative financial analyst Joe Walsh.  Between that matchup and Bean’s outstanding fundraising (1.04 million so far), I’m itching to move this to solid D, but in this environment, I can’t.  Still, Bean is in great shape.

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Illinois-9 – Jan Schakowsky/Democrat – This district covers Chicago’s northern inner suburbs, and is very democratic.  Schakowsky is safe.

District PVI – D+20

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-10 – Open/Republican – This is without a doubt the biggest open seat headache the republicans face this cycle, as Mark Kirk bailed to run for the Senate (which might turn out well for them, who knows).  This district, which is comprised of Chicago’s northern suburbs, voted very heavily for Obama in 2008, by a 61-38 count, yet Kirk was able to beat Dan Seals by 9%.  Now the eternal question is was Kirk that good, or was Seals that bad?  We’ll soon find out, both in Kirk’s Senate bid vs Illinois treasurer Alexi Giannoulias, and here, where Seals is in the race for a third time.  He defeated Julie Hamos in the democratic primary by a razor-thin 1% margin.  Meanwhile, the democrats caught a break as respected moderate Elizabeth Coulson lost the republican primary to conservative Bob Dold.  A Coulson victory probably would’ve put this race into Leans R status, but against Dold, Seals has a good chance at winning.

District PVI – D+6

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Dem Pickup (4th overall)

Total National Score – Rep +13

Illinois-11 – Debbie Halvorson/Democrat – Halvorson won her 2008 race fairly easily, and was probably boosted by Obama a bit as he carried the district by 8% in 2008.  The good news for Halvorson is that her district is fairly moderate, and her fundraising has been nothing short of prodigious so far, at 1.25 million so far.  The bad news is that the Republicans got a very solid recruit here.  Adam Kinzinger, a pilot in the Illinois Air National Guard, has been campaigning and fundraising pretty well thus far.  He’s down quite a bit in the cash race but such youthful and articulate challengers are a rarity on the republican side, so he’s got a chance at pulling an upset.  Unless he can up his fundraising though, that chance will remain narrow.  

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Illinois-12 – Jerry Costello/Democrat – We head out of the Chicago area and into downstate Illinois now, and IL-12 is a slightly democratic district lying along the lower Mississippi valley.  Costello is fairly well entrenched here, so I don’t foresee a competitive race.

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-13 – Judy Biggert/Republican – Biggert, who’s usually a very tough incumbent, had a bout of toughness dealt her way by Scott Harper, who held her to a single digit victory in 2008.  Harper is back for another chance at this swing district, but it’s going to be tough sledding for him as Biggert is way up on him in the fundraising battle 804k to 179k.  Plus, he won’t have native son Barack Obama on the ticket with him, so turnout may not be in his favor.  I’m not writing this one off completely, but this is a very uphill climb for Harper.

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Illinois-14 – Bill Foster/Democrat – For years, this northern Illinois seat was republican held, in fact this was Dennis Hastert’s former seat, which Foster won in a 2008 special election.  Foster has been on a fundraising rampage, collecting 1.45 million so far in the cycle, which is even bigger when you consider that republicans Ethan Hastert and Randy Hultgren just got done with a tough primary.  Hultgren won the race, to the surprise of many, so he’ll take on Foster.  With only 10k cash on hand at the moment, it’ll be tough, but Foster isn’t exactly entrenched and the wind is at his back, so anything is possible.

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Illinois-15 – Timothy Johnson/Republican – Johnson is a fairly entrenched incumbent in this eastern Illinois district centered on Champaign-Urbana.  The Dems have one candidate, David Gill, but his fundraising hasn’t gone well.  Even though Johnson isn’t sitting on a mountain of cash and Obama nearly won this district in 2008, I don’t see it flipping now.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Illinois-16 – Don Manzullo/Republican – Now this is a district that should be ripe for a possible takeover at some point.  Barack Obama won here by a 53-46 count, and the republican incumbent is getting up in years a bit.  Manzullo doesn’t have much opposition and should win easily, but if this seat ever comes open, Team Red will have a tough time holding on.  

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Illinois-17 – Phil Hare/Democrat – The very badly gerrymandered 17th is a slightly democratic district consisting mostly of towns in the Mississippi valley.  Hare is a well-entrenched incumbent and like Manzullo, doesn’t have much opposition.  He should be safe.

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Illinois-18 – Aaron Schock/Republican – If ever there was a politician that got by on looks, Aaron Schock is it.  As the youngest member of the House, I can’t think of anything substantive the man has done since winning in a 2008 open seat race.  Yet he seems to be in good shape, the only real democratic opposition here is environmental activist Diedre Hirner.  The challenger is badly behind in cash on hand, down by a 10-1 margin, which makes this an extreme longshot for Team Blue.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Illinois-19 – John Shimkus/Republican – This is the most republican district in Illinois, consisting of much of the state’s southern tier.  Shimkus should be fine here.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Wisconsin-1 – Paul Ryan/Republican – Arguably a rising star in the Republican Party, Paul Ryan has a virtual lock on this southeastern Wisconsin district, a great feat considering Obama beat McCain here by 4%.  

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Wisconsin-2 – Tammy Baldwin/Democrat – Like Ryan in the 1st, Tammy Baldwin is in firm control in her district, which is based around the state’s capital, Madison.  

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Wisconsin-3 – Ron Kind/Democrat – Kind has been very popular in the 3rd district for some time now.  He defeated his 2008 challenger by nearly 30 points, almost doubling the victory margin Barack Obama had against John McCain.  Republican hopes seemed to hinge on Kind running for the open gubernatorial seat, but he decided against that.  State senator Dan Kapanke has been heralded as a strong challenger here but with fundraising at just 183k thus far, almost 900k behind Kind in cash on hand, it’s hard to imagine much coming out of this race.

District PVI – D+4

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Wisconsin-4 – Gwen Moore/Democrat – Moore is based in central Milwaukee, which along with Madison, is a very liberal place.  No lost sleep for Moore.

District PVI – D+22

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Wisconsin-5 – Jim Sensenbrenner/Republican – This is the only safe Republican district in Wisconsin, consisting of most of Milwaukee’s northern and western suburbs/exurbs.  It’s interesting how much more republican Milwaukee’s suburbs are than other cities in the Midwest, outside of maybe Indianapolis.  At any rate, he’s safe.

District PVI – R+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Wisconsin-6 – Tom Petri/Republican – Barack Obama pulled off a shocking win in this mostly rural/exurban district by a 50-49 count, but in all honesty, I don’t think the well-entrenched Petri will fret over that too much.  He’s safe.  

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Wisconsin-7 – David Obey/Democrat – This democratic-leaning district went big time for Barack Obama, he beat McCain by 14 points here, the same as his statewide average.  Obey, one of the oldest incumbents in the House of Representatives, should be fine, although his 21% win margin perhaps wasn’t as dominating as it looks because of the favorable 2008 cycle.  Obey has been fundraising as though he expects a strong challenge, he’s over 900k this cycle.  The two confirmed Republicans are Dan Mielke and Sean Duffy.  My guess is that the cycle could hold down Obey’s win margin, but he’s not in any kind of particular danger.

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Wisconsin-8 – Steve Kagen/Democrat – If there’s going to be any turnovers in Wisconsin in 2010, this is probably where it will happen.  The Green Bay-based 8th covers much of northeastern Wisconsin, and for a long time was a Republican stronghold.  That changed in a big way as Obama beat McCain 53-45 and Kagen beat ex-Rep John Gard by an identical margin.  Kagen initially beat Gard in 2006 by a 2% count.  The republicans are trying hard to win this seat back, and the primary field is huge.  Perhaps the leader in the pack is small business owner Reid Ribble, he has the best fundraising numbers so far at 182k.  Other names are former Door County GOP chair Marc Savard, state representative Roger Roth, and former state representative Terri McCormick.  Kagen is doing well in fundraising, having raised 798k to this point.  This looks to be a tense race, but the leftward trend of the district plus the fractured republican primary field will make this a tough pickup for the GOP.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Minnesota-1 – Tim Walz/Democrat – We now move to the land of the 10000 lakes, which looks to be mostly boring in 2010, outside of one district in particular that we’ll get to in a bit.  If the Republicans are going to net any gains in MN though, this is where they’ll need to do it.  Walz represents the southern tier of the state, a constituency that leans very slightly republican but that supported Obama over McCain 51-47.  Between where I get my research there seems to be some dispute as to who is actually in the GOP primary here, it tells me that asst. house minority leader Randy Demmer, congressional aide Jim Hagedorn, and former state representative Allen Quist are the major players but that the race is very much contested.  Regardless, though Walz’s outright liberal streak concerns me a bit, I think he’s in the clear because of his obvious popularity in the district.  

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Minnesota-2 – John Kline/Republican – It would appear to the casual observer that Kline is the safest member of the republican delegation in Minnesota.  But the democrats claim to have a few tough challengers ready to go, one being former state representative Shelley Madore.  Former airline pilot Dan Powers is also in the race.  Really though, I think Kline may be overly conservative, but he doesn’t tend to show off and make a jerk of himself, unlike a certain counterpart to the north.  I think he’s fine.

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Minnesota-3 – Erik Paulsen/Republican – This seat was a huge missed opportunity for the democrats in 2008 as an entrenched incumbent had retired and the seat was open.  Paulsen caught a huge break when the DFL, in essence, backed the wrong candidate, going with Iraq veteran Ashwin Madia over state senator Terri Bonoff, which helped lead to his 8% win.  Obama won over McCain by a 52-46 count in the presidential race.  Bonoff isn’t running again to the chagrin of the DCCC, but Paulsen won’t be without  competition this time around, as State PTA president Jim Meffert and physician Maureen Hackett are running in the DFL primary.  Hackett is leading in fundraising with 138k, but that pales in comparison with Paulsen’s illustrious 1.18 million total.  In a tight district like this, the incumbent always has to work hard, but I don’t see a Dem pickup as very likely.

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Minnesota-4 – Betty McCollum/Democrat – The St. Paul-based 4th is solidly democratic, so McCollum is safe.  

District PVI – D+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Minnesota-5 – Keith Ellison/Democrat – The Minneapolis-based 5th is another democratic stronghold, and is the most liberal part of Minnesota.  No problem for Ellison.

District PVI – D+23

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Minnesota-6 Michelle Bachmann/Republican – Here in the northern and northwestern exurbs of the twin cities lies perhaps the single most ridiculous, deranged, and insane member of the House, Michelle Bachmann.  The 6th wasn’t expected to be a major battleground in 2008, but after Bachmann made some McCarthy-esque comments late in the campaign, her opponent, Elwyn Tinklenburg, surged in fundraising and in the polls.  She won the race by 3%, getting by with a 46-43 plurality, well behind John McCain’s 53-45 win over Obama.  It’s hard to judge whether Bachmann is truly popular/unpopular in the 6th based on this result, but she does have several factors working in her favor.  First off, she’s collected 1.54 million this cycle, which is huge.  Second, the democratic primary is going to be a very tough affair between Minnesota senate majority leader Tarryl Clark and physician Maureen Reed, both of whom have raised roughly 600k so far.  I have little doubt that either Clark or Reed will be a formidable challenger, but I worry about the cost of a divisive primary here.  Team Blue’s chances are also brought down by the presence of democratic-leaning independent Troy Friehammer.  The presence of the independence party may have cost Tinklenburg a win in 2008.  Regrettably, I think Bachmann holds on.  If Clark wins the primary the chances of a pickup may increase nominally.  

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Minnesota-7 – Collin Peterson/Democrat – Peterson is a very conservative democrat who is well entrenched in this western Minnesota district.  Despite the partisan lean of the district, which gave John McCain a 3% win in 2008, it doesn’t appear that Team Red is even contesting the seat.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Minnesota-8 – James Oberstar/Democrat – Oberstar, like Peterson, is a well entrenched incumbent.  The district, which runs across northeastern Minnesota, used to be a democratic stronghold mostly due to organized labor but it is becoming more republican.  Oberstar is getting up in years, so an open seat situation would be tough, but for now, it’s a safe win.

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Region Recap – Well, well, well, look what we have here.  I’ve got the Democrats gaining 1 seat in the Western Great Lakes (IL-10), and the Republicans gaining none.  That makes this region so far the only region in which Team Blue has ended up on the plus side.  The pickup of IL-10 gives Team Blue 4 total pickups now, compared with 17 for Team Red, giving the GOP a net advantage of +13 seats through 7 regions.  

Next stop…The Central Plains

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 6

Hello, and welcome to part 6 of my 2010 baseline predictions for the House of Representatives.  In this section I will cover the western half of the deep south, referred to by me as the South Gulf.  This region encompasses the states of Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Texas.  There are 50 total seats in this region, of which the Democrats currently hold 18 and the Republicans hold 32.  Overall, this is one of the most conservative regions of the United States, perhaps the most (although the Plains Region might have something to say about that, we’ll cover that in part 8)

I think this is going to be a rather tough region for the democrats.  In a really big wave, the damage might not be as severe here as it could be in other regions that have more neutral/marginal seats, but there are several seats that the Dems own here that have eye-popping R+ PVIs.  Some of these seats will be the first to go in the 2010 elections.  

First off, a recap of where we’ve been, and where we still have to go:

Northeast – Rep +3 – (Rep pickups of NH-1, NY-24, NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even – (Rep pickups of PA-11, MD-1, Dem pickups of PA-6, DE-1)

Upper South – Rep +5 (Rep pickups of VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8)

South Atlantic – Even – (no pickups on either side)

Eastern Great Lakes – Rep +3 (Rep pickups of OH-1, MI-7, IN-8)

South Gulf –

Western Great Lakes –

Central Plains –

Rocky Mountains –

Pacific Coast –

Alabama-1 – Jo Bonner/Republican – This district, which encompasses the gulf coast of Alabama, is very conservative.  Bonner went uncontested in 2008, and is a lock for 2010.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Alabama-2 – Bobby Bright/Democrat – This extremely conservative district in southeastern Alabama was the site of one of the nation’s closest house races in 2008.  Montgomery mayor Bobby Bright pulled off a monster upset, defeating Jay Love by six-tenths of a percent after Love got dragged down in a brutal republican primary.  This is a district that supported McCain 63-37 over Obama, so it’s no surprise that they are going after Bright with hammer and tongs.  Bright’s voting record has been very independent, actually more like a republican than a democrat, so it’s not out of line with the district.  The Republicans have a crowded primary field, but one candidate, Montgomery city councilwoman Martha Roby, stands out.  Her fundraising has been average thus far, at 293k, but no other republican is on the map there.  Bright is at 752k, which isn’t bad.  Despite the voting record, and his money advantage, I feel all Roby has to do in this environment is say “he voted for Pelosi”, and it’s over.  

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Pickup (14th overall)

National Score – Rep +12

Alabama-3 – Mike Rogers/Republican – This district, like the neighboring 2nd, was the sight of a close house race in 2008, as Rogers held off democrat Josh Segall by 6%.  The district favored McCain over Obama by 13%, so Segall was able to overperform that.  However, this re-match is going to be tough for Segall because of the national environment.  Rogers so far has raised 640k to Segall’s 311k, but the cash on hand race is only a 175k difference.  Regardless, this is going to be an uphill climb unless if Rogers makes some significant errors.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Alabama-4 – Robert Aderholt/Republican – This is the 6th most republican district in the nation.  No trouble for Aderholt.

District PVI – R+26

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Alabama-5 – Parker Griffith/Republican – Now here’s an interesting situation!  Parker Griffith won this seat as a democrat and then turned his back on them, becoming a republican last December.  In the wake of his switch, his staff quit, and AL-5’s democratic base is up in arms.  The problem is that the democrats don’t have any solid candidates as of yet.  But Griffith is going to probably suffer in a tough republican primary, led by Madison County Commissioner Mo Brooks and businessman Les Philip.  It’s possible that 2008 candidate Wayne Parker could be in the mix too.  If the Democrats can get firmly behind a strong candidate they can win here.  But it’s not looking likely at the moment.

District PVI – R+12

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Alabama-6 – Spencer Bachus/Republican – This is the #1 most republican district in the nation.  Nuff said.

District PVI – R+29

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Alabama-7 – Open/Democrat – Outgoing rep Artur Davis is running for governor (yeah, good luck with that by the way), and the democrats are in search for somebody more, ahem, progressive to represent this seat.  Attorney Terri Sewell and state representative Earl Hilliard are the favorites here.  Either will keep the seat in democratic hands.

District PVI – D+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Mississippi-1 – Travis Childers/Democrat – Childers won this seat in a 2008 special election when Roger Wicker was appointed to the Senate, and he won a close race, then trounced his republican opponent by 11 points in the 2008 general election despite the fact that McCain crushed Obama by 25%.  That was impressive, but Childers can’t afford to rest on his laurels.  The republicans got one of their strongest recruits this cycle in state senator Alan Nunnelee, who has raised 421k to Childers’s 822k thus far.  Childers has attempted to fit the district with his voting record, which has been somewhat independent of the national party but again, these rural districts, especially in the south, have the potential to be brutal in 2010.  I say Nunnelee rides the environment and the partisan lean to a win.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (15th overall)

National Score – Rep +13

Mississippi-2 – Bennie Thompson/Democrat – This is the lone democratic district in Mississippi, and Thompson is fairly popular there, so it’s hard to imagine him having much trouble in 2010.

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Mississippi-3 – Gregg Harper/Republican – It’s hard to believe that this is the only district in Mississippi currently held by a republican.  In any case, Harper is safe.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Mississippi-4 – Gene Taylor/Democrat – Now we reach the master, or co-master if you include Chet Edwards, of holding down a crazy republican district as a democrat.  He’s been so strong that even in a cycle like this, the republicans aren’t throwing up much opposition.  This seat will likely be lost when it opens up, but for now, the democrats shouldn’t have much reason to sweat.  I however, refuse to put an R+20 district into lock status in an environment like this.  In the rural south, you just never know.

District PVI – R+20

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Louisiana-1 – Steve Scalise/Republican – Moving into the bayou now, we hit some very republican territory, some of the most republican in the entire nation.  Easy squeezie.

District PVI – R+24

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Louisiana-2 – Anh Cao/Republican – Cao pulled an upset of historic proportions when he took down William Jefferson by 3%.  This came in a special election held in December because the general had to be postponed because of hurricanes.  It took a scandal and a full freezer full of cash to get Cao where he is now, and given that, I don’t think he’s going to become the republican Gene Taylor.  The democratic primary is between state representatives Cedric Richmond and Juan LaFonta.  Richmond is ahead in fundraising and is just barely behind Cao in cash on hand.  While you can’t write off Cao completely, he is the incumbent, I don’t see him surviving here for long.  

District PVI – D+25

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Pickup (3rd overall)

National Score – Rep +12

Louisiana-3 – Open/Democrat – Aside from maybe Tennessee-6, this is probably the biggest open seat headache the democrats have in the entire country.  The seat is open due to Charlie Melancon’s decision to run for the Senate against weapons-grade jackass David Vitter.  The good news for the Democrats here is that the Republicans appear headed for a difficult primary, most likely between state representative Nickie Monica and attorney Jeff Landry.  The democratic field is paced by attorney Ravi Sangisetty, who is off to a decent fundraising lead over the field.  The wild card in this race is state natural resource secretary Scott Angelle, who is a democrat but whom the Republicans are trying to get to run for them as a party switcher.  The Dems are angling for him too.  I’m not sure what’s going to happen there, but with the candidates that are currently in, I think the Repubs pick this one up.

District PVI – R+12

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Strong Rep Pickup (16th overall)

National Score – Rep +13

Louisiana-4 – John Fleming/Republican – Fleming, a physician, won a razor close open seat race by four-tenths of one percent, a race that actually occurred in December due to hurricanes delaying the election.  That delay probably cost the democrats the victory here.  Given that, you’d think that the democrats would be going after him hard, but they don’t even have a candidate in the race.  It looks as though Fleming might go unopposed in 2010, which was unfathomable about 13 months ago.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Louisiana-5 – Rodney Alexander/Republican – This northeastern Louisiana district is like most in the state, very conservative.  No problem for him.  

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Louisiana-6 – Bill Cassidy/Republican – This was a race that absolutely haunted Democrats in 2008, as incumbent Don Cazayoux, who won a 2008 special election for the seat, went through an awful, racially based primary against Michael Jackson.  Following Jackson’s defeat, he decided to be a sore loser and run as an independent, splitting the vote and giving Cassidy a 48% plurality victory.  With Cazayoux likely headed to the federal bench, he won’t be running again, and in fact, like in LA-4, the Dems don’t even have a candidate yet.  Amazing how both of these districts just got away and fell into the abyss, probably never to be seen again as Fleming and Cassidy become entrenched.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Louisiana-7 – Charles Boustany/Republican – Yet another extremely republican district.  Get used to it folks, we ain’t in the northeast no more.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-1 – Lou Gohmert/Republican – We move now into the Lone Star State, which outside of the urban areas and the south toward Mexico has become a haven for lunatic reactionaries.  This district, in rural east Texas, personifies that.  No threat for Gohmert.  

District PVI – R+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-2 – Ted Poe/Republican – This district, in the southeast corner of Texas, is republican territory and an easy retention for Poe, who didn’t even have a challenger in 2008.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-3 – Samuel Johnson/Republican – Johnson is fairly well entrenched inside a district that voted 57-42 for McCain.  The district is starting to turn democratic, but it’s going to be a while until the democrats have a shot at winning it.  

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-4 – Ralph Hall/Republican – The northeast corner of the state, this district is rural, very white, and very, very red.  

District PVI – R+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-5 – Jeb Hensarling/Republican – This is a really easy call as well, as this northeast Texas district is like most of the others, very conservative.

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-6 – Joe Barton/Republican – We continue to slog through north central rural country, and this district is just like the rest of em really.  Nothing to see here.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-7 – John Culberson/Republican – This fairly rich, ritzy part of Houston’s northwest is very republican territory, so much so that Culberson will walk through this one unscathed despite getting pressed  a bit in 2008.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-8 – Kevin Brady/Republican – Yet another solidly republican district in rural east Texas, and this one happens to be the 8th most republican in the nation.  Yeesh.  

District PVI – R+25

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-9 – Al Green/Democrat – At last we hit a democrat-controlled district, this one in the southern portion of the Houston metroplex.  Green is a solid incumbent in a solidly democratic district, so he shouldn’t have any worries.

District PVI – D+22

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-10 – Michael McCaul/Republican – McCaul won his 2008 re-election by 11%, an amount that mirrored the presidential vote here.  It looked like he was headed for a tough re-election against businessman Jack McDonald, but after raising over 1 million he abruptly quit the race in December.  The Dems have since coalesced around 2006 candidate Ted Ankrum, but he came up short by 15 points in a favorable 2006, so it’s hard to imagine him getting close against the well-funded McCaul in 2010.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-11 – Mike Conaway/Republican – This district, which is between the panhandle and the deserts north of the Rio Grande, is the 3rd most republican in the nation.

District PVI – R+28

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-12 – Kay Granger/Republican – The 12th is another republican stronghold, lying to the west of the fort worth area.  Granger is safe.

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-13 – Mac Thornberry/Republican – This panhandle-based district is a place where very few democrats exist.  Thornberry is probably more worried about challenges from his right, if anything.

District PVI – R+29

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-14 – Ron Paul/Republican – The leading libertarian in the house, Paul sometimes makes some strange votes on occasion, which reflects in his party unity scores.  But he’s safe.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-15 – Ruben Hinojosa/Democrat – I don’t get the numbering of Texas districts, we’ve gone from the upper panhandle to the gulf coast to the rio grande valley in the past three districts.  Oh, yes, Hinojosa looks good.

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-16 – Silvestre Reyes/Democrat – And now we’re in the El Paso metroplex, go figure.  Well, at any rate Reyes doesn’t have much to worry about here.

District PVI – D+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-17 – Chet Edwards/Democrat – Back into rural east-central Texas now, and we find a real political anomaly.  Chet Edwards has been able to retain his hold on a district that voted 67-32 for McCain in 2008 and bigger than that for Bush in 2000 and 2004.  He’s in charge of the 19th most Republican seat in the nation.  That being said, his hold is tenuous at best, as he defeated cash-strapped republican Rob Curnock 53-45.  Curnock is back for another run in 2010, but he faces a crowded primary, most notably against businessman Rob Flores, who has fundraised well at 667k so far, and he’s spent some of that already to raise his profile in the district.  To get re-elected as a democrat in a wingnut district like this, in this environment, in the rural south, is just about mission impossible.  This year, I think Edwards’s train reaches the end of the line, regardless of who wins the republican primary.

District PVI – R+20

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (17th overall)

Total National Score – Rep +14

Texas-18 – Sheila Lee/Democrat – We reach the downtown of Houston now, and as with most urban districts, it’s pretty much a cinch for any democrat, including Lee.

District PVI – D+24

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-19 – Randy Neugebauer/Republican – Another crazy republican district in the panhandle, this one the 5th most republican in the nation.

District PVI – R+26

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-20 – Charlie Gonzalez/Democrat – Our random bopping around the state continues, we’re now in downtown San Antonio.  I swear this is getting to be like “Where in Texas is StephenCLE?”  Yeah, Gonzalez is in good shape for re-election.

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-21 – Lamar Smith/Republican – This district is essentially exurbs of Austin and San Antonio, making it an easy hold for a republican.  

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-22 – Pete Olson/Republican – Democrat Nick Lampson won here in 2006 when Tom Delay got awashed in his own filth, but he couldn’t hold it in 2008 against Olson.  2010 should be much nicer for republicans and Olson’s win margin should respond appreciably.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-23 – Ciro Rodriguez/Democrat – Rodriguez has once been knocked out via primary challenge, and it looks as though history has a chance to repeat itself, albeit not a great chance.  Lawyer Miguel Ortiz is challenging Rodriguez for the democratic nomination.  Unless he is really softened up, its hard to imagine Rodriguez not making it through the general, as the republican opposition is poor.  Francisco Canseco and William Hurd lead the primary field.  Rodriguez is well over 800k raised so far, so he’s in good financial shape.

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Texas-24 – Kenny Marchant/Republican – This fort-worth based district is starting to trend to the left now, but it has a ways to go.  This cycle will hurt as Marchant doesn’t even have a challenger.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-25 – Lloyd Doggett/Democrat – The Austin-based 25th used to be a swing district, but it has swung extremely hard in the democratic direction the last few election cycles.  Doggett is pretty much safe here.

District PVI – D+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-26 – Michael Burgess/Republican – This district takes in virtually all of fast-growing Denton County and parts of Fort Worth too.  It, like many districts in the Dallas-Fort Worth area is starting to trend blue, but it is still very red for the time being.  

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-27 – Solomon Ortiz/Democrat – Ortiz is a pretty entrenched incumbent, and although this Corpus Christi/Brownsville based district does lean slightly republican, it doesn’t appear that he is going to get much of a challenge here.  Still, he only won by 19% in 2008, which implies that this race could eventually become competitive.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Texas-28 – Henry Cuellar/Democrat – Now here’s a guy that is in total command of his district, he hugely overperformed Obama in the 2008 election.  None of the three republicans in the race are even second-tier, so this doesn’t look to be much of a race.

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-29 – Gene Green/Democrat – The 29th sprawls over much of the east side of Houston, and Green is very well entrenched.  Nothing to see here.

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-30 – Eddie Johnson/Democrat – The heart of central Dallas, this is the most democratic district in Texas, and an easy win for Johnson.

District PVI – D+27

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Texas-31 – John Carter/Republican – I’m starting to yawn here, there’s just no action in Texas outside of Edwards’s district.  This one looks to be a yawner too.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Texas-32 – Pete Sessions/Republican – Now this is one district that is threatening to fall out under the feet of the incumbent.  This once solidly republican district had the look of a swing district in 2008 as Obama came within 7% of McCain.  Sessions, who won re-election by 17%, is the leader of the NRCC, which might be why the democrats are committed to going after him.  Grier Roggio, the democratic candidate must get going on the fundraising front though, as he’s only raised 189k so far, which isn’t going to get it done against all the resources Sessions has at his disposal.  

District PVI – R+8

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Region Recap – The south gulf region is tough territory, and it looks to get even tougher in 2010, as I have the Republicans picking up four districts, AL-2, MS-1, LA-3, and TX-17, giving them 17 total.  The Democrats will pick up LA-2, giving them their 3rd overall.  That leaves the national score at Republicans +14 through six regions.  

Next stop…The Western Great Lakes

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 5

Welcome to Part 5 of my baseline predictions for the 2010 House of Representatives elections.  In this section, I will cover my home region, the Eastern Great Lakes, which consists of Indiana, Michigan, and Ohio.  These are all fairly important states, Ohio being perhaps the pre-eminent swing state in the nation, Michigan containing a nice haul of electoral votes, and Indiana appearing to be a swing state of the future.  All three of these states have their fair share of competitive house races, particularly Ohio, so we’ll get down and dirty in the rust belt.  First though, a recap of where we’ve been so far:

Northeast – Rep +3 (Repubs pick up NH-1, NY-24, & NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even (Repubs pick up PA-11 & MD-1, Dems pick up PA-6 & DE-1)

Upper South – Rep +5 (Repubs pick up VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, & TN-8)

South Atlantic – Even (no pickups on either side)

Total so far – Rep +8

Indiana-1 – Peter Visclosky /Democrat – This district, which comprises much of northwestern Indiana and the Chicago suburban area around Gary, is rarely competitive.  Visclosky supposedly has some ethical issues that could prove problematic in the future, but I haven’t heard anything about them hurting his electoral chances as of yet.  He’s always been a great vote-getter.

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Indiana-2 – Joe Donnelly/Democrat – This is a swing district in the north central part of the state that Obama carried by 9% in 2008, which was a huge swing to the left as Bush won by 12% in 2004.  Donnelly destroyed his republican challenger in 2008 by almost 40 points, but this race is expected to be much more of a battle.  The Republicans have what they think is a strong challenger in state representative Jackie Wolarski.  Having gotten into the race fairly late, Wolarski is way behind in the fundraising battle, by a count of 751k to 110k cash on hand.  This doesn’t look like a hugely serious race, but in this environment, you just never know.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Indiana-3 – Mark Souder/Republican – The Fort Wayne based 3rd district covers most of northeastern Indiana, and it is very conservative in nature.  Yet this district is somewhat on the radar because of Mark Souder’s meh standing as an incumbent.  Souder was nearly swept away in 2006 as he struggled to beat physician Tom Hayhurst, but he came back strong in 2008, defeating Michael Montagano by 16%.  Hayhurst is giving it another shot in 2010, and though the fundraising numbers look unimpressive for the incumbent thus far, I feel this district is simply too conservative for Hayhurst to win in this environment.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Indiana-4 – Open/Republican – This seat is one of the most conservative in Indiana.  The seat is open, but with two solid candidates in Indiana secretary of state  Todd Rokita and state senator Brandt Hershman running in the republican primary, it’s almost impossible to see a situation in which the democrats pick up this seat.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Indiana-5 – Dan Burton/Republican – This is the most Republican seat in Indiana, containing many of Indianapolis’s cherry red exurbs.  Easy territory for Burton.

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Indiana-6 – Mike Pence/Republican – One of the big republican leaders in the House, Pence won’t have any trouble retaining his seat.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Indiana-7 – Andre Carson/Democrat – This Indianapolis-centered district is a major democratic stronghold, one that is turning rapidly more liberal by the day, or so it seems.  Carson is safe here.  There’s talk that the Republicans might crack this district in redistricting to get rid of Carson, but honestly, I think they’d be ill-advised to do so given the blue trend throughout the state.

District PVI – D+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Indiana-8 – Open/Democrat – The 8th, which contains much of southwestern Indiana including Evansville and Terre Haute, is going to be the site of an intense open seat battle now that Brad Ellsworth has jumped into the open seat Senate race (which, incidentally, I think is the right move by Ellsworth because he has a great chance at winning).  State representative Trent Van Haaften is the likely democratic candidate, while the republican field is crowded, led by cardiologist Larry Bucshon.  At this point it’s hard to tell what’s going to happen here because of the seat just coming open in the last few days, but ultimately, I think this is going to be a very tough hold for the Democrats.

District PVI – R+8

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Pickup (11th overall)

Total National Score – Rep +9

Indiana-9 – Baron Hill/Democrat – This is going to be another difficult district for the Democrats to hold.  Baron Hill isn’t exactly beloved in the 9th, which covers much of southeastern Indiana.  The good news is, his perennial challenger, Mike Sodrel, is even more hated by the ninth’s voters.  It appears that these two could be on a crash course for yet another matchup, but he’ll have to get through a primary against lawyer Todd Young, who also worked in senator Richard Lugar’s office at one time.  Hill is a good fundraiser, but his unpopularity means this is going to be a fight.  It might come down to whether or not Sodrel makes it through the republican primary, if he does that’s a definite plus.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Dem Hold

Michigan-1 – Bart Stupak/Democrat – Stupak’s district used to be solidly democratic, but it has trended republican since the early 90s.  Obama did win this upper  peninsula district by 2%, and Stupak is fairly well entrenched, so he shouldn’t have any problem.

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Michigan-2 – Open/Republican – Peter Hoekstra’s run for governor of Michigan has opened up this seat, and with Obama’s strong finish here, only falling by 4 points to McCain, you’d expect the Democrats to step up here with a challenge.  But so far, only 2008 candidate Fred Johnson is in.  Meanwhile the republican field is filled with candidates that are fundraising very well, such as state senator Wayne Kuipers, former NFL player Jay Riemersma, and former state representative Bill Huizenga.  Given that, I don’t see much shot at a democratic pickup here.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Michigan-3 – Open/Republican – The retirement of Vern Ehlers has opened this seat up, but once again the democrats are suffering from a recruitment shortfall.  The Grand Rapids-based 3rd was a 49-49 tie between McCain and Obama.  At this point, there are so many candidates in the Republican primary that I can’t talk about them all, but the democratic opposition isn’t there right now.  

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Michigan-4 – Dave Camp/Republican – This is a district that like many in Michigan, shed it’s Republican leanings in 2008 and went for Obama.  But Camp is an extremely entrenched incumbent and won by 26% in 2008, so he’s safe.

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Michigan-5 – Dale Kildee/Democrat – Kildee’s district, centered upon Flint, is a pretty easy win for Kildee, who’s well entrenched.

District PVI – D+11

Stephen’s Rating -Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Michigan-6 – Fred Upton/Republican – The Kalamazoo-based 6th in southwestern Michigan has become a partisan battleground, one that Barack Obama won by 10% over McCain.  But unfortunately for Democrats, the 6th is home to another well entrenched Republican in Fred Upton, who won re-election by 20% in 2008.  As far as I know no democrat has even stepped up to challenge Upton, which is a huge recruiting failure because Dems can’t be letting even districts like this go quietly.  

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Michigan-7 – Mark Schauer/Democrat – The south central 7th district is another formerly Republican district that has become swing territory (yeah, the Repubs are a few election cycles away from this map becoming a complete dummymander).  Schauer defeated Tim Walberg by 2% in 2008, and Walberg wants his seat back.  He’ll have to fight for it in a primary against Iraq war veteran Brian Rooney.  So far Walberg has raised 387k this cycle to Rooney’s 218k, but there is the possibility that this could be a difficult primary.  Schauer is killing it in the fundraising game, having raised 1.41 million thus far.  Looking at this district, a rural district that is usually republican-leaning (though Obama won by 6%), and Schauer’s extremely close win, you’d think this would be a republican pickup.  But the fundraising and the primary setup suggests otherwise.  This is a very tough call.  Ultimately, I think that rural districts are going to be much more susceptible to the change in the national environment than urban ones, and as such, Schauer will lose by a razor-thin margin.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (12th overall)

Total National Score – Rep +10

Michigan-8 – Mike Rogers/Republican – The 8th, which contains Lansing and much of central Michigan, voted for Obama by 7%, but again, another strong, entrenched incumbent exists for the republicans as Rogers won by 16% over his dem challenger in 2008.  With the environment what it is, it’s not a great year for a challenge to Rogers.  Redistricting though could be a big problem for Rogers if  the Dems hold onto the state house, there’s just not enough territory to keep him, Upton, Camp, and maybe Walberg/Rooney safe in a compromise map.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Michigan-9 – Gary Peters/Democrat – This district, containing much of Oakland County and Detroit’s northern suburbs, has moved to the left fairly quick.  Obama won by 13% here, and Gary Peters beat up on Joe Knollenberg by 9% in 2008 to win the seat.  Peters will face a challenge for sure, but like the 7th, it’s going to be a tight affair in the Republican primary.  Oakland County GOP chair Paul Welday, businessman Gene Goodman, and former state representative Andrew Razckowski are all in and all have raised over 200k thus far, though that pales in comparison with Peters’s 1.5 million.  This will definitely be a fight, but because of 2008 margin as well as geography, I think Peters is in better shape than Schauer is over in MI-7.

District PVI – D+2

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Michigan-10 – Candice Miller/Republican – This was one of three Michigan districts that voted for McCain in 2008, and ultimately I don’t really see anybody mounting a challenge to the entrenched Miller.  

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Michigan-11 – Thad McCotter/Republican – For the democrats, this district was a missed opportunity in both 2006 and 2008 as they were unable to find a strong candidate.  It looks as though those recruitment woes are continuing in 2010, as state senator Glenn Anderson and state house speaker Andy Dillon have both passed on the race.  Civic leader and former teacher Natalie Mosher is the only declared candidate against McCotter, who won by 6% in 2008 despite Obama winning 54-45 over McCain.  

District PVI – Even

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Michigan-12 – Sandy Levin/Democrat – Now we start to get into Detroit’s inner suburbs and core, and indeed, this district is quite democratic.  Levin shouldn’t have much trouble in 2010.

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Michigan-13 – Carolyn Kilpatrick/Democrat – Now we hit downtown Detroit, and this is some of the most liberal territory in the United States.  Kilpatrick I believe is facing a primary, but regardless of whether that turns into something serious or not, this seat will stay in democratic hands for sure.

District PVI – D+31

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Michigan-14 – John Conyers/Democrat – Another urban district that is extremely democratic, the most democratic district in Michigan.  Conyers is safe.

District PVI – D+34

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Michigan-15 – John Dingell/Democrat – This district is essentially a democratic vote sink in southeast Michigan, containing Detroit’s southern suburbs and liberal-leaning Ann Arbor.  Dingell is safe, and even if he were to retire at some point the dems would have no trouble holding this one.

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Ohio-1 – Steve Dreihaus/Democrat – Alright, now for the big bad, buckeye state.  We begin my home sweet home in the Cincinnati area, which has been historically conservative but went for Obama by 11% in 2008, a win bolstered mostly by the district’s black constituency.  Dreihaus won by 5% over 7-term incumbent Steve Chabot, which was impressive.  Chabot is back for a rematch and boy does it look like a brawl.  Chabot has raised 704k thus far this cycle, while Driehaus is at 869k.   In a battle like this, in a district where there are essentially two extreme right wing and left wing factions and very few moderates, turnout is going to be huge.  And quite frankly, I don’t have much faith that Cincinnati’s black population, so critical to Driehaus’s 08 victory, is going to turn out in 2010.  I really like Driehaus, but I just don’t see how he wins this race.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Moderate Rep Pickup (13th overall)

Total National Score – Rep +11

Ohio-2 – Jean Schmidt/Republican – Schmidt, formerly the biggest loudmouth in the house republican caucus before getting displaced by Michelle Bachmann, has survived two surprisingly strong challenges in 2006 and 2008.  In fact, the unpopular Schmidt was probably saved by the fact that democrat Victoria Wulsin and independent David Krikorian split the anti-Schmidt vote in 2008, allowing her to survive with a 45% plurality.   Not impressive at all in a district that is very republican.  Krikorian is running again, this time as a democrat, but he faces a primary challenge from Surya Yalamanchili.  In a year such as this, unpopular incumbents of all stripes should be on notice. If Krikorian wins the primary as he should, who knows, this could end up being a tight race despite the environment and the 2nd’s conservatism.  FWIW, Schmidt’s raised 480k so far this cycle to Krikorian’s 189k.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Ohio-3 – Mike Turner/Republican – Turner is intensely popular in the Dayton area, and the district leans republican anyway, so the democrats aren’t in good shape here at all.  

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Ohio-4 – Jim Jordan/Republican – Heading into the rural west of the state now, the 4th is the most republican district in Ohio, and Jordan is fairly well liked inside the district.   He should have no trouble whatsoever.  

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Ohio-5 – Bob Latta/Republican – Latta, who hails from my collegiate home of Bowling Green, Ohio, is pretty much a lying scumbag cheat that lied about his primary opponents in the 2007 special election but still was elected over democrat Robin Weirauch in the general.   This district took a nice swing to the left in 2008, as Obama only lost by 8%, but it’s not exactly what I would call competitive, unfortunately.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Ohio-6 – Charlie Wilson/Democrat – Wilson is a fairly entrenched incumbent, but his district, which runs along the Ohio river  in Ohio’s southeast, is trending republican.  It’s actually slightly conservative now according to the PVI, but the Republicans don’t have a strong challenger here.   Donald Allen, who has only 3k cash on hand, has the unenviable task of going up against the popular Wilson.  Still, because of the environment and the rightward lean in Appalachia, it’s not a lock.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Ohio-7 – Steve Austria/Republican – Austria netted 58% in a 2008 open seat race in this south-central Ohio district, and I don’t really see much of a challenge being put up against him in 2010.  

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Ohio-8 – John Boehner/Republican – Ah yes, the House republican leader, fearless leader Boner…err Boehner.  Stupid spelling.  Tomato, tomatoe, it’s all the same.  Oh his re-election?  Yeah, it’s pretty much in the bag.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Ohio-9 – Marcy Kaptur/Democrat – This district, which encompasses most of the Toledo area and the western Lake Erie coastline, is a solid democratic district.   Kaptur, who’s been around the block quite a few times, won’t have any problem here.

District PVI – D+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Ohio-10 – Dennis Kucinich/Democrat – Proof that there are enemies within your own side as well, Kucinich has been his own party of no lately, but he’s very popular on Cleveland’s west side for reasons that I have not yet deciphered even though I’ve lived here for 22 years.  Unfortunately, it doesn’t appear as though the democrats plan to primary him, but thankfully, the Republican opposition isn’t there either.  Still, there is a large contingent in the 10th that hates him, so I think Generic R could put up a surprisingly good showing here.  Remember, Kucinich only got 57% in 2008, not very good.  Also, Kucinich’s fundraising has been nonexistent thus far.

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Ohio-11 – Marcia Fudge/Democrat – This is the most democratic district in Ohio, and one of the most democratic in the nation.  No problem for Fudge, who’s practically a deity in this district anyway.

District PVI – D+32

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Ohio-12 – Patrick Tiberi/Republican – Tiberi, like Thad McCotter in MI-11, has gotten lucky and hasn’t faced much opposition the last two cycles, but his luck may be running out for two reasons.  First, this Columbus-based district is growing rapidly more democratic, and second, Franklin County Commissioner Paula Brooks is in the race for the democrats.  Her fundraising has been decent thus far, collecting 392k thus far, although she is still down 2-1 to Tiberi in cash on hand.  Another problem for Brooks is that she actually lives in OH-15, so she could get the carpetbagger charge thrown her way.  I’m undecided on this race because I don’t know if Tiberi is a strong incumbent based on his 2006 and 2008 performances, or if those were a result of poor Democratic opposition.  What I do know is that the national environment probably won’t be a lifesaver here because of Columbus’s rapid turn to the left.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Ohio-13 – Betty Sutton/Democrat – We now reach my home district, OH-13, where within the last week or so a strong race is shaping up.  Republican Tom Ganley’s entry into the race has spiced this one up for Sutton, who is a very popular incumbent.  She’s not really been tested like this though.  Her fundraising of 365k so far is decent, but actually puts her at a disadvantage against the self-funding Ganley.  Ganley has the same problem Paula Brooks has though, as he actually lives in OH-10, so the carpetbagger charge will probably be lobbed at him too.  Ultimately, this is a suburban district that leans democratic according to the PVI, and with Sutton’s popularity, I would find it very hard to imagine her losing.  Maybe I’m biased because this is ground zero for me, but Ganley has an uphill climb despite the money advantage.  

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Ohio-14 – Steve LaTourette/Republican – I will always have respect for this man as he once took my 8th grade class onto the floor of the House or Representatives when we went to D.C. in 2001.  He’s a fairly entrenched incumbent too, as he defeated his democratic challenger by 20 points in 2008 while Obama and McCain fought to a virtual draw here.  He’s in good shape for another term.  

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Ohio-15 – Mary Kilroy/Democrat – Now comes a race that has the look of a real conundrum.  Mary Kilroy defeated Steve Stivers in a razor close 46-45 plurality outcome, a race that really puts her in almost an identical position to Jean Schmidt in OH-2.  Like Schmidt, it seems as if Kilroy has some likeability issues, because she underperformed Obama by 8%, most all of that going to the independent candidate(s).  Maybe that’s why she has spent 414k of her 1.1 million already in an attempt to drive up her favorables.  Stivers is back for another run at the seat, and he’s fundraised very well so far, only trailing Kilroy by about 200k in cash on hand at the moment.  OH-15 is a tough district to understand for 2010, because it is trending in the democratic direction as a whole, but is laden with student voters as well (Ohio State University is in OH-15), who may not turn as well in 2010. Then there’s one more factor, the presence of constitution party (ie: teabagger) David Ryon, which will almost certainly take votes away from Stivers.   Geez, after all that, how do I make a prediction.  I think without the independent candidate in this race, Kilroy would be in big trouble.  But with that factor in play, I’m on pins and needles, but by the smallest of margins, I think Kilroy makes it through.  Ridiculous race in the capital.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Dem Hold

Ohio-16 – John Boccieri/Democrat – This district, which consists of Cleveland’s southern suburbs and exurbs, was Republican territory for a long time, but Boccieri changed that when he beat Kirk Schuring by 11% in a 2008 open seat race.  That was big, as McCain edged Obama by a 2% margin here.  Former mayor and accountant Jim Renacci is the big favorite for the Republican nomination here, and he’s fundraised pretty well, collecting 414k to Boccieri’s 824k.  Assuming Renacci doesn’t get pulled down in the primary, which is unlikely, this is likely to be a good fight.  I think Boccieri is a rising star in the democratic party though, as he’s a great campaigner.  The environment will make this one tough, but I like Boccieri to retain.

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Ohio-17 – Timothy Ryan/Democrat – The Youngstown based 17th is one of the few democratic strongholds in the state, and Ryan is pretty well liked by his constituency.  The only potential reason to pay attention to OH-17 is the rumor that former representative James Traficant may run as an independent.  Good luck with that James.

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Ohio-18 – Zach Space/Democrat – Space was swept into this normally conservative seat in 2006 thanks to the infamous “coingate” scandal that erupted on the previous incumbent.  He’s won both of his races by big margins, but 2010 will be a different animal given the environment.  The good news for Space is twofold though, first he’s on a fundraising tear at 1.31 million, and second, the republican primary looks like its going to be a crowded and potentially crushing affair.  State senator Bob Gibbs appears to be the slight favorite, but former state agriculture director Fred Dailey, and lawyer Jeanette Moll are also in the race and very capable.  All three will have an uphill climb against Space, who is popular in his district, but it will be a good race.  Space’s money advantage could be decisive though.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Region Recap – The Eastern Great Lakes is a region worth watching, one that could be potentially tough for the Democrats.  In a worst case scenario, the Republicans could pick up 6-7 seats in this region, but in a best case scenario, the Dems might not lose any and might even have a shot at a few pickups, like OH-2 and OH-12.  I give the Republicans three pickups here, IN-8, MI-7, and OH-1, bringing them 13 total pickups and a national score thus far of Republican +11 as we hit the halfway point of this journey.

Next stop…The Deep South Gulf

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 4

Welcome to Part 4 of my 2010 baseline predictions for the house of representatives.  In this section, we’ll head into the Deep South, which I’ve split up into two regions, the deep south Atlantic, consisting of South Carolina, Georgia, and Florida, and the deep south Gulf, which covers Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Texas.  Today we’ll cover the south Atlantic, and the south gulf will be covered in part 6.

National Recap so far –

Northeast – Rep +3 (rep gains NH-1, NY-24, NY-29)

Mid-Atlantic – Even (rep gains PA-11, MD-1; dem gains DE-1, PA-6)

Upper South – Rep +5 (rep gains VA-2, VA-5, TN-4, TN-6, TN-8)

The South Atlantic doesn’t look all that interesting, honestly, though by election day that might change.  There aren’t any top tier races in Georgia or South Carolina, and thus far, the one hotbed of the region is in the central part of Florida thanks to some vulnerable incumbents.  The good news for the Democrats in this region is that most of their seats are centered in urban areas, which might shelter them from the wrath of a rural republican “teabagger” uprising in 2010.  

South Carolina-1 – Open/Republican – This district was the site of one of the most intriguing and surprising races of 2008, as Brown barely held on against the openly lesbian democratic challenger, Linda Ketner.  That poor performance, combined with an upcoming primary challenger in Carroll Campbell Jr., caused him to bail.  With the seat open, Campbell Jr is the favorite on the Republican side, barely, as the field is deep and his fundraising has been poor thus far at 121k.  The Democratic side is also very unsettled, with no clear favorite, though it’s unfortunate that Ketner isn’t running again.  Ultimately, with the environment being what it is, it’s hard to imagine the Dems picking this up, but it’s not impossible.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

South Carolina-2 – Joe Wilson/Republican – This is about as high profile a house race as you can have.  Joe Wilson, the famed representative who yelled out that Barack Obama was a liar in front of the whole world, has received a lot of heat, and fame, for his outburst.  His shout heard round the world also gave himself, and his Dem opponent Robert Miller, a ton of cash.  Wilson currently has 2.3 million in cash on hand, while Miller has 1.7 million.  This is going to be a war, and I have a feeling it’s going to be very ugly in nature.  This district is conservative, and voted for McCain by 9 points, so I give an edge to Wilson to retain.  If the environment wasn’t in the republicans’ favor Wilson would be in dire straits.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

South Carolina-3 – Open/Republican – This is an intensely conservative seat, held currently by Gresham Barrett.  As of now, the republican primary is a crowded affair, with state representative Rex Rice, state senators Shane Massey & Jeff Duncan, and businessman Richard Cash all vying for the chance to succeed Barrett.  The likely Democratic candidate is Jane Dyer, who is fundraising close with the republican challengers.  The problem for her is that this district is one of the most conservative in the nation, so a Dem pickup is extremely unlikely.

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

South Carolina-4 – Bob Inglis/Republican – The big question here is whether or not Bob Inglis will survive a primary challenge.  The Dems really should put forth a challenger in case he doesn’t, but so far they don’t have one.  

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

South Carolina-5 – John Spratt/Democrat – Spratt has been for a long time an entrenched House incumbent in the 5th, but this year it looks like he might get a fairly strong challenge.  The Repubs have coalesced around state senator Mick Mulvaney, who is a freshman in that body.  I don’t have any fundraising data on this race, but despite the enthusiasm around Mulvaney, it’s hard to imagine a young-un like him taking out a strong incumbent like Spratt, even in a slightly conservative district.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

South Carolina-6 – James Clyburn/Democrat – This is the one democratic district in South Carolina, and Clyburn is fairly well entrenched here.  It’s also a VRA district, making Republican takeover  a very difficult proposition.  

District PVI – D+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Georgia-1 – Jack Kingston/Republican – This southeastern Georgia district is very conservative, and favored McCain by 25% over Obama.  It’s not really on the democratic radar screen for 2010.

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-2 – Sanford Bishop/Democrat – This district, which comprises much of southwestern Georgia, is a rarity in the south in that it is a swing district.  Most southern districts are either intensely democratic in the cities and intensely republican in the country.  Bishop is currently heavily favored for re-election, but he is facing a republican challenger in Mike Keown.  I shouldn’t think this challenge will amount to much, but seeing as this is the rural south, I can’t completely count out the republican.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Georgia-3 – Lynn Westmoreland/Republican – This district in west-central Georgia is crazy conservative and so is Westmoreland.   A good match really.  

District PVI – R+19

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-4 – Hank Johnson/Democrat – Heading into metro Atlanta now, this district comprises Atlanta’s east, covering most of Dekalb County.  Johnson won’t be sweating over re-election as this district is very democratic.  

District PVI – D+24

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Georgia-5 – John Lewis/Democrat – This district, which consists of central Atlanta, is probably the safest for Democrats in the entire south outside of South Florida.  Lewis is safe.

District PVI – D+26

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Georgia-6 – Tom Price/Republican – The 6th district, which is centered north of the Atlanta metro area, is starting to turn in the Democratic direction, but it has a long way to go before it becomes competitive.  Price is safe.

District PVI – R+19

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-7 – John Linder/Republican – The 7th district, which falls to the northeast and east of the Atlanta area, is also starting to take a democratic turn, but as with the neighboring 6th, it still has a long way to travel before a democrat can look to win here unless we find the next Bobby Bright or Gene Taylor.

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-8 – Jim Marshall/Democrat – This is perhaps the one district in the state that, on paper, has a decent chance at turning over.  This south-central Georgia district is fairly conservative in nature, but Marshall has voted fairly well in line with their political lean, defecting from the party on some key issues.  That, and the fact that the Republican side has had some major recruiting woes here is keeping him in good shape.  Businesswoman Angela Hicks is the favorite in the republican primary as several state senators the NRCC attempted to recruit have given her their blessing, but the field is deep, and she has not fundraised well at all to this point.  Marshall’s fundraising has been fairly lackluster.  It’s a tricky race because Marshall only won by 15% in 2008 (Obama got beat 56-43), so this race is almost guaranteed to be closer based on the political environment.  

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Georgia-9 – Open/Republican – Hey, here’s an open republican seat!  Yay!  Only problem is this pine tree covered part of north Georgia is the 4th most republican in the nation, voting 75-23 for McCain.  On the bright side, if you like wingnut on wingnut warfare…this is the district for you.

District PVI – R+28

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-10 – Paul Broun/Republican – There’s actually a nice democratic vote center in the 10th, coming in the form of the college town of Athens.  But it’s pretty much an island of blue in a sea of deep, deep red.  Not much chance here.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-11 – Phil Gingrey/Republican – The 11th district contains much of northwestern Georgia rural country, with Rome as it’s major population center.  And unfortunately, its not competitive in the least.  

District PVI – R+20

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Georgia-12 – John Barrow/Democrat – This east Georgia  district centered upon Augusta was re-drawn following a rare mid-decade redistricting, which stripped Athens out of the district in favor of more rural territory.  Barrow survived a tough race in 2006 but romped to a 66-34 win in 2008 while Obama won the district by 9%.  The Republicans appeared to have a good challenger here in army veteran and surgeon Wayne Mosley, but his dropping out has really left the NRCC in a hole.  Now the primary is likely to be a divided and tough affair between a bunch of Some Guys.  That’s not going to get it done against an entrenched incumbent like Barrow.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Georgia-13 – David Scott/Democrat – This is the newest district in the state, stretching over Atlanta’s western and southern suburbs.   It’s fairly democratic in nature, and Scott is well entrenched.  Not much chance of losing this one.

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Florida-1 – Jeff Miller/Republican – We now move into Florida, a perennially key state, which begins a stretch of four big, swing states in a row for us.  That’s notable, even though this western panhandle-based district isn’t, it’s solidly republican.

District PVI – R+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-2 – Allen Boyd/Democrat – This is an odd district.  It is a swing district trending quickly rightward, but has a democratic blue dog-ish representative.  But instead of a strong republican challenge, it looks like Allen Boyd’s biggest trouble will be getting through a primary challenge from Al Lawson.  Boyd has about a  10-1 cash on hand advantage, but if Lawson consolidates the sizeable black vote in the district he’s got a shot.  The Republicans’ only chance is if Boyd is defeated in the primary, as their biggest challengers, William Sutherland and Carl Meece, have barely gotten their campaigns off the ground.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Florida-3 – Corrine Brown/Democrat – Along with NC-12, PA-12, and NY-28, this district is about as hideous a gerrymander as you’ll see on the national House map, stringing together the most democratic parts of Jacksonville, Gainesville, and Orlando.  It’s meant to be a democratic vote sink with it’s purpose hiding behind the VRA.  It’s safe for Brown at present, but god does it need to be re-designed in the 2010 redistricting.

District PVI – D+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Florida-4 – Ander Crenshaw/Republican – This north Florida district is very similar to the 1st district, rural, white, and very republican.  

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-5 – Ginny Brown-Waite/Republican – Brown-Waite is one of the most popular politicians in the state of Florida, and is widely beloved in her district.  The 2008 race was her closest election since her initial win in 2002, but she still won by 23%.  It’s doubtful any democrat could take a run at her.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-6 – Cliff Stearns/Republican – This is another hideously drawn district.  Looking at the map it looks as though it is spooning with the neighboring 3rd.  As you would expect, it is the yin to the 3rd’s yang, as it is a very republican district.  In this environment it would be hard to imagine the Dems picking this one up.

District PVI – R+10

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-7 – John Mica/Republican – This district comprises a lot of Florida’s northeastern coast between Jacksonville and Daytona Beach.  Honestly I’m surprised that this district is not overwhelmingly republican, Obama only lost by 7% here in 2008.  That being said, Mica won re-election by 24% in 2008, making it very difficult to believe that this seat will be in play this time around.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-8 – Alan Grayson/Democrat – Finally!  After 28 districts of boredom, we reach a competitive district, potentially one of the most competitive in the nation.  The 8th is a gerrymandered (yup, what else is new) central Florida district that comprises a good portion of the Orlando metro area.  It is a swing district that is trending leftward.  Grayson is perhaps the biggest loudmouth in the democratic house caucus, famous for his “don’t get sick, die quickly” rant about republican health care agenda.  Much like Joe Wilson last year and Michelle Bachmann in 2008, there’s big a large influx of money into this race, but luckily for Grayson, most of it has been on his side since the Republicans amazingly haven’t been able to find a candidate.  Armando Gutierrez was the leading fundraiser on the R side but he dropped out earlier this month, leaving a wide open field paced by state representative Kurt Kelly and businessman Bruce Odonoghue.  Florida’s late primary date isn’t going to give the Repubs much time to get behind their eventual candidate, either. There are some that think because of his bullish nature that generic R could beat Grayson and his 1.45 million cash on hand, but I don’t.  Not in a city like Orlando that is trending bluer and bluer by the day.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Florida-9 – Gus Bilirakis/Republican – Another oddly shaped district, this one covers the area north of Tampa/St Petersburg, with Clearwater/Dunedin as it’s main population center.  Even though Obama came with 5% of McCain in this pink-colored district, Bilirakis cruised to re-election by 25%.  I think he’s in really good shape here.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-10 – Bill Young/Republican – The longest-serving member of the Republican house caucus, Bill Young has routinely run up big margins in this Pinellas peninsula district (hey, a compact district in Florida, no way!).  But with him being somewhat non-committal about running for re-election this cycle, this district has some life to it.  The Democrats have also served notice by finding a very strong candidate in state senator Charlie Justice.  Having not faced a real campaign in years, Young could struggle against the young and articulate Justice.  The problem for Justice is that his fundraising hasn’t been good, only 212k raised thus far, but it does give him the money advantage this cycle over Young.  Ultimately I think if Young runs he’ll probably win, but if he retires, the race moves to toss up or possibly even leans dem.  For that reason I’ll stay the middle of those two outcomes for now.

District PVI – R+1

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Florida-11 – Kathy Castor/Democrat – Castor’s district is essentially a democratic vote sink in the Tampa/St Petersburg area, and while it’s not hugely democratic to the point where a republican can’t win, there isn’t much in the way of Republican opposition here to make this interesting.

District PVI – D+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Florida-12 – Open/Republican – This seat is open because of Adam Putnam running for Florida Agricultural Commissioner, and it’s a potential pickup opportunity for the democrats.  This district is pink in color, but took a hard swing to the left in 2008, where McCain edged out Obama 50-49.  The democrats also have a very solid candidate in Polk County elections supervisor Lori Edwards.  The republicans counter with their own strong candidate, former state representative Dennis Ross.  Currently, Ross leads the fundraising game 456k to 176k, so fundraising has been a problem for Edwards.  That’s the one thing that gives the Repubs the edge.  I have a feeling that this could be a much more hotly contested district than most pundits expect.  FWIW, I do remember one poll earlier showing Edwards doing well.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Florida-13 – Vern Buchanan/Republican – Buchanan just barely held off Christine Jennings in 2006 by less than 400 votes to win an open seat election here.  The outcome was disputed, and perhaps voters thought of Jennings as a sore loser, because he crushed her by 18% in the 2008 rematch.  It appears that Buchanan has weathered the storm, because his only opposition is Bradenton city councilman James Golden.  State representative Keith Fitzgerald is the democrats hoped-for #1 recruit but it appears that he is out.  

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-14 – Connie Mack/Republican – This southwest Florida district, centered on Fort Myers, is a very conservative part of south Florida.  Mack should be fine here.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-15 – Bill Posey/Republican – Posey won the 15th district’s seat in a 2008 open seat race, winning by 12% over democratic candidate Stephen Blythe.  That’s a big overperformance from the top of the ticket, where McCain struggled and barely beat Obama 51-48.  Given this, the democrats would need a really strong candidate to have a shot, and honestly, they’ve had a bit of a recruiting failure here.  Cape Canaveral councilwoman Shannon Roberts is all they’ve got.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-16 – Tom Rooney/Republican – This seat is interesting because it has turned over the last two election cycles on account of representatives not being able to keep their pants on.  So far, Rooney hasn’t had that problem, but it’ll be interesting to see how he fares against a non-scandalized combatant.  The democrats were hoping for Dave Aronberg to run for this seat, but he decided to run for Attorney General instead, so Chris Craft is the nominee.  Rooney so far has a huge advantage in fundraising, by a count of 733k to 102k.  I’m not optimistic that this district is going to turn over.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-17 – Open/Democrat – This seat is open as Kendrick Meek is running for the Senate.  The 17th, which centers on downtown Miami, is the most Democratic district in Florida and one of the most liberal in the nation.  The winner of the Dem primary will win the seat easily.

District PVI – D+34

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Florida-18 – Ileana Ros-Lehtinen/Republican – This district is the southernmost in the continental United States, stretching from south Miami to Key West.  Ileana is one of three Cuban American republicans in south Florida, and she is very well entrenched, to the point where she defeated Annette Taddeo by 15% in 2008 while Obama was busy pulling a 51-48 upset over McCain here.  Given that and the fact that she is generally well liked by most, I really don’t see her going down in 2010.  

District PVI – R+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-19 – Open/Democrat – There is a special election for this seat being held on April 13 because of Robert Wexler’s departure.  Democrat Ted Deutsch is heavily favored to win over Republican Edward Lynch.  I have to figure that there won’t be much activity in this seat in November unless somehow the Republican were to pull an upset, then the Dems would be chomping at the bit to get it back.

District PVI – D+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Florida-20Debbie Wasserman-Schulz/Democrat – This seat is very democratic in nature, and DWS is a very popular incumbent who went unopposed in 2008.  Nothing to see here.

District PVI – D+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Florida-21Mario Diaz-Balart/Republican – I know that Diaz-Balart isn’t technically the incumbent here, his brother is, but with the recent seat switch in the works and Mario’s incumbency in the 25th, he might as well be.  This is a once republican district turned into more of a swing-ish area, as McCain held on for a 51-49 win over Obama in 2008, but with only the relatively unknown William Sanchez in the race for the democrats, a pickup is extremely unlikely.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Florida-22 – Ron Klein/Democrat – This district, which is drawn as a republican vote sink in Palm Beach and Broward counties, was clearly drawn in the hopes of squeezing a republican representative out of a democratic zone.  Ron Klein, the democratic incumbent, took out Allen West 54-45 in 2008, but West is seeking a rematch under a better political environment this time.  He only underperformed McCain by a few points (Obama won 52-47) and he’s fundraising well at 1.22 million to Klein’s 1.4 million, so this is going to be a huge battleground.  Everybody talks about FL-8 and Grayson and maybe FL-24 and Kosmas, but honestly, I think this race is flying way under the radar, and is actually the Repubs’ best chance at a pickup in the Sunshine State.  It helps to actually have a candidate.

District PVI – D+1

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Dem Hold

Florida-23 – Alcee Hastings/Democrat – This is the remainder of Palm Beach and other surrounding counties not taken in by FL-22.  In other words, it’s hugely democratic.  Nothing for Hastings to worry about.  

District PVI – D+28

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Florida-24 – Suzanne Kosmas/Democrat – The 24th is a district centered around Daytona Beach, and should be a big republican target.  But again, just like in the 8th and several other districts in the south with vulnerable democrats, they’ve had a very hard time on the recruiting front.  In this case they have a divisive primary coming as well. Winter Park commissioner Karen Dieble and state representative Sandy Hood are the leaders among a very crowded primary field.  Making things tougher on the Repubs is that Kosmas is on a fundraising tear, having received 1.1 million thus far.  Unless one of the challengers can win and consolidate support and fundraising dollars quickly following Florida’s late primary date, I think Kosmas is in great shape for a retention.  

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Florida-25 – Open/Republican – Now this is an open seat!  Mario Diaz-Balart’s announcement that he is moving over to the 21st has put this once republican, now more swing-ish seat into play.  McCain edged Obama by 1% in the presidential vote in 2008, meaning that anything is possible.  So far, it appears that state representative David Rivera and state senate majority leader Alex Diaz de la Portilla are the leading republican candidates.  On the democratic side, state representative Luis Rivera is in, though most are waiting on two other possibilities, one being 2008 candidate Joe Garcia, who held Diaz-Balart to a 6% win in 2008, and the other being former Miami mayor Manny Diaz.  Either one of them would be very strong, and would move this seat into the toss up category.  With the primaries falling late in Florida, a lot will depend on who gets in and who triumphs in the parties’ respective primaries.  One thing I do know however, is that CQ and Cook are both out of their minds keeping this one at Safe R.  Seriously, what are they thinking?

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Leans R

Prediction – Moderate Rep Hold

Regional Recap – Well, not much of a recap here, because unlike the first three regions, right now, I don’t see any seats turning over on either side.  So the combined total remains Republican +8 through four regions.  

Next stop…The Eastern Great Lakes

By what margin will Bob Shamansky win?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

StephenCLE’s 2010 House Predictions – Part 3

StephenCLE’s House Predictions Part 3 – The Upper South

Welcome to the third installment of my 2010 baseline predictions for the US House of Representatives.  In this section, I will overview all the seats in the Upper South region, consisting of Virginia, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, and North Carolina.  This region, in terms of politics, has undergone a lot of change in recent times, with the areas east of the Appalachians turning blue and those in the mountains and west turning red.  It’s hard to call this region solidly in the camp of one side or the other.

Current region breakdown – 42 seats (23 Dem, 19 Rep)

Virginia-1 – Rob Wittman/Republican – Wittman won his 2008 re-election by 15%, which was actually his first re-election since he was initially voted in via a 2007 special election.  That was better than McCain, who only beat Obama by 3.  Surprisingly, the Democrats have two candidates in the race worth noting, Scott Robinson and Krystal Ball (which is a phenomenal candidate name!).  Wittman has raised 597k for his re-election, compared to 386k for Ball and 270k for Robinson.  It’s hard to imagine either democrat winning here unless Wittman blunders on the campaign trail, but this seat has the potential to be a sleeper, kind of like Maine-1.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Virginia-2 – Glenn Nye/Democrat – This seat is going to be a battleground for sure.  Glenn Nye won this seat in his first run for elected office in 2008, defeating conservative firebrand Thelma Drake by 5%.  Obama also carried the district but only be a scant 2%.  The Republican primary is shaping up to be a battle.  The frontrunner is business owner Scott Rigell, who has raised 666k thus far.  He faces competition from Ben Loyola and Bert Mizusawa though, who are both over 200k raised as well.  Nye himself has raised 1.09 million, and certainly has the campaigning skills to back it up in the face of a bad national environment.  It’s going to be a fight no matter how the Republican primary shakes out.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (6th overall)

Total Pickup Counter – Rep +4

Virginia-3 – Bobby Scott/Democrat – The 3rd is the most democratic district in Virginia, and Scott won uncontested in 2008.  He’s safe.

District PVI – D+20

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Virginia-4 – Randy Forbes/Republican – The 4th district was one of the shockers of the nation in the 2008 presidential election, as Obama beat McCain 50-49 in this conservative district. Forbes, the entrenched incumbent, defeated Andrea Miller by 19% in 2008, and with her being the only democrat in the field for 2010, it looks like a rematch is coming.  In other words, this looks like a sure retention.

District PVI – R+4

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Virginia-5 – Tom Perriello/Democrat – Perriello is perhaps one of the most vulnerable democrats in the entire country heading into 2010.  He won by less than 1% over Virgil Goode, in a district where Obama fell by 3% against John McCain.  The good news for Perriello is that his fundraising has topped 1 million, and the Republican primary looks to be a heated affair between James McKelvey, Lawrence Verga, and Robert Hurt.  McKelvey is arguably the favorite, having received over 501k in donations thus far.  Perriello’s problem goes far beyond money though, because unlike Nye and some other democrats, Perriello has voted for virtually all major democratic legislation this session, including health care and cap-n-trade.  That’s going to make things really difficult for him.  There’s no doubt the base will turn out to Perriello to the bitter end, I just wonder if that base is big enough.

District PVI – R+5  

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup (7th overall)

Total Pickup Count – Rep +5

Virginia-6 – Robert Goodlatte/Republican – This district is very conservative in nature, and includes a lot of the Appalachian west of the state.  Goodlatte doesn’t have any opposition yet, and won’t have any trouble holding this seat.

District PVI – R+12

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Virginia-7 – Eric Cantor/Republican – In this mostly republican district, the well established Cantor has only 2008 Dem candidate Anita Hartke to worry about.  In other words, he ain’t worrying too much.

District PVI – R+7

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Virginia-8 – James Moran/Democrat – Unlike a lot of democrats that have gotten caught up in Virginia’s sudden turn back to the right in 2009/10, Moran doesn’t have to lose sleep over his seat, which is heavily Democratic.  There are three republicans running in the primary but they all have a very steep climb in a district that went 69-30 for Obama.  

District PVI – D+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Virginia-9 Rick Boucher/Democrat – This has turned into a very tough region for Democrats, the Appalachian southwest of the state, but Boucher is a fairly entrenched incumbent.  He actually ran unopposed in 2008, but this time he won’t be so lucky as the Repubs will look to take advantage of the district’s rightward swing.  So far they only have 2 undistinguished names in the Republican primary, but the 2000-lb elephant in the room is Terry Kilgore, who may or may not run.  If he does run, Boucher’s in a lot of trouble.  If he doesn’t, then he’s probably going to win.  Thus, I’ll take the middle road for now.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Virginia-10 – Frank Wolf/Republican – In many ways this exurban DC northern Virginia district is the opposite of VA-9, a district that is rapidly turning blue but has an entrenched Republican incumbent.  Wolf rose above the blue tide in 2008 and netted 60% of the vote, a very impressive statement.  The Dems would need somebody of Mark Warner’s popularity to beat him in this environment.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Virginia-11 – Gerry Connolly/Democrat – This district, in the heart of “NoVA”, was once solidly Republican but has taken an extreme swing to the left in the past decade, as Obama cleaned up by 15% in 2008.  The blue wave helped Connolly, who picked up the open seat here by 11%.  That’s not overwhelming strength, but the good news for Connolly is, unlike some other districts in the state, the Republican field here is really unsettled.  2008 candidate Keith Fimian, a businessman, is running again, but against him are state senator Tim Hugo, former CIA officer Rocky Johnson, and Fairfax County commissioner Pat Herrity.  None of these are fundraising giants either, so between that and the district’s blue-ing trend, I think Connolly is in very good shape.

District PVI – D+2

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

West Virginia-1 – Alan Mollohan/Democrat – We move now into West Virginia, a state that is a bit of a political enigma.  The state is trending rapidly to the right at the federal level, but is still quite democratic locally.  Mollohan is a long entrenched incumbent, who was unopposed in 2008, but he has had to face questions about his ethics following a string of earmarks to non-profit organizations that he may have been close with.  He’s been cleared of charges, but the Repubs are going after him anyway.  Business executive David McKinley is the favorite of the party, but there are six candidates vying for the Republican primary.  It remains to be seen whether Mollohan still has the ability to really campaign, as he hasn’t had to do it in quite a while.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

West Virginia-2 – Shelley Capito/Republican – Capito appeared vulnerable in 2008 but defeated her democratic challenger by a wider than expected margin.  Given the rightward swing of the state, it’s hard to imagine the Dems contending here.

District PVI – R+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

West Virginia-3 – Nick Rahall/Democrat – Rahall is a very entrenched incumbent, and unlike Mollohan, doesn’t seem to have any internal issues that might make him vulnerable.  Despite the conservatism of the district, this one should be a slam dunk.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Kentucky-1 – Ed Whitfield/Republican – Whitfield is well entrenched, and this part of Kentucky, the western part of the state, is intensely republican.  Easy hold.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Kentucky-2 – Brett Guthrie/Republican – Guthrie had to gut out a close 5% open seat race in 2008 against David Boswell, which was surprising considering that McCain obliterated Obama by 23% in KY-2, which runs over west-central Kentucky.  It is a very conservative district, but Guthrie’s sizeable underperformance against the top of the ticket makes me wonder if he may have some individual weakness.  08 Dem candidate Boswell is undecided at present, but another candidate, state representative Edward Marksberry has recently declared, so to some extent this seat will be competitive.  A pickup is very unlikely though.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Likely R

Prediction – Strong Rep Hold

Kentucky-3 – John Yarmuth/Democrat – This is the lone Dem-leaning district in Kentucky, which pretty much centers around greater Louisville.  Yarmuth defeated incumbent Anne Northup by 2 points in 2006, then crushed her by 20 in the rematch.  His fundraising has been very good so far (665k), and shows that expects a competitive race even though it may not come.  There are five repubs running in the primary, but none are all that exceptional.  

District PVI – D+2

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Strong Dem Hold

Kentucky-4 – Geoff Davis/Republican – This northern Kentucky district, like many in this state, is intensely conservative in nature.  Davis is well entrenched, and should have no problem.

District PVI – R+14

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Kentucky-5 – Harold Rogers/Republican – Rogers ran unopposed in 2008, and may do so again in 2010.  Even if there is a challenge here, it won’t get very far in this republican bastion.

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold  

Kentucky-6 – Ben Chandler/Democrat – This is a fairly hostile seat outside of the liberal haven of Lexington, which is where I believe Chandler hails from.  This is a district that supported McCain by a 55-43 count, but Chandler won by 29% over his 2008 opponent, suggesting that he has dug himself into the district pretty deep.  That being said, he has a pretty serious opponent in 2008, attorney Andy Barr, who has raised over 300k thus far.  Chandler has raised almost twice that however.  The partisan lean of this district and the environment has me nervous about this district, but like Alan Mollohan in WV-1, it seems Chandler will be awfully hard to dislodge.

District PVI – R+9

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

Tennessee-1 – Phil Roe/Republican – This is one of the most Republican districts in the country, and Roe won an open seat race here in 2008 by 47%.  Forgettaboutit.

District PVI – R+21

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Tennessee-2 – John Duncan/Republican – This district is also intensely conservative, and Duncan has been around since the 80s.  I think we can write this one off too.  Dems are pretty much DOA in eastern TN.

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Tennessee-3 – Open/Republican – The Democrats appeared to have small chance at pulling off an upset here in the dark red 3rd when former state insurance commissioner Paula Flowers jumped in.  With a fractured Republican primary field, the chance of an injured survivor taking on Flowers made this district one to watch.  But now she’s dropped out due to family concerns, and without her, the Dems don’t even have a candidate.  Shame, but really, it wasn’t likely she was going to win anyway in this environment.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Tennessee-4 – Lincoln Davis/Democrat – Now here is another case of a democratic incumbent holding onto a hostile district.  Lincoln Davis was able to defeat his republican opponent by 20% in 2008, but the bottom totally fell out in the presidential race, as Obama was demolished by McCain by 30%.  For a district that nearly voted for Gore in 2000, that’s a brutal drop.  The question is can the Repubs take advantage of that drop.  Four republicans are running in the primary, and the most notable of them are physician Scott Desjarlais and attorney Jack Bailey.  Davis’s fundraising this cycle, just 400k, is somewhat underwhelming for an incumbent in a district like this.  Maybe I’m just very pessimistic on this one, but I think unless the Republican primary is a brutal and bloody affair, Davis is going down because this district has moved out from under him very quickly.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Moderate Rep Pickup

Total Pickup Count – Rep +6

Tennessee-5 – Jim Cooper/Democrat – Cooper had no trouble winning re-election in 2008, winning by 34% while Obama defeated McCain by 13%.  As far as I know the Repubs don’t have much in the way of opposition here, just some no-namers in the primary field.  That won’t get it done here.

District PVI – D+3

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Tennessee-6 – Open/Democrat – This is, without question, the worst open seat dilemma the Democrats are facing in the 2010 House cycle.  Bart Gordon’s decision to pack his bags has really left the Dems in a bind in a very republican district.  In fact, the situation is worse considering that three republican candidates, Diane Black, Lou Ann Zelenik, and Jim Tracy have already raised 150k or more for their runs at the seat.  The Democrats don’t even have a confirmed candidate yet.  This situation, along with the huge republican lean of the district and the environment tells me we have no shot here.

District PVI – R+13

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Pickup

Total Pickup Count – Rep +7

Tennessee-7 – Marsha Blackburn/Republican – Blackburn is very safe in this district, which amounts to a republican vote sink in western Tennessee.

District PVI – R+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

Tennessee-8 – Open/Democratic – Another R-leaning open seat for the Dems.  This is precisely why Tennessee is probably the worst state in the nation going into 2010 for Team Blue.  This seat supported McCain by a 13% margin in 2008, and the seat has drifted away from democrats in general, but not as much as TN-4 or TN-6.  Surprisingly, it appears that both sides have agreed on a candidate already, as farmer Stephen Fincher has settled in well ahead of the Republican primary field.  On the Dem side, state senator Roy Herron is the guy, as he stepped down from a run at the governorship to run here in TN-8.  Both have raised approximately 680k thus far, so we’re looking at a toss-up battle at the moment.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Toss Up

Prediction – Weak Rep Pickup

Total Pickup Count – Rep +8

Tennessee-9 – Steve Cohen/Democratic – Finally we hit the Memphis-based 9th, the only truly safe D seat in Tennessee and also the only VRA seat in the state.  Cohen is being primaried by Willie Herenton but it’s doubtful that he’ll lose that.  Even if the sullied Herenton were to win, it’s unlikely the Repubs would be able to mount much of a challenge.  

District PVI – D+23

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-1 – George Butterfield/Democrat – We move now into North Carolina, a state that has moved in the blue direction recently.  This district, in the northeastern part of the state, is essentially a racial gerrymander to comply with the VRA.  That makes the seat very democratic, and while the republicans have a half decent candidate in insurance executive Ashley Woolard, it’s not likely that she’ll make much headway against Butterfield.

District PVI – D+9

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-2 – Bob Etheridge/Democrat – This district is actually a swing battleground, but you’d never know it watching Etheridge score 67% of the vote in 2008.  Obama did win, but only by 5%.  Ultimately the Republican challenge here doesn’t look like much anyway.  

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-3 – Walter Jones/Republican – This is the other racially gerrymandered district in the northeast part of the state, and this one has all the white people in it.  Seeing as we’re in the south, I don’t think I need to go much further than that.  

District PVI – R+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

North Carolina-4 – David Price/Democrat – The Raleigh-Durham based 4th is the most democratic of all parts of the state, well, at least of those that occur naturally.  Price isn’t likely to be challenged much here.

District PVI – D+8

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-5 – Virginia Foxx/Republican – The 5th, which encompasses Appalachian territory in the northwest corner of the state, is solidly republican.  Even a firebrand like Foxx can pretty much breathe easily in a district like this.

District PVI – R+15

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

North Carolina-6 – Howard Coble/Republican – This is one of the most republican districts in the nation, which isn’t surprising given that some of the districts around it are racially gerrymandered.  No chance here.

District PVI – R+18

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

North Carolina-7 – Mike McIntyre/Democrat – Here’s a rarity, a democrat representing a republican-leaning district in the south that has virtually no competition for re-election.  2008 Repub candidate Will Breazeale is the only challenger, and he lost by 37% last time around.

District PVI – R+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-8 – Larry Kissell/Democrat – This is an intriguing seat to predict.  Kissell won this seat by 11% in 2008 while Obama scored a 5% win over McCain.  His win followed a 2006 campaign that was impressive though he fell short.  It’s notable that he performed well in both years despite not being a great fundraiser, which is good because his fundraising numbers haven’t been all that great so far.  More good news, the Republican field is fractured big time, with 7 candidates in the race.  I think whoever emerges on the Repub side could raise funds and have a shot at this, but their odds aren’t as good as the NRCC might think.

District PVI – R+2

Stephen’s Rating – Leans D

Prediction – Moderate Dem Hold

North Carolina-9 – Susan Myrick/Republican – In this affluent, suburban Charlotte district, Sue Myrick is pretty well entrenched and she’s got the back of a republican lean.  The Dems aren’t likely to challenge this seat this cycle but it should be noted that the whole Charlotte area is trending blue fairly rapidly.  If NC-12 is broken up in the next redistricting (and it SHOULD be) Myrick could be in trouble.

District PVI – R+11

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

North Carolina-10 – Patrick McHenry/Republican – This seat isn’t much to see, McHenry’s a very conservative fellow in a very conservative district.  

District PVI – R+17

Stephen’s Rating – Solid R

Prediction – Solid Rep Hold

North Carolina-11 – Heath Shuler/Democrat – This Appalachian district is somewhat conservative in nature, though not quite as much as the neighboring 5th and 10th.  Shuler has projected a centrist profile for the most part, and he’s well liked in the district.  Better yet, the Republicans don’t have a top tier candidate to face him, and Shuler has already banked 586k, over 500k more than any of his challengers.  Right now it’s hard for me to see him losing.  Still, as with just about any R-leaning district in the south, I can’t completely rule it out.

District PVI – R+6

Stephen’s Rating – Likely D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-12 – Mel Watt/Democrat – Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the most hideous gerrymander in America.  It’s a safe dem district for sure, and Watt will have no trouble retaining the seat, but could they try to make that less of an eyesore in redistricting?  Please??

District PVI – D+16

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

North Carolina-13 – Brad Miller/Democrat – This is a fairly democratic district in north central NC, and Miller is fairly well established.  I don’t see a challenger in the field that could make this district interesting in 2010.

District PVI – D+5

Stephen’s Rating – Solid D

Prediction – Solid Dem Hold

Region Recap – The Upper South is going to be one of the toughest regions for the Democrats in 2010, of that I am sure.  Open seats in Tennessee are partly responsible for that indigestion.  Overall, I see the Dems losing 5 seats and picking up none, giving the Republicans 10 total pickups to the Democrats’ 2.

Current region breakdown – 23 Dem, 19 Rep

Projected breakdown after 2010 – 24 Rep, 18 Dem

Next stop…The South Atlantic